Text

Real Revolution, Part 10

For the peqple of that early period this point was one of a staggering nature. [n tact even today it is far from having attained an undisputed position. We find that in Europe there is a fairly large number of people who arc opposed to the imposition of capital punishment, the argument they use tor the purpose being that if it is a crime tor anyone to take life, how does it become permissible […] government to do so ? But the fact of the matter is that the government does not only execute certain people; it also commits certain other deeds which have an appearance very similar to those ot certain crimes — for instance, it forces people to surrender portions of their incomes and properties in the form of taxes. It the objection mentioned above is held to be valid, it will have to be conceded that no government is justified in forcing people to pay “taxes. But these people do not object to governments receiving taxes, which shows, in turn, that the objection against capital punishment too is* rather a fanciful one, which springs ‘from lack ot due thought, .

The very essence ot civilization, thus, is just this that all those actions which are considered bad and reprehensible, are called the basis of culture and human progress when a government has recourse to them. No one objects to these actions on the part of the staté. But when an individual takes the same course, he is held tully guilty and duly punished.

When first the human mind took this stupendous step under the impulse of divine revelation, it was a revolution that must have most severely taxed the intellectual power of the human group first addressed. Naturally for the wild people of that era the demand must bave been bewildering that they should submit to the authority of one from among themselves who, against their own inclinations, would have a measure of control over what they pussessed, aad would in certain cases even inflict the death penalty. Quite understandably, the first general reaction to such a demand must bave been a violent urge to reject and throw away this new control. “It 1 bave killed a man, that is something

betw cen me and those around the man I have killed. Who is this man that he should interfere in what I do, or want to do? Why should I submit to his authority? He is no better than myself. Why should 1 let him set himself up above me?” Such questions must bave naturally risen in the mind of the members of the first group to which the law was originally addressed. Not to speak of those days, even now many people with muddled ‘minds tall into similar mental contusions, and duly established governments have often to cope with disruption caused by men of this type. It is due, in some respects, to similar ccnfused reasoning that capital punishment has been abolished in some European countries; but if the people who have done so were present before me at ‘this moment, I ‘would ask them why on the same basis they do not take away from their governments the right to levy taxes, . Ideas of this kind are, in fact, an indication that ‘a decline has set in in the mental capacities of the people of Europe, in some respects anyway: and it is people of this kind who become the cause of weakness in the authority of established governments. The only difference between those who indulge in such confused thinking at this day and the primitive savages who tended to defy the law when first it came into human affairs is this that the idea ot ordered society having”become firmly rooted in the human mind; + . 0 longer occurs to anyone that the system of gov.rnment by law should be-done away with altogether. The idea, nevertheless, keeps ciopping up in various forms that another government, differently constituted, would perhaps be more mindful of their rights, this being the reason why attempts are from time to time being wade to effect changes in systems ot government. Among the. primitive people, of whom there still are a fairly large number, the tendency even now is that they disapprove of all systems ot control in an ordered society. Submission to any such order is extremely painful for them and they fail to understand why other people want to inter-

I fere with them. “If we find it more convenient to go about naked, what right has anybody to force us to wear garments. Qur limbs are freer. and we get more air if we remain naked; and in aay case it suits us. Why should anybody want to interfere with our personal likes and dislikes?"

At one stige during their colonial administration in some parts of Africa, when the British began to persuade t-e primitive natives to wear clothes, on the out-skirts of towns officials were posted with supplies of wearmg apparel, to be given over to natives coming irom the bush to put on betore they entered the city. With great reluctance the natives put them on, but felt very embarrassed in them. casting furtive glances to right and left, lest there be some one from among their own people who might see them in this disgraceful condition. When with clothes on they happened to run across each other, they passed by with closed eyes, which ‘meant that they were ashamed to have been caught in this condition. No wonder, then, that as soon as

— they had finished their business in the town, they flung the clothes at the official concerned at the post, and ran into the bush.

Not to speak of the primitive people in Africa and ; other parts of the world who still have an

~abhorence tor clothes, there are people here and there in Europe and America even now who prefer to go about without clothing of ary kind. They are called the Nudists, the tendency having established itself in Western society as a sort of cult, seriously and publicly preached by its adherents. The police places certain restrictions on them in public interest, but they always kick against such interference with their personal inclinations and desires, as they call it. h

This also is a symptom that a kind of mental decay has set in in some parts of the West. There are numerous regular clubs in these lands where no one can become a member if he or she bathed with any clothes on, for according to their point of view such a person is not properly civilized.

I once read a book on this subject in which a doctor wrote that his daughter joined the Nudists which he disliked very much, and he began to be strict with her. At last his daughter one day asked him to accompany her to the Nudist colony or club and see for himself how polite and civilized werethese people whom he was pleased to call indecent. When he went to that place he saw that everyone - was going about without a stitch of clothing on the body. At first he felt extremely embarrassed. But then, he said, he noticed how innocent these people looked in this simple, unaffected condition.

Finally he was so impressed that he took off his own clothes and joined them. Advantages of Civilized Life under a Settled Government Today perhaps you feel inclined to laugh at those who doubt the value of certain controls on human actions in the interests of all. But when this question was first raised by Adam, it must have created a violent commotion in the human group addressed, with tempers rising and blood flowing in many cases. When Adam called upon bis people to take to some sort of clothing. many unruly spirits must have raised a violent protest that the proposed measure involved intolerable interference with their freedom of thought and action. To overcome this strong opposition, Adam was taught to take his stand on a rational, social basis. “If you agree to live in the proposed ordered unit, called jannat, you will no longer be exposed to the pangs of huhger and thirst, nor have to suffer at the hands of inclement weather (20:1i9-120)"". Here is the earliest root of the functions of a state established I on the basis of moral and social concepts — that it should work for the well-being of the people. The verse in the Holy Qur’an bearing on this point has been grossly misunderstood to mean that Adam was kept in some place where he and those with him were not subject to honger and thirst. The fact is that this verse lays down the basic duties of a government as conceived by the Islamic point of view, namely, that it should create channels for useful employment of the peuple placed under its “care, should look to the fundamental needs of those not able to do work of any kind, arrange for dependable supplies of water, and furnish shelter against the inclemencies of weather. In other words, four duties devolve upon a government: to meet the needs of its people for food, water, clothing and housing ; these duties having been clearly set forth in this verse of the Holy Qur’an where the benefits of the new system are expounded for Adam. If people protested against the new order, Adam was directed to explain to them the advantage it would bring. If they submitted to it, they would be placed in a condition where they would not ever have to go without food : they would not have to go about naked in the sun and rain; supplies of water would be assured when needed :- and they would bave houses to live in and rest. Evidently, if a government made sure of these four things, it would have to be adjudged one of the best even according to modern standards.

Adam's people were thus told that restrictions. upon individual freedom and action were no doubt irksome, but they were in the best interests of the group, for they would enable the new social set up to take care of their needs better than they could themselves individually, ensuring a lasting condition of prosperity and peace called Jannat, or. Paradise — a place of bliss.

·

10 of 10 left today