Chapter One—Khilafah

The Reality of Khilafah, Part 2

The Shiites who think that as-Siddiq [Hadrat Abu Bakr ra] and al-Faruq [Hadrat ‘Umar ra] violated the rights of al-Murtada [Hadrat ‘Ali ra] and Az-Zahra [Hadrat Fatimah ra] and oppressed them, have in fact renounced fairness and embraced injustice and taken the approach of the wrongdoers; for, these were the people who left their homes, friends, wealth, and properties for the sake of Allah and His Messenger. They were persecuted by the disbelievers and driven out by the evildoers but remained steadfast in the manner of the most virtuous and righteous of men. When they became Khulafa’, they did not fill their homes with wealth and treasures and their sons and daughters did not inherit gold and silver. Instead, they returned everything they acquired to the Public Treasury. They did not appoint their sons as their successors, as is the way of the worldly and of those who go astray. They lived in this world in the raiment of poverty and want and did not incline towards lives of luxury like kings and lords. Is it then believable that they usurped people’s property through wrongdoing and that they were in any way inclined towards usurping, looting and robbing? Was this the effect that the company of the Messenger of Allah, the Best of the Universe, had upon them? Could this be true when Allah, the Lord of all Creation, has praised and commended them! Certainly not! Allah had indeed purified their souls, cleansed their hearts, and illumined their beings. He made them models of righteousness for all pious people to come. We cannot find even the slightest hint of ill intention on their part, or the least indication of any evil act. Surely, no injustice can be attributed to them.

By Allah! They were men who acted justly. Had they been presented with a valley full of riches acquired by unfair means, they would not have cared the least for it. They would never be allured by wealth like those who follow their base desires, even if it was a mountain of gold. When they obtained money earned in a righteous way, they only spent it in the way of Allah, the Glorious, and for the obligations of the Faith. How then can it be imagined that they angered Az-Zahra [Hadrat Fatimah ra] for the sake of a few trees and distressed the daughter of the Holy Prophet s (as) like the mischief-makers? The fact is that noble people are pure in their intentions, firmly adhering to what is right, and the blessings of Allah descend upon them. Allah surely knows what is in the hearts of God-fearing people. If such deeds are considered as hurtful, then even the Lion of Allah [Hadrat ‘Ali ra] cannot be free from such blame, for he betrothed the daughter of Abu Jahl and thus distressed Az-Zahra. Beware, and do not transgress. Do not adopt the filth of those who deviated from the straight path and turned away from the truth after having seen the light of argument, and persisted in falsehood. I am guiding you to the path that will remove all doubts. Think carefully and do not rely upon ignorant notions. I hope and pray to God that you will turn to the truth. I do not mind if some of you reproach me. No one can be guided unless Allah chooses to guide him. None can be satiated but those who drink from His hand. God sees what is in my heart and what is in yours, and He sees your conduct and my conduct. He surely knows what is in the hearts of all people.

Dear people, know that some Shiite scholars say that the Khilafah of the three Companions [Hadrat Abu Bakr, Hadrat ‘Umar and Hadrat ‘Uthman] is not supported by the Holy Qur’an and Sunnah, while the Khilafah of al-Murtada, the most pious one and the Lion of Allah, is established in all respects and with categorical proofs. Therefore, they say, the three Khulafa’ are usurpers, oppressors and unjust, and that their Khilafah was not according to the will of the Seal of the Prophets and the Best of Messengers.

The Reply: All fair-minded, discerning and pious servants of Allah should be aware that the claim that Khilafah should have first been given to al-Murtada is pure arrogance and bears not an iota of truth. There is no reference to it in the Holy Qur’an and the

Shiites have no clear evidence to substantiate their claim. Such a claim is undoubtedly without proof—it is like a destitute beggar whose poverty is all too evident—even if ‘Ali was a sea of light and beyond all praise and eulogy. Do not, therefore, argue unjustly, nor come to us strutting with your false articulateness, and do not follow the path of the unjust. By Allah! I have reflected deeply upon the Holy Qur’an and pondered over its verses. I have thoroughly studied the subject of Khilafah and done everything required for proper scrutiny. I have searched every nook and cranny but I have not come across anything as decisive as the verse of Istikhlaf.1 I realized that this is one of the most significant verses of the Holy Qur’an. It contains clear proof and is a decisive argument from the Lord of the Universe for anyone who wishes to discern the truth like a fair judge. I am certain that one who is of pure nature and is unprejudiced will gratefully accept it and offer thanks to Allah for guiding him and saving him from error.

