Chapter 7: Punishment For Apostasy
Murder in the Name of Allah
PUNISHMENT FOR APOSTASY
In earlier chapiers we have given numerous references from the Holy Qur’an and the history of Islam to expose the fallacy that Islam prescribes any corporal punishment for those who renounce Islam as their faith. We examined at length the most common arguments presented by the advocates of death for apostasy, namely the report of Ikramah and the incident of zakat in Hazrat Abu Bakr’s time. Some other arguments are examined in this chapter.
It is difficult to assess whether the concept of coercion in Islam had its birth on Islamic soil or was the child of the orientalists’ imagination and was later on transferred to the lap of Islam. Having examined this in the light of Islamic history, I honestly believe that the idea first took root in the Islamic world itself and that it is wrong of us to blame the orientalists for having initiated it. They picked it up from the Muslims: before the orientalists were even born, the idea seems to have been present in medieval Islamic thought. It originated in the late Umayyad dynasty. Throughout the Abbaside period, the idea continued to flourish and was further strengthened because the Abbaside sovereigns wanted to use force not only against the enemies of Islam but also against their own people. A licence for this was not infrequently sought from Muslim scholars under their influence. The concept has therefore arisen from the conduct and policies of the post-Khilafat-i Rashida! Muslim govern- ments of Baghdad.
Looking on from the outside, Western scholars believed that this was an Islamic teaching, but the fact was that it was not Islamic at all. It was the basis of the behaviour of some Muslim governments. We should remember that the idea had its birth in an age when all over the world the use of force for the spread of influence and ideology was a common feature and no exception was taken to this.
It is clear that the allegation that Islam advocates the use of force for the spread of its ideology does not originate from a study of the sources of Islamic teachings but from a study of the conduct of some Muslim states. Now that a new era has dawned in which all the Islamic literature and traditions are available to us and the Holy Qur’an has been translated into so many languages - when Wester scholars have direct access to the sources of Islamic teachings - their persistence in making the allegation is unjustified. They should go to the sources and study the teachings of the Holy Qur’an, the traditions and the conduct of the Holy Prophet, Muhammad®*, himself.
This work is an attempt to examine the whole issue, not in the light of how Muslims of a certain era behaved, but in the light of the fundamental teachings of the Holy Qur’an and the exposition of those teachings by the words of the Holy Prophet* and by his conduct.
The tendency to judge teachings by the conduct of their followers has often misled people about the original teachings. It is universally ob- served that after a while all religions lose their influence on the conduct of their adherents. For illustrations of this, study the behaviour of the Buddhists of today or of earlier eras, study the behaviour of the Hindu governments, and so on and so forth; it often has no relationship whatsoever with the original teachings. In particular, politics must not be confused with religion; political behaviour of a nation should not be treated as a mirror reflecting the teachings of the religion which its people are supposed to follow.
It is against this background that we examine the arguments pre- sented by the advocates of death as a punishment for apostasy. Definition of an apostate
The Holy Qur’an states:
They will not stop fighting you until they turn you back from your
faith, if they can. The works of those from among you who turn
back from their faith and die in a state of disbelief shall be vain in this world and the next. These are the inmates of the fire, therin
shall they abide. (2.218)
This means that whoever, out of fear of the sword (or the pain of punishment), decides to abjure Islam has a fundamental right to do so but no one else has the right to declare him to be an apostate. The right to declare himself to be an apostate lies only with him. Nowhere in the Holy Qur’an has this right been granted to others. That is to say, one is free to renounce one’s own religion but has no right toimpose renunciation of religion on others. According to Islamic teachings, an apostate, there- fore, cannot be manufactured by religious scholars or the clergy or any non-tolerant individual or government.
The Holy Qur’an also states: ‘Surely, those who have turned away after guidance has been made manifest to them have been deceived by Satan who has beguiled them with false hopes.’ (47.26)
Other verses from the Holy Qur’an on apostasy The Holy Qur’an says:
O ye who believe, whoso from among you turns back from his
religion let him remember that in place of such a person, Allah
will soon bring a people whom He will love and who will love
Him, who will be kind and considerate towards the believers and
firm and unyielding towards the disbelievers. They will strive
hard in the cause of Allah and will not at all take to heart the reproaches of fault finders. That is Allah’s grace; He bestows it upon whosoever He pleases. Allah is the Lord of vast vounty, All-