10. My second question: how did Hazrat Jonah (as) remain alive in the belly of the fish?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 10 January 2003

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: My second question: how did Hazrat Jonah (as) remain alive in the belly of the fish?

As to how Hazrat Jonah (as) remained alive – scientists have now proven in the present age that a sailor went into the belly of a fish and remained alive in it for twenty-four hours. And about Hazrat Jonah it is not even said that he remained there for twenty-four hours. In fact my own view is that when the fish swallowed Hazrat Jonah, his leg got stuck in its mouth or throat, which caused irritation, and after some time it vomited him out. ‘In the belly of the fish’ means he went into its mouth and disappeared. This is my view as a possibility. But even if he went into the belly, then, as I said, scientists have proven that a person can remain alive in a fish's belly for quite a long time; twenty-four hours is reported. Sailors were hunting the fish from a ship. The fish struck the boat of some sailors with its tail and the boat capsized. Some fled and took refuge on the ship, and the fish swallowed two men. One of them was taken out dead and one alive. So a person remaining alive in the belly of a fish is proven even in the present age.

10 of 10 left today