Christian Arguments for the Divinity of Christ & Trinity

Refutation of the Divinity of Christ

Christian Arguments for the Divinity of Christ & Trinity 15 And it is absolutely clear that the son is the equal of the father in what is essential, but because the son is in need of the father to be the son, so if the Messiah, peace be upon him, had been the Son of God Almighty—God forbid—then he would have been the equal of God in His Self-Sufficiency and total lack of any need, but being the Son, he cannot be considered as being free from needs.Then, the Being of the Exalted Maker is not composite because one who is composite is in need of the one who puts it together.And since He is not made up of various parts, how did the Son separate from Him? Then again, being a son calls for separation, whereas being an Eternal Son is opposed to separation.Christian Arguments for the Divinity of Christ & Trinity All the arguments that the Christians have presented in support of the Divinity of Christ and the Trinity, which is the fountain- head of the Divinity of Christ, are in their entirety based simply on believing and are, thus, weak and worthless.I shall state these arguments and present a refutation of them with the help of God, who is free from all defects.These are the most potent arguments for the Divinity of Christ and for the Trinity, which is the origin for the Divinity of Christ.

16 Their First Argument—Trinity Now, pay heed to the arguments for the Trinity and their refutation.THE FIRST ARGUMENT —The first sentence of the Holy Torah: Bara Elohim.Bara is a verb; its meaning is he created — Elohim [God] is its subject.The people belonging to the Christian faith ‘prove’ the Trinity from this sentence because bara is a singular verb whereas Elohim , its subject, is plural, and an indication of the Trinity is found in it.rebuttal of this Argument Elohim is derived from eloah, and eloah is used for both the true God and false deities.Elohim is the plural of eloah.Thus, its meaning will be false gods or true gods.The plural of eloah , elohim , has been used for judges, rulers, angels, and kings as well.The plural meaning of it is not obliga- tory and essential.Eloah is used in the sense of the true God in Nehemiah 9:17, and eloah is used in the meaning of a false god in Daniel 11:37, 38; 2 Chronicles 32:15; Habakkuk 1:11; and Job 12:6.▣ Elohim , which is the plural of eloah , has also been used for a single real person.In Exodus 7:1 and Exodus 4:16, Moses has been called elohim.God says I have made you, O Moses, elohim for the Pharaoh, and elohim for Aaron.▣ Elohim is used in the context of plural false gods in Deuteronomy 13:7, 32:39; Judges 5:8, 10:14; 1 Kings 9:6; 2 Kings 19:18; 1 Chronicles 5:25; 2 Chronicles 13:9, 25:14; Psalms 97:7; Psalms 136:2; and Jeremiah 10:11, 11:12, 16:20.

Christian Arguments for the Divinity of Christ & Trinity 17 ▣ Elohim used in the meaning of kings, rulers, and judges: Exodus 22:28; Deuteronomy 10:17; Psalms 82:1, 138:1; Genesis 6:2, 4; and Exodus 21:6, 22:8, 22:9.▣ Elohim used in the meaning of angels: 1 Samuel 4:8, 28:13; 2 Samuel 7:23; and Psalms 82:6, 8:5.▣ Elohim used in the meaning of the One True God: Genesis 1:1; 1 Kings 18:24, 39.It appears frequently in the plural for false gods, kings, rulers, judges, and angels and sometimes in the meaning of one, and for the True God it is always used in the meaning of absolutely singular.Quite apart from all this—if the intent is [to prove the Divinity of Christ] only through allusions—then it would be bet- ter to first establish the Trinity through some other proofs and then strengthen it through allusions.(Indications) Unequivocal and explicit mention of the doc- trine of Trinity does not exist in the earlier holy scriptures.If believing in it on the basis of such conjectural indications can lead to salvation—as is the fanciful belief of the Christians—then let the Christians heed [what follows] justly and consider the Muslims to have attained salvation.In many places in the Holy Qur’an, the Blessed Being of the Exalted Maker has been referred to in the plural form.See: 1 Part 14, S u rah al- H ijr, Ruk u ‘ 1— اَّنِا ُنْحَن اَنْلَّزَن َرْكِّذلا َو اَّنِا ٗهَل َنْوُظِفٰحَل Verily, We Ourself have sent down this Qur’an, and most surely We will be its Guardian.1.S u rah al- H ijr, 15:10 [Publisher]

