Another Argument

Refutation of the Divinity of Christ

Another Argument 13 affirms—as is acknowledged by those who consider some holy personage to be the Son of God—that Allah the Exalted is the Creator of everything.Furthermore, the entity that is the Creator is not said to be the father, and the one who is the son is not said to be the creation of the father.This is because having a son is a natural affair and happens without power and will, whereas being the Creator affirms power and will, as the Christians them- selves acknowledge that the Son came for salvation and Allah the Exalted brought him forth so that salvation may take place.Another Argument َوَوُه ِّلُكِب ٍءْيَش ٌمْيِلَع [And He knows all things full well].Allah the Exalted says those people who consider some holy person to be the Son of God, believe that Allah the Exalted is the Knower of all things.Such perfect knowledge and such all-encompassing under- standing requires that such an operative be a Creator with will, because it is only discernment and knowledge that distinguishes between natural actions and acts of creation.Natural actions lack discernment and will.Collecting all these arguments in one place the Holy Qur’an says:

14 ُعْيِدَب ِتٰوٰمَّسلا َو ِضْرَاْلا١ؕ ىّٰنَا ُنْوُكَي ٗهَل ٌدَلَو َّو ْمَل ْنُكَت ٗهَّل ٌةَبِحاَص١ؕ َو َقَلَخ َّلُك ٍءْيَش١ۚ َو َوُه ِّلُكِب 1 ٍءْيَش ٌمْيِلَع And at another place the Noble Qur’an says: اوُلاَق َذَخَّتا ُهّٰللا اًدَلَو ٗهَنٰحْبُس١ؕ َوُه ُّيِنَغْلا١ؕ ٗهَل اَم يِف ِتٰوٰمَّسلا َو اَم يِف ِضْرَاْلا١ؕ ْنِا ْمُكَدْنِع ْنِّم 2 ٍۭنٰطْلُس اَذٰهِب١ؕ َنْوُلْوُقَتَا ىَلَع ِهّٰللا اَم اَل َنْوُمَلْعَت Here Allah the Exalted refutes the Messiah, peace be upon him— and any other holy person apart from him—being His son in the following manner: Allah the Exalted is Self-Sufficient and free of all needs.And for someone to be His son negates Allah the Exalted being Self-Sufficient and totally unconcerned with any need.This is because Allah the Exalted would have a son only when that Holy Being would become incapable Himself of doing some task.For example, due to His being Just, He cannot bestow sal- vation upon anyone.Therefore, He developed the need—as the Christians believe—that He should have a Son who could enable salvation to be granted.Or, He had a Son because He developed the need to satisfy His sensual desires or He had a Son for the reason that He developed the need to find an heir.1.The Originator of the heavens and the earth! How can He have a son when He has no consort, and when He has created everything and has knowledge of all things? ( S u rah al-An‘ a m, 6:102) [Publisher] 2.They say, ‘Allah has taken unto Himself a son.’ Holy is He! He is Self- Sufficient.To Him belongs whatsoever is in the heavens and whatso- ever is in the earth.You have no authority for this.Do you say against Allah what you know not? ( S u rah Y u nus, 10:69) [Publisher]

10 of 10 left today