Verses of the Holy Qur’an are definite and their commandments are final, whereas oral traditions and historical evidence are not beyond question. Even where the narrators are trustworthy and discerning, any edicts based on such evidence remain dubious. Do not be deceived by their pleasant outward appearance, for most of these narrations are shrouded in darkness as they have not been protected from the meddling of the unjust. Trying to discern the truth from them is as hard as extracting honey from a beehive, and yet people seem to take it so lightly. This is true of most ahadith, as everyone is aware. What then, after rejecting Allah’s Book and His Signs, will you believe? Where will you go when the truth comes to light? If you discard the truth, what will you be left with except for error? O Muslims! Save yourselves from going astray!

I said earlier that the Traditions do not necessarily provide certainty. They are rather a collection of conjectures, doubts, assumptions, and concoctions. Anyone who abandons the Holy Qur’an and relies solely on them will fall into the abyss of destruction and will be ruined. The Traditions are like a trembling old man in a worn-out garb; they cannot stand up except by leaning on the firm support of the Holy Qur’an. How can one expect to attain the treasures of knowledge and wisdom from the Traditions without this great Imam [the Holy Qur’an]? The Holy Qur’an provides support to feeble Traditions, purifies those that contain some element of error and clarifies their intent with clear and categorical arguments. The Holy Qur’an is indeed the embodiment of certainty and it brings comfort to the hearts. It is the most powerful in expression and most expansive in its breadth and scope. Those who turn away from it and attach themselves to anything else transgress the bounds of faith and honesty, like the arrow that arrogantly leaves the bow. Whoever abandons the Holy Qur’an and looks down upon it and instead follows the Traditions, for whose veracity he has no clear proof, such a one surely goes astray. He shall soon be overcome by the blazing fire of regret and Allah will show him that he was in manifest error.

In summary, true peace and security rests in following the

Qur’an, while ruin and destruction come from abandoning it. In the eyes of those blessed with insight, there is no misfortune like the misfortune of turning away from the Book of Allah. Always remember the enormity of this tribulation, no matter how great the calamity of al-Husain may be in your eyes. Become seekers of truth, O heedless ones!

Let us now discuss the verses of the Holy Qur’an that provide magnificent arguments in support of the Khilafah of Abu Bakr, the Truthful One. I will prove it categorically, leaving no shadow of a doubt, as the path of doubt only leads to ruin. Arguments cannot be resolved except by pursuing certainties. Therefore, pay heed to my words and do not turn away from me. I pray to Allah that He bestows clear vision upon you. Allah, the Honourable and Glorious One, says in His Holy Book:

that He will surely make them Successors in the earth, as He made Successors from among those who were before them; and that He will surely establish for them their religion which He has chosen for them; and that He will surely give them in exchange security and peace after their fear: They will worship Me, and they will not associate anything with Me. Then whoso is ungrateful after that, they will be the rebellious. And observe Prayer and give the Zakat and obey the Messenger, that you may be shown mercy. Think not that those who disbelieve can frustrate Our plan in the earth; their abode is Hell; and it is indeed an evil resort (Surah an-Nur, 24:56–58). [Publisher]

These are the glad tidings that our Lord has bestowed on the believers, and these are the signs that He has given us to recognise the Khulafa’. Therefore, anyone who approaches Allah seeking His forgiveness, without adopting the ways of insolence or covering the truth with deceit, must accept this evidence, abandon unreasonable excuses and hearsay, and adopt the paths of the righteous. The full breadth of its meaning will be made clear to you through convincing arguments.

O people of understanding! Know that in these verses Allah has promised Muslim men and women that some of the believers from among them will be made Khulafa’ by His grace, and that He will remove the sense of fear in their hearts and replace it with security and peace. This promise was only perfectly fulfilled in the Khilafah of as-Siddiq. Every scholar knows that his time of Khilafah was a time of fear and tribulation. Upon the demise of the Messenger of Allah, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, countless calamities befell Islam. Many hypocrites turned apostate and grew in their hostility towards Islam. Some impostors claimed prophethood and many Bedouin joined them. Things came to such a pass that about one hundred thousand ignorant and wicked people started following Musailamah. Seditions and tribulations arose and the believers were severely shaken. Everyone was tested, and terrible situations emerged. The believers were distressed as if embers were burning their hearts or they were being cut to pieces with knives. At times, they shed tears over being parted from Khairul-Bariyyah [i.e. the Best of Creation—the Holy Prophet Muhammad s (as)], and at times they wept for the mischief that had become an all-consuming fire. The absence of peace was conspicuous. The mischief-makers grew in numbers like weeds growing out of the filth. The hearts of the believers were filled with terror and anguish. At this time, Abu Bakr, may Allah be pleased with him, was appointed ruler and the Khalifah of Khatamun-Nabiyyin [the Seal of the Prophets]. He was overwhelmed by grief and sorrow when he saw the conduct of the hypocrites, the disbelievers, and the apostates. Tears gushed from his eyes like heavy rainfall and he implored Allah to save Islam and the Muslims.

·

10 of 10 left today