Chapter One—Khilafah
The Reality of Khilafah, Part 5
If the prejudiced Shiites are asked who the first adult was who parted from the disbelievers and accepted Islam, they are obliged to say that it was Abu Bakr. Again, if they are asked who migrated with the Seal of Prophets, leaving behind all those dear to him and following the Holy Prophet wherever he went, they have to admit that it was Abu Bakr. If they are asked who the first Khalifah was, even though he was a usurper in their eyes, they acknowledge that it was Abu Bakr. If they are asked who collated the Holy Qur’an so that it could be spread to all nations, they must say it was Abu Bakr. If they are asked who were the people buried next to the Best of Messengers and the Chief of the Pious, they cannot but say that they were Abu Bakr and ‘Umar. It is astonishing that every honour was accorded to those whom the Shiites label as ‘hypocrites and disbelievers’. Moreover, the superiority of Islam was established at the very hands of these ‘enemies’. Is it possible for a true believer to think that the foundation stone of Islam was laid by an infidel, and that the first to migrate with the Pride of the Messengers was an unbeliever and an apostate, and that while every excellence was granted to these ‘disbelievers’, including the proximity to the grave of the Chief of the Pious, ‘Ali was deprived of all these blessings and Allah did not pay any attention to him? It was as if He did not know him or recognize him and did not stand by his side. This is nothing but manifest falsehood.
The truth is that as-Siddiq and al-Faruq were eminent Companions. They never usurped anyone’s rights. Piety was their rule and justice was their intent. They would scrutinize all matters, manifest and hidden, with a critical eye. They had no worldly ambitions and had devoted themselves to the service of Allah. I have seen no one equal to these two in their magnanimity and in their support for the religion of the Prophet of the two Realms. They were swifter than the moon in following the Sun of all mankind. They were completely engrossed in his love. They bore every hardship for the truth and happily accepted every humiliation for the matchless Prophet. They emerged like lions to face the armies of the unbelievers until Islam became victorious, the opposing armies were defeated, idolatry regressed, and the sun of faith and religion shone forth once more. Having thus rendered great services to Islam and having placed the Muslims under a debt of gratitude, they came to rest in the proximity of the Holy Prophet. This is the grace of Allah from whose vision the righteous are not hidden; indeed, all blessings are in the Hands of Allah and He bestows them on whomsoever He pleases. One who seeks God with all his heart is never lost even if the whole world turns against him. A seeker of God never experiences loss or lack. Allah never leaves the truthful unaided.
Allah is the Greatest! How sublime was their sincerity and loyalty that they were buried alongside the Holy Prophet. Had Moses and Jesus been alive, they would have envied such a great honour. This high status does not come by mere longing or desire; it is an eternal blessing from the Lord of Glory, and it is only destined for those who are eternally under Divine grace. I cannot fathom how these people can give preference to ‘Ali over as-Siddiq and not pay attention to these facts. They keep praising al-Murtada without looking at the status of as-Siddiq who was the most righteous. Those who ascribe infidelity to as-Siddiq and curse him should beware that the wrongdoers will soon come to know their place of return. As-Siddiq and al-Faruq were indeed the leaders of the caravan that surmounted high peaks for the sake of Allah. They called the people of cities and villages to the truth until the message reached far and wide. The fruits of Islam blossomed during their Khilafah, the atmosphere was filled with their fragrance, and Islam achieved great victories. During the era of as-Siddiq, Islam underwent a period of great hardship and was the target of mighty onslaughts. Allah came to its rescue through Abu Bakr and revealed its lost and buried treasure. Islam thus moved from a vulnerable state to one of strength. If we are to be fair, we should be grateful to this guardian of faith and pay no heed to his opponents. Do not turn your back on the one who supported your Lord and Master and saved your religion and home, and who looked after your welfare for the sake of Allah without expecting any reward. It is amazing how anyone can deny his eminence. The truth is that his radiant attributes shine brilliantly like the sun! Every believer reaps from the harvest that was sown by him and benefits from the knowledge taught by him. He preserved our faith by giving us the Holy Qur’an and bringing peace and security to our world. He who denies this is a liar and will end up ruined, with Satan as his company. Those who are confused about his true status are guilty of a deliberate error, as they see a drought in the place of abundant water. In their rage, they have insulted the most honourable one.
The personality of as-Siddiq was a combination of hope and fear, trepidation and longing, sympathy and love. His nature was perfect in sincerity and loyalty and was completely drawn towards the Almighty. He was empty of ego and all carnal desires. He was dedicated to God to the highest degree. Whatever he did was for the sake of the reformation and welfare of the believers. He was innocent of the charge of causing harm or grief, which some attribute to him.
Do not dwell on the internal conflicts, therefore, and look at them in a positive light. Reflect that this man, seeking Allah’s pleasure, gave no precedence to his own sons and daughters to make them rich, nor did he assign to them high offices. He sought from this world only his basic needs. How can you think that such a person would oppress the family of the Messenger of Allah? Allah had conferred upon him superiority over all of them and granted him His help because of the sincerity of his intentions. Not every dispute is based upon ill intentions, as some ignorant ones claim, since some disagreements stem from differences of opinion. The most appropriate and correct approach is to say that the differences among some Companions of the Best of the Universe were mere differences of perspective and were not born out of enmity or injustice. Those who sincerely hold an opinion, even though they might be in error, are to be forgiven. Sometimes righteous men, even the most honourable saints and holy men, have mutual disputes which may lead to envy and rancour. There is a divine purpose in all of this.
