Foreword – Muhammad as a Man

Muhammad The Great Exemplar, Part 7

We Ourself have sent down this Exhortation, and most surely We will be its Guardian—has been manifestly fulfilled. And the miracle of this text is such that no other scripture can point to its like.

As a second example, I will present another interpretation of this verse. The word [of God] is protected in various ways. Its content is safeguarded as are its meanings and outcomes. Having discussed the protection of its words, I will now move on to demonstrate the miracle of the safeguarding of its deeper meanings. It is entirely possible for the words of a scripture to be preserved in their original form, yet fail to be understood according to their actual intent. Let us cite here the Vedas. Though much of it is interpolated, there are still elements of its truth which have been preserved. Yet the language of its transmission is now so ancient and rare its true meanings cannot be determined with any degree of certainty. [Teachings about] monotheism, idolatry, superstition, celestial worship, medicine, the finer points of sexual conduct and many other subjects are interpreted in contradictory ways. The words are the same but the meanings extrapolated from them are completely different. It is able to give rise to beliefs as disparate as Vedic philosophy and the tenets of the Wam Margians, all at the same time. The differences exist not in their meaning but in the literal understanding of the words and not just in isolated cases, but throughout the text. But the words of the Holy Qur’an are protected to a degree that though one word which has multiple meanings may be interpreted in different ways at various places, the distinction is not profound. Also, the solution to this problem is found in the Holy Qur’an itself, so it is impossible to formulate an erroneous interpretation. The Holy Qur’an elucidates the meaning of its own verses and if a person subscribes to a false meaning, then another verse of the Holy Qur’an will expose their error and in this way the promise that God Himself will protect the Holy Qur’an is again fulfilled.

No external source is required to understand the essence of the Holy Qur’an. God has instilled it with such meanings that any erroneous interpretations can be swiftly identified. Those who commit mistakes cannot match their interpretation with any other part of the Holy Qur’an. This is a miracle of the Holy Qur’an which cannot be found in any other scripture. Other texts are composed in such a way that if one of their passages is interpolated, the other parts are unable to identify the point of digression. But all the verses of the Holy Qur’an safeguard one another. When a person makes a mistake, other verses draw attention to it and the error is apprehended.

Thus in his capacity as a recipient of revelation the Holy Prophet (sa) was greater than all others. His revelation is alive and eternal. It possesses such miraculous effects that no other form of revelation can compete with it and no scripture can stand alongside the Holy Qur’an.

(Alfazl, 25 Oct 1930)

The Holy Prophet (sa) in the Sight of an Enemy

Sir William Muir K. C. S. I.—a civilian resident of UP (Uttar Pradesh) who eventually rose through official ranks to become the Lieutenant Governor of the province—authored a biography of the Holy Prophet (sa), which if not the finest, is still considered one of the best works on the subject by a western scholar. The writer was a strident opponent of both Islam and its founder. However, his relations with Muslims and the eminence of his government post, precluded him from unleashing the full fury of his pen against the religion. Still his prejudice often seeps into his writings. The foul and poisonous tone with which he speaks against the Holy Prophet (sa) is hardly a cause for surprise; a vessel can only pour out that which it contains. Instead, what is extraordinary to note is how, on occasion, the beauty of the Prophet’s (sa) character lights the flame of insight and perception even in his eyes, and he too can be seen succumbing to the delightful charms [of the Holy Prophet (sa)].

This marksman of Christianity fires his arrows at the Prophet (sa) like one driven by madness. And yet the heart cannot be but moved to see him fervently prostrate towards the earth and respectfully caress the blood his arrows have spilled. At such junctures, he embodies the contradictory emotions which arise when enmity and astonishment weave in coalescence in the manner of a [thunder] cloud which nature has at once invested with fire and water. And when these moments pass, Muir again reaches for his arrows.

