3. My name is Tariq Mahmood and I come from the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat Graz. I have two questions. First: if one has offered the Maghrib prayer on time but without congregation, and then goes to the mosque at Isha time and finds the Maghrib prayer being offered in congregation, it is said one should join it. Why is preference not given to the Maghrib offered without congregation, even though it was offered on time according to the commandment of the Holy Qur’an?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 10 January 2003

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: My name is Tariq Mahmood and I come from the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat Graz. I have two questions. First: if one has offered the Maghrib prayer on time but without congregation, and then goes to the mosque at Isha time and finds the Maghrib prayer being offered in congregation, it is said one should join it. Why is preference not given to the Maghrib offered without congregation, even though it was offered on time according to the commandment of the Holy Qur’an?

Yes, I say preference should be given to it, because it was offered on time. ‘Prayer is enjoined on the believers at fixed times.’ If it was offered on time, that is much better, and then there is no need to repeat it. If one then goes and prays combined with the Imam, one would be combining and the Sunnahs would be dropped; that is also not permissible. Offer the prayers on time; separately is correct, even if they are offered without congregation.

10 of 10 left today