Correspondence with Nawwab Muhammad Ali Khan
The Mirror of the Excellences of Islam, Part 4
For example, when the greatest among the Truthful, Hadrat Abu Bakr, may Allah be pleased with him, believed in the Holy Prophet, peace and the blessings of Allah be upon him, he did not demand a miracle. On being asked why he had believed in him, he replied that it had been proven to him that Muhammad, peace and the blessings of Allah be upon him, was Amin [the Trustworthy] and that he firmly believed that he [the Holy Prophet s (as)] had never spoken a lie about anyone, let alone that he should lie about God.
Similarly, each Companion—according to his personal inclinations—believed in the Holy Prophet, peace and the blessings of Allah be upon him, upon witnessing one or another of his moral excellences or teachings and taking that as a proof of his truth after minutely pondering over it. None of them had asked for a Sign. To make a distinction between truth and falsehood, it sufficed for them to know that the Holy Prophet, peace and the blessings of Allah be upon him, occupied the highest position in righteousness, was bold and steadfast in the proclamation of his mission, had brought a teaching that was clearer and purer than all other teachings, was a Light pure and simple, was incomparable in all praiseworthy morals, held the most glorious degree of God-given zeal, and the truth was manifestly evident upon his countenance. Thus, they were led to believe that he was truly commissioned by God Almighty.
It should not be taken to mean here that no miracles were manifested by the Holy Prophet, peace and the blessings of Allah be upon him. On the contrary, he showed more miracles than all the other Prophets, but the way of Allah has always been that, in the beginning, manifest miracles and Signs remain concealed, so that the sincerity of the believers and the denial of the deniers may be put to the test. This time [the beginning] is the time of trial, and no manifest Sign is shown in it. When, however, some pure-hearted people, through their profound vision, come to believe [in the Prophet], and only the common people lag, Signs begin to appear so that arguments of the [Prophet’s] truth may be brought home to them, and that, there may be a justification for the punishment to which they may be subjected. The only people who benefit from these Signs, however, are those who have already declared their beliefs, and there are very few who come to believe afterwards; for, they become hard-hearted by their persistent denial and cannot change their publicized opinions, and at long last, they go to Hell in the state of this very disbelief and denial.
It is my ardent heartfelt desire, and I pray, that you may come to understand the fact that the real meaning of faith requires the acceptance of the unseen. And that when a thing becomes completely manifest, or when a large part of it becomes manifest, acceptance of its existence does not constitute faith. For example, now that it is the time of day, if I were to say that I believe and declare my faith that it is now day and not night, what merit would there be in this faith of mine, and what superiority would I have over others by believing this? The first sign of a fortunate man is that he comes to understand this blessed concept of what it is that is called faith.
For all the people who went on opposing the Prophets ever since the beginning of the world, their failure to understand the real significance of faith was this very veil that was blinding their intellects. They thought that it was improper to accept a Prophet unless his Prophethood and teachings were manifested to them like other obvious and palpable phenomena. These foolish people did not stop to think how accepting what was already openly manifest could possibly constitute faith—such a thing would be like addition and subtraction, mathematics, a science and not faith. This indeed was the veil due to which Abu Jahl and Abu Lahab, etc., remained deprived of faith in the beginning. And then, when they became confirmed in their rejection and stubbornly insisted upon their hostile opinions, it was at that time that openly clear Signs of the truth of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, were made manifest; so, at that time these people said it was now better for them to die than to believe.
In short, it is the people of good fortune who recognize the truthfulness of a true claimant through the use of their profound insight, and to demand a Sign is the most wretched habit of evil people, which has caused tens of millions of people—the deniers of Prophets—to be flung into the fire of Hell. God Almighty does not change His practice. As He has stated, in His view, only the faith of such is considered to be faith, who do not show much obstinacy, and who, upon seeing significant pointers and evidence of his truthfulness, accept the truthful one. For them, the speech of that truthful person, his righteousness, his perseverance, and his very countenance, testify to his truthfulness. Blessed are those who are gifted with the intellect to recognize the worth of men.