18 1 Part 27, S u rah al-W a qi‘ah, Ruk u ‘ 2— ُنْحَن ْمُكٰنْقَلَخ ْوَلَف اَل َنْوُقِّدَصُت We have Ourself created you.Why, then, do you not accept the truth ? 2 Part 27, S u rah al-W a qi‘ah, Ruk u ‘ 2 ۠ — ُنْحَن اَنْرَّدَق ُمُكَنْيَب َتْوَمْلا َو اَم ُنْحَن َنْيِقْوُبْسَمِب We have Ourself ordained death for all of you; and no one can prevail against Us.And the Muslims have faith in all the sentences of the Quran.Thus, if the Prophets Moses and Abraham etc., attained salvation by reciting the plural form Elohim in the phrase bara Elohim which is susceptible to interpretations, then why would the Muslims not attain salvation by reciting the plural forms of the Exalted Being of the Maker? What remains are the full particulars of faith and this, first of all, the Christians do not even avail of, because they believe that human intellect is incapable of understanding the Trinity and the mystery of Divinity.So how could those who preceded the Messiah attain it? Secondly, the details do not exist in the previous scriptures.So after producing all these facts, I submit to the Christians hum- bly: O Christians! What correlation exists between the essence of the Trinity and the use of plural forms? 1.S u rah al-W a qi‘ah, 56:58 [Publisher] 2.S u rah al-W a qi‘ah, 56:61 [Publisher]

Christian Arguments for the Divinity of Christ & Trinity 19 Their Second Argument— Use of Plural Forms for God THE Second ARGUMENT — و یومر یھواہ الوھیم بن ھا آدم کا حد ممنو [way- yō-mer Yah-weh ’ĕ-lō-hîm, hên hā-’ ā -dām h ā -y ā h kə-’a- h ad mim- men-n ū ]1 Translation: ‘And God said, Behold the man is become as one of Us.’ The Trinity is corroborated by this verse.rebuttal— Here, the translation of kə-’a- h ad has been carried out on the style of ordinary translations otherwise its true mean- ing is that of unique.Job 23:13, Song of Solomon 4:9 And the word mim-men-n ū is a composite made up of من — man and ھو — hu.And when combining in Hebrew, just like in Arabic, there is a ه ی ن وقا —omitted ن.A ن — noon is brought to make من ھو man-hu into من نھو man-nahu and in Hebrew ha and noon interchange and so من ھو , after becoming من نھو comes to be من ننو.And upon three ن coming together the first ن — noon changes into a م — meem and the remaining two—yes, both of them—merge into each other.From the above investigation, it becomes clear that this [objec- tive pronoun] is the third person [singular] case and not the first person including others [i.e.plural] case, as the Christians sup- pose it to be.Thus, the meaning of mim-men-nū — ممنو becomes ‘from among him’ and not ‘from among us’.1.Genesis 3:22 [Publisher]

20 Note the use of mim-men-n ū in the third person form [in the following examples]: ▣ Genesis 2:17; 3:3, 11, 17, 22; and 23:6; 26:16; 48:19.▣ Leviticus 2:11; 3:14; 4:19; 5:2, 3,4; 6:15; 7:3, 14, 15, 16, 18; 8:11; 15:16.▣ Exodus 1:9; 4:26; 5:8; 10:26; 12:9, 10; 14:12.Thus, the correct meaning of this verse is the following: Adam became unique from among them.What does that mean? That becoming distinguished from the animals, Adam became unique.Rabbi Shimon writes that God said, look, he is unique from those below like I am Unique from those above.(Talmud) Their Third Argument— Use of the Term ‘Son of Allah’ THE Third ARGUMENT— For the Messiah, peace be on him, being God, or the Son of God is the expression, son of Allah, that has been mentioned in Divine revelation with respect to Christ.The Christians say that the one who is the Son of Allah will neces- sarily be One in being with his Father.The Rebuttal— It is really very clear from the phrases given below that the expression son or son of Allah —as used in the Torah, the Gospels, and their supplements—connotes a rather

