Chapter 3: A Rebuttal of Maududian Philosophy
Murder in the Name of Allah
A REBUTTAL OF MAUDUDIAN PHILOSOPHY
The Hindu revivalist movements took an aggressive turn in the early 1920s after the failure of the joint Hindu - Muslim khilafat movement. The Hindu Mahasabha, founded at Hardwar in 1914 by Pandit Madan Mohan Malaviya (1861-1946), joined the Arya Samaj in its campaign of shuddi (reconversion and purification of Muslims, initially in the Punjab, the United Provinces, now Uttar Pradesh, the Deccan and other parts of India). By forcing Muslims to ‘wash away their pollution’ with total immersion in a river or water-tank, Hindu gangs provoked communal rioting. Between 1922 and 1926 over 200 Hindu - Muslim clashes were reported. Verbal and written attacks on Islam and Islam’s Prophet* became widespread. In their religious zeal, the writers of shuddi litera- ture made scurrilous attacks on the Holy Prophet®. An Arya Samaj preacher, Pandit Kalicharan Sharma, wrote his own account. He empha- sised the Prophet’s* alleged immorality and the fact that he married to ‘correct’ the view of history. His book, Vichitra Jiwan (Strange Life), also stressed ‘the spread of Islam by the sword’. All Muslims, according to Pandit Sharma, were intent on looting, arson and rape. In May 1924, a Lahore book-seller, Rajpal, published an Urdu tract by an anonymous author criticising the Holy Prophet*. The tract, Rangila Rasul (Playboy Prophet) suggests that all great religious leaders are associated with sets of ideas and symbols. For instance, the founder of Arya Samaj, Swami Dayanand, had glorified celibacy and closely identified his reforms with the Vedas. Similarly, the life and faith of the Prophet of Islam® were linked closely with relationships with women. Rajpal was later murdered by two Muslim youths, which led to Hindu - Muslim rioting. Another Hindu wrote an article, ‘A trip to hell’, in Risala-i- Vartman describing the Prophet* in hell and elaborating on his sufferings and ‘sins’.
The Ahmadis of undivided India immediately got themselves to- gether and defeated the reconversion movement on its own ground. The Imam of the Ahmadiyyah Movement in Islam at the time, Mirza Bashirud- din Mahmud Ahmad, also took a positive step. He decided that there should be inter-faith conferences where the leaders of different faiths should meet and explain their beliefs in order to pull down the walls of ignorance and prejudice. He set up an annual conference for just this purpose. It was called Yaum-i-Paishwayan-i-Madhahib (The Day of Religious Founders). On that day, for instance, a Muslim would speak of the greatness of Krishna* or Buddha’, while a Hindu would talk of Islam’s Holy Prophet, putting right misunderstandings about him which were being spread by propagandists. The Ahmadi attitude during this unfortunate time of calumny and hatred was that non-Muslims should be educated and given the message of love and peace which the Prophet of Islam* gave the world. Accusations and sectarian diatribes do not help a missionary preach his faith. He should instead emphasise the good points of his religion. The [mam of the Anmadiyyah Movement also persuaded the government of India - then British - to strengthen the law to protect the honour of religious leaders. The Punjab governor, William Hailey, who was briefed by Mirza Bashiruddin Mahmud Ahmad, recommended that the government of India change the law by banning material blatantly offensive to religious feeling.' The government ac- cepted this recommendation. A bill was accordingly drafted to add a new section to the Indian Penal Code, 295A, which made it an offence to insult or to attempt to insult the religious beliefs of any class of people. The bil! was passed in 1927 by the Legislative Assembly.
But Indian Muslims were very upset and indignant at this time. A Muslim calligrapher, Abdul Rashid, outraged by such malicious attacks on the Holy Prophet’s* life, murdered Swami Shraddhanand, a shuddi leader. Rashid was tried and hanged. Thousands of Delhi Muslims went to the Delhi District jail to collect his body and he was buried as a martyr. This glorification of murder enraged the Hindus, who calied Islam a religion of violence and force which relied on jihad and not reason or virtue.? A young journalist, Abul Ala Maududi, answered these accusa- tions in a series of articles in Al-Jamiyat, the newspaper of the Jamiyat Ulama-i-Hind. These articles were subsequently published in book form as Al-Jihad fil Islam.
In the first part of this book, Maududi convincingly proved that the wars fought by the Prophet of Islam“ were defensive. He fought to establish freedom of conscience and opposed all attempts to suppress the peaceful work of preaching Islam. Having convinced the reader that Islam did indeed establish the freedom of conscience, the Maulana himself seems to cast doubt on his own argument by adding this rider:
That freedom of conscience is limited to faith and religion only. It does
not mean that people have freedom to commit sin. Islam does not permit
the use of force for conversion, but force may be used - in fact, should be
used - to prevent people from doing wrong. Non-Muslim countries and
cultures cannot be allowed to practice immoral deeds and force used to keep these countries free of vice should be clearly distinguished from that used to convert people to Islam.
Thus, the Maulana evolved a tortuous method of interpreting the Holy Qur’an and the tradition (hadith) of the Prophet* to prove his point.
Maulana Maududi goes alittle deeper in discussing the use of force and explains the purpose of verse 29 of Chapter 9 in the Holy Qur’an. Quoting it out of context, he says:
The words: ‘Until they pay the jizya’ fully explain the purpose of war
[prevention of vice]. If the words were: ‘until they accept Islam’ then, of
course, one could say that Islam uses force to spread its faith. But the
words, ‘until they pay the jizya’ are clear. Consent to pay thejizya ends
the war. After this, the life and property of non-Muslims are inviolable,
whether or not they accept Islam.
Maulana Maududi began writing his book to prove that Islam gives complete freedom of conscience and that the Holy Prophet® went to war because his opponents were suppressing that very freedom. This was in answer to non-Muslim claims that Islam is based on two main principles: the forcing of people to do good and the prevention of them from indulging in vice. Since forcing people to do good is against the freedom of conscience, Islam refrains from it. But the Maulana is a little forgetful, for he quotes the words in the Holy Qur’an which say that a war should be stopped after non-Muslims have agreed to pay the jizya. How could a war, begun purely to prevent vice, ever be won if the enemy pays thejizya without promising to wipe out vice? The Maulana’s aim was to impose the poll tax. Since an agreement had been reached for its payment, the second principle of Islam, prevention of vice, had been conveniently forgotten.
The final part of Maulana Maududi’s logic, however, nullifies the very purpose for which he wrote this book. He says:
When all methods of persuasion failed, the Prophet® took to the sword.
That sword removed mischief, the impurities of evil and the filth of the
soul. The sword did something more - it removed their blindness so they
could see the light of truth - and it also cured them of their a:rogance:
arrogance which prevents people from accepting the truth, stiff necks and
proud heads bowed with humility.
As in Arabia, so in other countries, Islam’s expansion was so fast that within a century a quarter of the world accepted Islam. This conversion took place because the sword of Islam cut away the veils which had covered men’s hearts.?