Moreover, testing a follower of the Principal Prophet—who believes in his commandments and the Book of Allah—in the manner of testing a Prophet, amounts to a lack of understanding. This is so because the Prophets come to make people leave one faith and enter another, to substitute a new qiblah for the old one, to abrogate some laws and replace them with others, but there is no such revolutionary claim here. Here it is the same Islam as there was before, the same Prayers, the same Beloved Messenger, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, and that same Noble Book that was there before. No such thing from the original faith has to be abandoned that could be a cause for great surprise.
The claim of being the Promised Messiah would have been greatly burdensome and would have required diligent investigation if, along with it, there had been some addition or deletion—God forbid—in the religious commandments and if my practical condition had in any way differed from other Muslims, but there is nothing of this kind. The only controversy is the question of the life or death of the Messiah [ Jesus]. The claim of being the Promised Messiah is, in reality, just an offshoot of this very issue. This claim does not imply any practical revolution, nor does it adversely affect Islamic beliefs. So, does accepting this claim require some great miracle or marvel, such as have always been demanded by people from the claimants of Prophethood? For an honest and God-fearing person, can there be any difficulty in accepting the claim of a man who is a Muslim, who has been sent by God Almighty to support Islam, whose objectives are to show people the beauties of Islam, to prove Islam to be free from the objections raised by modern day philosophies, etc., and to bring the Muslims back to the love of Allah and the love of the Messenger?
Had the claim of being the Promised Messiah been accompanied by anything that had adverse effects to the commandments and beliefs of the Shariah, it would have been something horrible without a doubt. Nevertheless, one should consider which Islamic principle I have perverted by making this claim, and to which Islamic commandments I have added or subtracted even an iota. Yes, of course, I have interpreted a prophecy in the light of the meanings which God Almighty has disclosed to me at its appointed time. The Holy Qur’an bears testimony to the authenticity of that interpretation, as do the authentic ahadith. Therefore, I do not know why there is so much commotion and clamour!
A seeker after truth may, however, ask here: ‘What indications are present for accepting the claim of the Promised Messiah; for, there should be some such indications present to accept the truth of a claimant, especially in the present age which is full of dishonesty, deceit, and fraud, and in which false claims run rampant?’ In reply to this question, it is sufficient for me to say that the following matters should serve as signs and indicators to guide a seeker after truth:
1. First, that prophecy of the Messenger of Allah, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, which has attained the status of
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[tawatur ma‘nawi], the meaning of which is that God Almighty has promised that He will raise a man at the head of every century who will rejuvenate the Faith and, removing its weaknesses, will restore it to its original strength and ability. It was essential, therefore, that in accordance with this prophecy, a person would be raised by God Almighty in the beginning of this fourteenth century who would also come forward to rectify the prevailing evils. So, this humble one has been appointed exactly at the proper time. Hundreds of saintly people had testified beforehand based upon their revelations that the Mujaddid [Reformer] of the fourteenth century would be the Promised Messiah. And the authentic ahadith of the Holy Prophet emphatically proclaim that the Messiah would appear after the thirteenth century. So, is this claim by my humble self not made exactly at the right time and appropriate occasion? Is it possible that the word of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, should fail to materialise? I have proven that if it is assumed that the Promised Messiah was not born at the head of the fourteenth century, several prophecies of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, would prove to be erroneous and hundreds of saintly ones possessed of revelation would turn out to be liars.
2. [Second] Let it be considered also that when the ulema are asked who, except my humble self, has claimed to be the Mujaddid of the fourteenth century, and who has informed the people of having come from Allah and made the claim of being the recipient of revelation, and of having been appointed [by God], they are completely silent in responding to this question. They cannot present anyone who has made such a claim. And it should be remembered that the claim of being the Promised Messiah is not greater than the claim of being the recipient of revelation from Allah or of being a Mujaddid deriving his authority from Him.