Christian Arguments for the Divinity of Christ & Trinity 21 broad range of meanings.If you wish to see the phrases containing ‘son’, take note of: ▣ The Jews are the sons of Jerusalem—(Matthew 23:37); ▣ The Jews are the children of Jerusalem—(Luke 19:44); ▣ The people are the sons of the Resurrection—(Luke 20:36); ▣ Ye are all the children of light, and the children of the day— (1 Thessalonians 5:5); ▣ Ye are of your father the devil—( John 8:44); ▣ The son of perdition—( John 17:12); and ▣ The Jews are the sons of serpents—(Matthew 23:33).Given the manner in which the word son has been applied at these places with a specific meaning and context, why isn’t the expres- sion son of Allah understood in the same manner? Now I will document those phrases in which the specific expression son of Allah has been applied in a vast—yes, indeed, a tremendously vast—context within the holy scriptures: 1.Adam, peace be upon him, the son of God—(Luke 3:38) 2.Seth, peace be upon him, the son of God—(Genesis 6:2) 3.Israel, peace be upon him, the son of God—(Exodus 4:22) 4.Ephraim the firstborn of God—Jeremiah 31:9, 20; for him, the bowels of God were troubled 5.David, peace be upon him, the elder son of God— (Psalms 89:26, 27) 6.Solomon, peace be upon him, the son of God— (1 Chronicles 22:9, 10; 28:6)

22 7.Judges and those who issue religious edicts, the sons of God—(Psalms 82:6) 8.All the Children of Israel, the sons of God—(Romans 9:4; Deuteronomy 14:1, 32:19) 9.All the disciples, the sons of God—(1 John 3:2) 10.All Christians, indeed, all believers, the sons of God— (1 John 3:9) 11.All orphans, the sons of God—(Psalms 68:5) 12.All distinguished and ordinary people, the sons of God— (Matthew 6:6, 18; 7:11; Genesis 6:4) 13.Nobles, the sons of God—(Genesis 6:2) 14.Rebellious children—(Isaiah 30:1) In all these places, the expression son of Allah has been spoken in regard to righteous and virtuous people, or regarding those for whom there are few means of training in the world, or regard- ing the noble and princely, or regarding all people—and in every one of these places, all the sons of Allah are simply the mere crea- tions of God.Not a single one of them is an embodiment of God.All are mere mortals and the progeny of mortals.1 Not one from among them is God.Accordingly, on account of these phrases and expressions, if 1.However, yes, in the commentary on Job 1:6 and 2:1 a British commenta- tor, Thomas Scott, has written that the prophets of Allah—meaning the sons of God—who are mentioned therein, refer to holy angels.Also at another place in Job 38:7, the reference to Prophets of Allah—meaning the sons of God—in the view of commentators means Prophets.This humble one has written this footnote for the sake of Syed Ghulab Shah for I had written in Fa s l al-Khi ta b that all Prophets and angels are sons of God on account of Job 1:6, 2:1 and 38:7.Written by N oo r-ud-D ee n.

Christian Arguments for the Divinity of Christ & Trinity 23 Christ, the son of Allah, is also a mere mortal and not God, then what word or phrase obliges us to understand son of Allah to mean the embodiment of God when it comes to the case of Christ, yet when the same phrase son of Allah is applied to others, we take it to simply mean a human being or the son of a human being? No ‘son of Allah’ expression is unequivocally proven to signify an embodiment of God, whereas Christ being the son of a mortal is proven from the following expressions: ▣ Jesus Christ, the son of David, the son of Abraham— (Matthew 1:1) ▣ Christ is the Son of man—(Matthew 8:20) ▣ He is the son of Adam, a man—(Matthew 9:6) ▣ Whom do men say that I the Son of man am?—(Matthew 16:13) ▣ The Son of man came eating and drinking and they say, Behold a man gluttonous, and a winebibber, a friend of publicans and sinners—(Matthew 11:19) ▣ Is not this the carpenter’s son?—(Matthew 13:55) And it is established from the Gospels that Christ was the son of man and, likewise, the Christians do not deny that Christ was the son of man, but they simultaneously claim this as well, that this son of man was in reality that very God.When he entered his physical body, that very individual was called the Son of Allah.From this much detail, it has at least become clear that to refer to Christ as son of Allah , the literal meaning of ‘son’ is not meant because in that case it becomes necessary that Christ should issue forth from the sperm of God, and that Mary the Ever Truthful become the wife of God.Otherwise, these meanings are incorrect

