16. Is the narration correct that after the demise of the Holy Prophet (saw), when Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddiq (ra) became Khalifa, Hazrat Ali (ra) did not take the Bai’at for six months? And if so, what was the reason for this delay?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 6 December 2002
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Is the narration correct that after the demise of the Holy Prophet (saw), when Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddiq (ra) became Khalifa, Hazrat Ali (ra) did not take the Bai’at for six months? And if so, what was the reason for this delay?
I had once said that it is not correct, but on reflection: Hazrat Ali (ra) took the Bai’at after one month; that is quite right. But the narration attached to it is false, namely that Hazrat Abu Bakr sent Hazrat Ali the message that if he did not take the Bai’at he would burn his house. That is completely false and fabricated by the Shias. The reason is that the Holy Prophet (saw) did not give any human the right to burn with fire, and repeatedly clarified that no human has that right. How could Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddiq (ra), a true devotee of the Holy Prophet (saw), send such a message to Hazrat Ali? The Shias fabricated it to prove that Hazrat Ali was coerced. But therein lies their defeat: Hazrat Ali was considered the bravest; wherever the Holy Prophet (saw) was surrounded by danger, Hazrat Ali stepped forward and faced it. Such a brave Ali afraid of such a small thing? That is against his dignity. So it is correct that he took the Bai’at after some time. Perhaps there was some hesitation in his heart – Allah knows best. But when he took the Bai’at, he did so sincerely and fully and was always in the forefront. Then he took the Bai’at of the next Khalifa and the one after. The Shias have needlessly fabricated something against Hazrat Ali.