8. When the Holy Prophet (saw) visited the grave of his mother, he said to the Companions: Allah has permitted me to visit her grave but has not permitted me to pray for her. What does this mean? This is a hadith, with reference to Muslim and Ibn Majah.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 13 December 2002

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: When the Holy Prophet (saw) visited the grave of his mother, he said to the Companions: Allah has permitted me to visit her grave but has not permitted me to pray for her. What does this mean? This is a hadith, with reference to Muslim and Ibn Majah.

I do not trust this hadith. For the Holy Prophet (saw) teaches us in the prayer [the supplication for the parents], and the mother is included in it. How can it be that he instructs us to pray daily in the prayer for the parents and himself not [be allowed to] pray for his mother? Therefore there appears to be a contradiction in these hadiths.

10 of 10 left today