24 and blatantly wrong.Neither the Muslims nor the Christians believe Mary to be the wife of God; indeed, no intelligent per- son would consider such a thing to be permissible and, thus, the literal meaning of son of Allah and its universally accepted mean- ing would not be intended.On the contrary, the meaning of this expression the son of Allah would be something else and beyond the universally accepted literal meaning.Mark 15:39 records that Christ was the Son of Allah, and in place of this verse, Luke 23:47 records that Christ was eminent and virtuous and righteous; that is to say, instead of ‘Son of Allah’, calls him eminent.Thus, I claim that wherever Christ referred to himself as the son of Allah, there he meant it in the sense of emi- nence and not in the sense of the embodiment of God.What argument exists on account of which we are obliged to concede that by ‘Christ, the son of Allah’ is meant the embod- iment of God? Quite the contrary, what does the phrase son of Allah have to do with righteousness and Divinity? It is not even necessary to apply the meaning of an ordinary believer for the rea- son that even evil-doers are the sons of God, Isaiah—30:1.In short, it is not proven that Christ was the embodiment of God through the phrase son of Allah.For further clarification, I advise pondering over these following verses: ▣ Behold, what manner of love the Father hath bestowed upon us, that we should be called the sons of God… Beloved, now are we the sons of God, and it doth not yet appear what we shall be: but we know that, when he shall appear, we shall be like him—(1 John 3:1–2)

Christian Arguments for the Divinity of Christ & Trinity 25 ▣ And in 1 John 4:7 it is said: And every one that loveth is born of God.▣ And in 1 John 3:9 there is: Whosoever is born of God doth not commit sin; for his seed remaineth in him: and he cannot sin, because he is born of God.In this the children of God and the children of the devil are manifest.▣ To Titus, mine own son after the common faith—(Titus 1:4) ▣ That the sons of God saw the daughters of men that they were fair; and they took them wives of all which they chose— (Genesis 6:2) Ponder over these prominent verses—do any of them have the slightest indication that son of Allah gives the meaning of the embodiment of God? No, not at all.Their Fourth Argument— The Miracles and Marvels of Christ THE Fourth ARGUMENT— The fourth argument consists of those miracles and marvels which Christ demonstrated.Rebuttal—First Miracle—Raising of the dead Evidence of Divinity from those miracles and marvels is similarly invalid since the celebrated, supreme, and greatest miracle was his raising the dead to life, but in this too there was no distinction for Christ from which his Divinity could be proven:

26 ▣ Elijah also raised the dead—(1 Kings 17:22) ▣ Elisha similarly raised the dead—(2 Kings 4:35) ▣ The dead body of Elisha also raised the dead—(2 Kings 13:21) ▣ Ezekiel raised thousands of the ancient dead—(Ezekiel 37:10) ▣ Moses and Aaron made a snake out of wood—(Exodus 7:10) ▣ Moses and Aaron transformed the dust and dirt into living lice—(Exodus 8:17) And for the reason that all these people are Israelites, all should, therefore, be affirmed in accord with the idiom and as attested to by: Exodus 4:22 and Deuteronomy 14:1, 32:19; to being the sons of God, nay even His firstborn.They also raised the dead to life.Thus, the situation demands that these people should also be deemed the embodiment of God without any discrimination.So given that they were not considered to be the embodiment ofGod—in spite of being called son of Allah and raising the dead to life—then how could the Messiah, peace be upon him, be accepted as the embodiment of God? Rebuttal— Second Miracle—Healing the Sick However, Elisha cured Naaman, the Commander, from leprosy—2 Kings 5:14.Joseph restored sight to his father; that is, Jacob—Genesis 46:4, 30.Rebuttal— Third Miracle—transforming paltry victuals and wine into plenitude Elijah transformed a handful of flour and a little oil into much more, so much so that it did not go short for an entire

10 of 10 left today