Cover Page

The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam, Part 25

MY REPLY

I reply to them in the same words in the Holy Qur’an in which === PDF-Seite 182 === 166 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam the Prophet of an earlier age (i.e. Mosesas) replied to as

his enemies. Not that I consider myself equal to even the dust of the feet of Prophetsas. However I consider it imperative to follow the Sunna of the Prophetsas. Justifying my reply on the basis of what Hadrat Musaas said to his enemies, I say to them in the words of the Holy Qur’an:

'By Allah'! I come into the refuge of my Lord from you and mischief-makers of your sort and every arrogant person who does not believe in the Day of Judgment. [Otherwise he would not stoop to these vile and contemptible deeds.]158

The Holy Qur’an goes on to expound this subject through many verses. There is an abundance of such verses, however, I shall now come to the last portion of this subject.

THE ALLEGATION OF APOSTASY AGAINST THE CHIEF OF PROPHETSAS

The most elevated, the best, the supreme, the most eminent, the chosen one is our master Hadrat

158 The Holy Qur’an 40:28. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 183 === 167 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam sa as Muhammad who is the chief of all the Prophets . It is established by the Holy Qur’an and the Sunna that allegations of apostasy were made even against the Holy Prophetsa by his people. They said that he had renounced his faith and should thus certainly be punished. Not only he had apostatized but also made others turn away from their faith. They said how was it possible that they could tolerate that he continuously propagated his faith and convert others to his beliefs. Allah the Exalted informed the Holy Prophetsa:

"And remember the time when the disbelievers plotted against thee that they might imprison thee or kill thee or expel thee. And they planned and Allah also planned, and Allah is the Best of planners."159

That is there was the time when the disbelievers would devise all sorts of plans against himsa. Among these plans was the scheme that hesa should be captured, murdered or expelled from the town. That all the methods thought by the enemies of the previous Prophetsas were not just hatched by the enemies of the Holy Prophetsa but a resolve was made to carry them 159 The Holy Qur’an 8:31. [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 184 === 168 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam out and for this all kinds of efforts were made by them. Just as Allah the Exalted declares: they tried all plans and Allah the Exalted also planned in response and indeed Allah is the best of the planners.

YOU ARE DEVOID OF SHAME!

Let us pause and reflect. The history that has been preserved by the Holy Qur’an and which has been, time and again, presented to us with great clarity— citing by name all the Prophetsas from the time of Hadrat Nuhas to the Holy Prophetsa—reminding us, repeatedly and categorically, that the opponents of all Prophetsas were united in the belief that Prophetsas were apostates who needed to be punished. The enemy of the Prophetas of each era is in agreement and unanimity with the enemy of the Prophetas of another era that there should definitely be a punishment for apostasy, whether one is killed, imprisoned or driven out of home, but punished they must be. In particular it is imperative to punish that apostate who also preaches his faith to others. With reference to this history Allah, the Exalted, constantly tells us that those people were false and cruel who proposed punishment for apostasy. They supported force in matters of faith and openly expressed their views in this regard. The Holy Prophetsa and all the other Prophetsas, without exception, dismissed these claims, declared them false, wretched and unfortunate. They made the === PDF-Seite 185 === 169 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam proclamations about freedom of religion and the freedom of conscience.

THE QUESTION IS:

After this general agreement and unanimity of the Prophetsas that there is no punishment for apostasy, how could it be that the Holy Prophetsa— about whom his enemies maintained that he was an apostate and should thus be punished— would leave the party of the Prophetsas and join the party of their enemies and announce that each apostate should be punished by death or other dreadful methods? It is astonishing that the scholars of today, whilst claiming love for the Holy Prophetsa, would make this assertion! Why, surely they must feel embarrassed. Do they not simply wish to die with mortification! How dare they utter such claims, when all Prophetsas, unanimously and without exception, continuously one after the other, dismissed the tenet of death penalty for apostasy. Each time God bore witness that these Prophetsas were true in what they said and that there is no compulsion in religion and those who promoted compulsion in matters of faith and suggested the punishment for apostasy were all liars and ignoble. God destroyed and obliterated them all. Leave all other arguments against apostacy aside and just consider what class you are (God forbid) dragging the Holy Prophetsa into. Most certainly this === PDF-Seite 186 === 170 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam can never be. God will certainly never allow you to do this. This doctrine is only fit to die, and it shall. Even if the Ahmadis have to lay down their lives for this, they shall do so. They shall erase this stigma from the Holy Prophetsa even if they have to erase these smears with their own blood!

