Foreword – A stage within the broader spectrum of human civilisation
Muhammad The Liberator of Mankind, Part 2
Delving into the origins of slavery, Hazrat Mirza Bashirud-Din Mahmud Ahmad (ra) confronts the primal instincts of early human societies, where conflict resolution often necessitated violence and elimination. In this primal era, moral understandings were rudimentary, and survival instincts prevailed, shaping the contours of societal norms and ethical frameworks. As civilisation progressed, so too did the moral consciousness of humanity, leading to nuanced distinctions and evolving attitudes towards slavery and its justification.
Huzoor (ra) outlined the notion of slavery as defined by Islam and hailed it as the only religion that truly removed the idea of slavery that seeks to harm the world.
In light of these reflections, we are compelled to acknowledge the pivotal role of the Holy Prophets (as) in reshaping perceptions of slavery and advancing the cause of human liberation. True enlightenment, as discerned by the wise, resides in the teachings espoused by the Holy Prophets (as) , heralding a path towards genuine freedom and moral rectitude.
This essay was originally published in Urdu under the title
[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]
(Hurriyyat-e-Insaani Kaa Qaaim Karne Waalaa Rasool s (as)) and can be found in Volume XII of Anwaaraul-‘Uloom.
March 2025
Slavery is a profoundly complex issue, understood by very few and contemplated by even fewer. It is unfortunate that many fail to grasp its intricacies and form opinions without due reflection. Slavery cannot be universally condemned across all times and contexts, nor can it be abolished with a mere stroke of a pen. Those who seek to challenge entrenched societal norms or a long chain of historical precedents without principally addressing all the underlying complexities are destined to sow the seeds of their own failure. Even if their ac-
the Exalted, the Greatest, and we invoke His blessings on His Holy Messengers (as) . [Publishers]
[Publishers]
tions are momentarily accepted in the eyes of the world, there will come a time when their triumphs sour into failures, and their accomplishments lose their lustre.
A stage within the broader spectrum of human civilisation
If we calmly contemplate the issue of slavery, disregarding societal judgments and the opinions of those who prioritise superficialities over deeper meanings and realities, we will realise that slavery represents a stage within the broader spectrum of human civilisation. It is not something that can be entirely eradicated from our world.
What does slavery entail
It means that an individual is entirely submissive or has been coerced into subservience to another’s will. If absolute obedience to another’s whim is deemed unacceptable, then partial obedience is equally unacceptable. Partial slavery
Nevertheless, we can observe that many institutions in our society operate on a form of partial slavery. When a child attends school, they become subject to the school’s system without being consulted on its establishment, schedule, or selection of the teachers. Their deviation from the system may result in physical punishment. What sets apart the child from a slave? The distinction lies in the duration of their servitude: a slave remains enslaved around the clock, whereas the child experiences it for only five to six hours a day.
Alternatively, while the beneficiary of a slave’s labour gains from their services, a student’s efforts primarily benefit themselves. Nevertheless, the element of blindly adhering to authority and the [established] system which is a core aspect of slavery remains prevalent in the student’s experience.
Not all forms of slavery are objectionable Thus, from this viewpoint, we may conclude that both absolute slavery and servitude solely benefiting another are objectionable. However, if servitude is temporary and serves one’s own interests, it may not be objectionable. Nonetheless, it would be premature to categorically deem all forms of slavery objectionable.
Slavery imposed on children
However, it appears that there exists a form of slavery even more profound than that experienced by students, that is imposed on children by their parents. Until reaching maturity, every child is entirely subservient to their parents’ desires. Any earnings the child may acquire belong to the parents, and contributions to household chores are often taken for granted. The child holds no sway in household affairs and dutifully follows parental directives regarding food, drink, and attire. Their input regarding the foundation of their future is disregarded as their parents dictate and orchestrate their life trajectory. Consequently, every child, until the age of 10-12 years, remains entirely reliant on their parents, exhibiting no discernible difference from a slave in terms of obedience, conscience, possessions, or freedom of action.
Which form of slavery is objectionable If someone argues that parents treat their child with profound love and care, ensuring that the child mirrors their lifestyle by eating the same food and wearing similar attire; it’s worth noting that childhood is not necessarily a time of discernment. Without guidance, a child might inadvertently pose risks to themselves and others. The directives imposed by parents are typically for the child’s benefit. Hence to me, it seems that objections to slavery arise primarily when a distinction is made between the master and the slave, disregarding the benefits conferred upon the latter. In cases where a slave possesses wisdom and understanding, yet they still remain constrained into slavery, [objections may be warranted]. However, when considering the parent-child relationship, a form of servitude which does not involve confinement cannot be deemed inherently unjust.
Slavery in the dynamics of employment The third category of slavery manifests itself within [the dynamics] of employment. In certain instances, employees find themselves wholly dependent on others or submissive to them, yet this arrangement is not typically labelled as slavery, despite having no differences among the two. Some might argue that employees differ from slaves because they enter into such service willingly, whereas slaves are forcibly subjugated. However, this distinction is flawed, as it implies that selling oneself into slavery willingly would be permissible, [which is not the case]. If this is not permissible and an individual agrees to being enslaved, we must acknowledge that it still qualifies as slavery. Alternatively, one might argue that the ability of employees to terminate their employment distinguishes them from slaves. However, this rationale suggests that slavery is objectionable only when the enslaved cannot free themselves at will. And slavery, where the individual retains the option to free themselves, is not a genuine form of slavery.
Slavery is an integral part of human civilisation In any case, the aforementioned examples undeniably illustrate that slavery is an integral part of human civilisation, and its exact meaning remains ambiguous to our world. To delve deeper into this matter, we must come to terms with one of two possibilities. Firstly, we must acknowledge that slavery exists and will persist in our world, asserting that it is indispensable for societal functioning. Alternatively, we may adopt the perspective that, like many other aspects of human existence, slavery is acceptable in certain contexts and unacceptable in others, lawful under specific conditions and unlawful under others. Therefore, without appropriate constraints, we cannot outright condemn it nor can we fully sanction its practice.