Therefore, all that was said between the Companions must be overlooked and not propagated. Their affairs should be left to Allah, for He alone is the Protector of the righteous. It is the way of Allah that He, in His Own determination, adjudicates between the pious in a way that is different from that of the transgressors, for the former are His beloved and are accepted by Him. It is for this reason that our Lord has informed us about the result of their dispute. He said, and He is indeed the Most Truthful:
This is the truth, but common people do not examine these matters as do those who are gifted with insight. Instead, they blindly believe in tales, and then one of them adds something to it and relates it to another, and he believes it and, in turn, adds something to it from himself and relates it to yet another, and so on, until the truth becomes completely obscured and is replaced by a new ‘truth’ that has nothing to do with the facts. Thus are nations destroyed by the dishonesty of the narrators.
So many truths have been lost, so many accounts obscured, so many stories changed, and so many narratives fabricated that no one knows what actually happened. If the early Companions and members of the household of the Prophet and his relatives were restored to life and were shown these stories, they would be astonished by the fabrications and lies of the people who exaggerated those events due to the whisperings of Satan, turned a drop of water into an ocean, made a mountain out of a molehill, and lied in order to deceive the undiscerning.
In fact, these tribulations festered in the middle ages and soon became like a fierce, roaring wind. Many false and fabricated reports were accepted as if they had been conveyed by truthful people. Use your reason, therefore, and do not act in haste. If you reflect over what has been vouchsafed to me, you cannot help but accept what I am saying and will not turn away from it. It is now up to you to believe it or reject it. However, those whose enmity towards the two Sheikhs is the essence of their life and part of their nature and habit will not at all accept what I am saying until Allah’s decree comes to be. They will not believe even if I present before them thousands of clear proofs. Let them wait until the time when Allah exposes what they harbour in their hearts.
O people! Do not entertain evil thoughts concerning the Companions and do not cast yourselves into ruin with your suspicions. The Companions have passed away and you do not know what transpired between them. How could they have been misguided when Allah had illuminated their eyes? Do not follow that of which you have no knowledge, and fear Allah, if you are humble. Undoubtedly, the Companions of the Holy Prophet and the members of his household were spiritual and virtuous people. They had completely devoted themselves to Allah. I can, therefore, never accept the accusation that they quarrelled for worldly gains or bore such rancour for one another that it resulted in fighting, estrangement, and all-out animosity. If we assume that the most truthful person [Abu Bakr] was one of those who prioritised the pleasures of this world and its temptations or that he was a usurper, then we are forced to admit that ‘Ali, the Lion of Allah, was also a hypocrite and not the ascetic whom we believe him to be, and that he was beguiled by the world, running after its ornaments and desiring its charms, and that this is why he did not turn away from the ‘apostates and disbelievers’ but cajoled them and chose to hide his faith for approximately thirty years. If as-Siddiq was a usurper and disbeliever in the eyes of ‘Ali al-Murtada, may Allah be pleased with him, why did he agree to swear allegiance to him? Why did he not migrate from the land of oppression, tribulation and apostasy? Was not Allah’s earth vast enough for him to emigrate, as has been the practice of many righteous ones? Look at the example of Ibrahim [Abraham], who fulfilled the commandments. How strong and powerful he was in bearing witness to the truth, and how when he saw that his father had erred and had gone astray and his people worshipped idols instead of the Supreme Lord, he turned away from them. He was not afraid and did not care for the consequences. He was thrown into the fire and subjected to suffering at the hands of the wrongdoers, but he did not choose to conceal his faith out of fear. This is the way of the righteous. They do not fear swords or blades. They consider the hiding of their faith to be one of the great sins and a matter of shame and transgression. Even if they commit a minor mistake, they return to Allah seeking forgiveness.
We are amazed at how ‘Ali, may Allah be pleased with him, swore allegiance to as-Siddiq and al-Faruq despite knowing that they had renounced Islam and had usurped the rights of others. Moreover, he lived among them a whole lifetime and followed them sincerely and devotedly. He did not tire or become weary, nor did he show any resentment, although he was supposedly aware of their corruption, disbelief and apostasy. He was free to go to the Arab tribes as the door was open for him and he was not a prisoner. Indeed, it was incumbent upon him to migrate to some other Arab lands to the east or the west to urge people to come out for battle. He should have aroused them with his eloquent words and led them against the ‘rebellious apostates’.
About one hundred thousand bedouin joined Musailamah the Impostor. ‘Ali was more deserving of their support than anyone else. On what basis, then, did he follow ‘the disbelievers’ and stay loyal to them? Why did he sit idly by like the indolent and not stand up in the manner of those who strive in the cause of Allah? What prevented him from rebelling against them when he possessed all the signs of being the chosen one of Allah and being honoured by Him? Why did he not go to war in support of the truth and summon people to it? Was he not the most eloquent among the people, the most articulate in delivering sermons, and one who could breathe life through his words? Surely, he could have gathered people around him within an hour or less by the strength of his rhetoric and oratory, which would have affected the listeners and motivated them with great zeal. If ‘the imposter’ could gather people around him, how is it that the Lion of Allah could not do the same while he was supported by Allah and was the beloved of the Lord of the worlds?