THE TIMES HAVE CHANGED

It is a pity that the officials and the mullahs of Pakistan do not realise that times have changed, that all the opponents of the Prophetsas—about whom the Holy Qur’an states that they had suggested punishments for apostasy—are now repentant and have abandoned this belief. At present followers of no religion of the world maintain death penalty to be the punishment for apostasy. Even if the collective judgment of all the faiths of the world in the times of the Holy Prophetsa was death penalty for apostasy or imprisonment or expulsion from township, times have indeed changed now. Now even the Jews say that death penalty is not the punishment for apostasy, that it is a crime in the name of humanity and a smear on religion. Today even the Christians say with reference to their historical past that if they had killed the fellow Christians mercilessly for the crime of apostasy then they have greatly wronged themselves and are now embarrassed to note that history. They say that their heads hang in shame reading the history of the Spanish Inquisition or the === PDF-Seite 187 === 171 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam details of the punishments meted out in England for apostasy and say that they now renounce all that. Similarly various other faiths that once held this belief, have now relinquished it. What a warped scenario is this that today among those who claim death penalty to be the punishment of apostasy, are none other than those who are associated with the Holy Prophetsa. Can a scenario more agonizing than this be imagined? There is a limit to everything. This situation has crossed all boundaries of ignorance. In the emotional reaction to all this, whilst I feel anger I also undergo extreme anguish and at times I am amused as to what has happened to these people, what on earth has become of their rational faculties!

THE MIRACLE OF HOLY PROPHET’S PRAYER:

I prays to God for the ears which can listen and for the hearts that may be guided. They may or may not believe us, but our stand shall always be that of the Holy Prophetsa—to the practice of whomsa we shall always remain loyal—encapsulated in the verses.

160 Admonish, therefore, for thou art but an admonisher; Thou hast no authority to compel them. (The Holy Qur’an 88:22-23). [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 188 === 172 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam We are here to heal the wounds of today’s world and we will definitely try and remove the perversity of today’s world. We shall do it through admonishing and reasoning, through counsel with love and care. However, we shall not take on the role of a warden. If one does not believe one has the right to reject:

Our task is to carry the message. But along with it we shall pray, for the arsenal of prayer is the greatest weapon of all. The land of Arabia witnessed such miracles of the prayers of the Holy Prophetsa that the world is still astonished by them. The fact of the matter is that the tremendous revolution that took place in the Arabian Peninsula within a few years was a fruit of the prayers of the Holy Prophetsa and not just a result of his preaching. One Hadith relates that, with the obvious exception of Mecca and Medina, Ta’if too was, not among the areas which apostatized and that these areas were blessed by the personal education and training of the Holy Prophetsa. The fact of the matter is that Islam reached the rest of Arabia, and indeed the world, by virtue of the prayers of the Holy Prophetsa. The town of Taif did not join the apostates because it has accepted

161 Wherefore let him who will, believe, and let him who will, disbelieve.

(The Holy Qur’an 18:30). [Publisher] === PDF-Seite 189 === 173 The Truth about the Alleged Punishment for Apostasy in Islam Islam exclusively as a consequence of the prayers of the Holy Prophetsa. The fact that Ta’if did not join in the rebellion against the Muslim government at the time when almost all the tribes of Arabia had given in to this treachery, proves that this miracle was indeed a manifestation of the prayers of the Holy Prophetsa for Ta’if. During the time when the Holy Prophetsa was subjected to cruelty in Ta’if, when he was being stoned, God’s angels descended and offered him that if he so wished the town could be destroyed. But the Holy Prophetsa prayed that the town be granted guidance and beseeched that:

·

10 of 10 left today