Many opponents of Islam allege the Holy Prophet (sa) was a product of his time. That is to say, they claim he did not impact the age of his existence, but was forged by the circumstances of his life. [According to their argument, the Prophet (sa)] came when the people of Arabia were disillusioned and increasingly drawn to Christianity. They were eager to be reformed and needed only a mould to fashion them according to its prescription—and that mould was the Holy Prophet (sa) who had been readied by the environment of his time. The hearts of the Arabs followed him and adopted a new identity and a new name for themselves by which they spread across the earth. However, [in real terms], the Holy Prophet (sa) did not impart onto the world at large a new law, nor did he initiate any sort of world reform. Muir, as per his disposition, is a firm proponent of this thesis. But at times, the breeze of the Holy Prophet’s (sa) character unsettles the sureness of his footing, and in a state of fear and trembling, he stumbles and yet thereafter his spirit soars from the earth to a new realm. At one such moment his pen flows with the words: The fabric of Islam no more necessarily grew out of the state of Arabia, than a gorgeous texture grows from the slender meshes of silken filament; or the stately ship from unhewn timber of the forest; or the splendid palace from rude masses of quarried rock. Had Mahomet, stern to his early convictions, followed the leading of Jewish and Christian truth, and inculcated upon his fellows their simple doctrine, there would have been a ‘‘SAINT MAHOMET’’—more likely perhaps a ‘‘MAHOMET THE MARTYR’’—laying the foundation stone of the Arabian Church. But then (so far as human probabilities and analogy indicate) Arabia would not, certainly in his day, have been convulsed to its centre, or even any considerable portions of it converted.

He abandoned his early convictions; for the uncompromising severity of inflexible principle, he substituted the alluring designs of expediency and compromise; and then, with consummate skill, he devised a machinery, by the plastic power and adaptive energy of which, he gradually shaped the broken and disconnected masses of the Arab race into a harmonious whole,—a body politic endowed with life and vigour. To the Christian, he was a Christian;—to the Jew he became a Jew:—to the Meccan idolator, as a reformed worshipper of the Kaaba. And thus, by unparalleled art, and a rare supremacy of mind, he persuaded the whole of Arabia, Pagan, Jew and Christian, to follow his steps with docile submission. Such a process is that of the workman shaping his material. It is not that of the material shaping its own form, much less (as some would hold) moulding the workman himself. It was Mahomet that formed Islam: it was not Islam, or any pre-existing Moslem spirit, that moulded Mahomet.

Whether walking the earth or soaring across the heavens, Muir is who he is; his [waspish] sting is inseparable from his being. And yet the honey sucked from the flowers of the garden of Muhammad (sa) flows even from his tongue. [It is of little import] how many times he asserts that Islam was a deceit contrived by the Prophet (sa)—he is after all a foe inhabited by enmity. But the truth written by his pen cannot be reverted, no matter how hard he and his companions might try. That is, that the Holy Prophet (sa) was not a product of his circumstances, instead he was the creator of a new world, and none can see such a thing to fulfilment except [with the support of ] the angels of God. Worldly leaders are of this temporal realm; only those who come to guide humanity can give birth to a new world—for those who come from their creator are invested with the power of creation.

(Alfazl, 25 Oct 1930)

Glossary

Ahmadiyyat or Ahmadiyyat (اَحَْدِیّــت) a religious community within Islam founded by Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad who claimed to be the Promised Messiah and Imam Mahdi.

Hadith or Hadith (حَدِیْــث) the recorded sayings and traditions of the Holy Prophet (sa).

Hazrat or Hadrat (حَضْت) an honorific Arabic title.

Hijra or Hijrah (ہِجْــرَة) the migration of the Holy Prophet (sa) from Mecca to Medina.

Khalifa or Khalifah (خَلِیْفَــہ) a term used for Islamic spiritual leaders, particularly the successors of the Holy Prophet (sa) and the Promised Messiah (as).

Khalifatul-Masih or Khalifatul-Masih (

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

) a title conferred on the spiritual successors of the Promised Messiah (as).

Khilafat or Khilafat (خِلَفَــت) an institution led by a supreme spiritual head known as the khalifa.

Sharia or Shari ‘ah (شَِیْعَــہ) literally ‘path’ or ‘way’. The word sharia is often used with reference to Islamic law or the various duties and obligations of Muslims.

Umma or Ummah (اُمّــة) the global community of Muslims.

Uswa-e-hasanah or Uswa-e-hasanah (أُسۡوَةٌ حَسَنَةٞ ) excellent model of conduct.

10 of 10 left today