Correspondence with Shaikh Muhammad Husain Batalawi

The Mirror of the Excellences of Islam, Part 10

What more should I say? I shall—God willing—print and publish this letter, and I have no need to hold any meeting in Batala to test this prophecy. It would be appropriate that you should also publish this letter of mine in Isha‘at-us-Sunnah and should also state what prevents you now from accepting my claim. The fair-minded people will themselves judge whether your objections are valid or not.

To reiterate, Allah, glorified be His eminence, knows very well that I am truthful in my claim and I am neither an impostor, nor a dajjal [deceiver] nor an arch-liar.

There was already no shortage of arch-liars, dajjals, and impostors during this era that God Almighty—instead of sending a Mujaddid [Reformer] ordained by Him at the beginning of the century—should have set up a dajjal to add to the discord and corruption. Nevertheless, what remedy can I offer to those who fail to understand the truth and make no effort to discover the truth of the matter; instead, they hasten to make fatwas of takfir [alleging disbelief ].

I am in pain like one attending to a dear one who is sick, and deeply grieved for these unmindful people and pray that, ‘O Lord of Power and Glory! O Guide who shows the right path! Open the eyes of these people; and bestow sight upon them Yourself and send down revelation of truth and righteousness upon their hearts Yourself.’

I am sure that my supplications will not be in vain, for I am from Him and call the people towards Him. It is true that if I am not from Him and I am an impostor, He will destroy me with a severe chastisement because He never bestows such honour upon an impostor as He bestows upon a truthful claimant. The one prophecy that I have put before you, which you have decided to rely upon to determine my truth or falsehood, is alone sufficient evidence for the recognition of my truth or falsehood, for it can never be that God Almighty should help a liar and an impostor. But together with this, I also affirm that in connection with this prophecy, there are two other prophecies that I have already published in the poster dated 10 July 1888. They state that God Almighty will make that woman a widow and will return her to me.

Now, just look at this with justice, for no man can be sure of his own life, nor can he make a claim regarding the life of another that that person would remain alive till such and such a time, or that that person would die by such and such a time. However, in this prophecy of mine there is not one, but six claims: First, my surviving until the time of nikah [marriage]; Second, the certain survival of the father of the girl until the time of nikah; Third, the passing away of the father soon after the nikah, not exceeding three years; Fourth, the passing away of her husband within two and a half years; Fifth, survival of the girl until the time of her nikah with me; and lastly, Sixth, setting aside all the customs which she should otherwise have observed as a widow, her marrying me in spite of the opposition of her relatives. Now, can you say honestly that all these things are within the control of man? Think about it with due deliberation: Can such a prophecy, upon being fulfilled, be said to have been the work of man?

Again, if you are not satisfied with that part of the prophecy which relates to the father of the girl and which was fulfilled on 30 September 1892, you should, in accordance with your promise, publish a notice in Isha‘at-us-Sunnah that, if the other prophecies are also fulfilled, you will repent of your false misgivings and will regard me as a true claimant. You should also, with all fear of God, declare that at least one of the prophecies has been fulfilled. But if the fulfilment of this prophecy does not have much impact upon your heart, you should at the very least adopt silence until the time when the prophecy runs through its final stage. When one part of the prophecy has been fulfilled, there should arise at least some fear in your heart. You are of course expecting my destruction and waiting for the days of my disgrace, but God Almighty is manifesting Signs in support of the truth of my claim. If you still do not accept, I cannot coerce you, but bear in mind that a man in the early stages of denial may be excused on the grounds of there being some doubt, but after he has seen the Signs, he can never be excused.

Was the prophecy which has been fulfilled such a coincidental event of which God Almighty was completely oblivious? Did this prophecy in support of the claim of a dajjal come to be fulfilled in and of itself without the knowledge or will of God? Is it not true that the prophecy of a false claimant is never fulfilled? This is indeed what is taught by the Holy Qur’an and the Torah. If you possess any sense of justice and even an atom’s weight of righteousness, you should now hold your tongue;

[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]

—[Why would Allah punish you if you are grateful and believe? And peace be upon him who follows the guidance and does not behave with pride and denial].

Humbly Ghulam Ahmad, may Allah grant him forgiveness.

I reproduce below a letter from my dear Nawwab Sardar

Muhammad ‘Ali Khan. He wrote this letter at the suggestion of another seeker after truth.

Otherwise, the Nawwab Sahib himself entertains special love and sincerity towards my humble self and

supports this Movement with his heart and soul.

10 of 10 left today