Reply to the First Question—Muhammad (sa) Had Doubts About His Prophethood and the Holy Qur’an

A Response to Three Questions of a Christian

Reply to the First Question The Guide of Islam, the well-wisher of all humanity, on whom be peace and blessings, had complete conviction and the high- est degree of knowledge and belief in his Messengership and Prophethood, and in his own truth and success.Never did any kind of doubt or uncertainty enter the holy and enlightened heart of the Holy Prophet, peace be upon him, but set aside the men- tion of the Holy Prophet s as himself, even his Companions and fol- lowers like myself hold the highest degree of certainty in his truth and Prophethood.[First] Argument ٖهِذٰه ْۤيِلْيِبَس اْۤوُعْدَا ىَلِا ِهّٰللا١ؔ۫ ىٰلَع ٍةَرْيِصَب اَنَا َو ِنَم ْيِنَعَبَّتا١ؕ َو َنٰحْبُس ِهّٰللا َو ۤاَم اَنَا َنِم S u rah Y u suf, 12:109— َنْيِكِرْشُمْلا This indeed is my way: I call unto Allah1 on the basis of the highest form of knowledge and understanding, and 1.In the idiom of the Holy Qur’an, ‘Allah’ is the name of that Holy Being who is the Possessor of every perfect attribute and is free from every defect.(Noor-ud-Deen)

8 those who are with me are also the same.And Allah is free from every evil and defect, and I would never think of associating any created thing in any matter with Allah.Second Argument of not Wavering by the Holy Prophet, peace be upon him ْلُق ْيِّنِا ىٰلَع ٍةَنِّيَب ْنِّم ْيِّبَّر َو ْمُتْبَّذَك ٖهِب١ؕ اَم ْيِدْنِع اَم َنْوُلِجْعَتْسَت۠ ٖهِب١ؕ ِنِا ُمْكُحْلا اَّلِا ِهّٰلِل١ؕ S u rah al-An‘ a m, 6:58— ُّصُقَي َّقَحْلا َو َوُه ُرْيَخ َنْيِلِصٰفْلا Without any doubt or ambiguity, I have with me from my Lord manifest Signs of the highest order testifying to my truth and veracity and you have rejected this veracity.You seek to hasten the punishment that is to befall you in con- sequence of your rejection; but inflicting this punishment is not within my power.The governance of affairs rests with none except Allah, but bear in mind that those who reject will come to suffer.Allah will continue to manifest the truth which I have brought and He (Allah the Exalted) is, without any uncertainty or doubt, the Greatest Judge to decide between falsehood and truth.He will humiliate the liar and grant victory to the truthful.

Reply to the First Question 9 Third Argument — ْلُق ْيِنَّنِا ْيِنىٰدَه ْۤيِّبَر ىٰلِا ٍطاَرِص ٍمْيِقَتْسُّم١ۚ۬ اًنْيِد اًمَيِق َةَّلِّم َمْيِهٰرْبِا اًفْيِنَح S u rah al-An‘ a m, 6:162 Without any uncertainty or doubt, my Lord has guided me upon the Straight Path—a correct and right religion, the name of which is the Religion of Abraham (Islam), the religion facing one way—entirely free from every type of association of partners with God.Fourth Argument S u rah al-Baqarah, 2:2–3 — َكِلٰذ ُبٰتِكْلا اَل َبْيَر١ۛۖۚ ِهْيِف ّٓمٓلا۰۰ This s u rah named ّٓمٓلا —Alif, L a m, M i m — is the Book (the promise to send which had been made in the 18th chap- ter of Deuteronomy in the Book of Moses, peace be upon him).There is no place for any uncertainty or doubt in it.Fifth Argument — ۤاَّنِا ۤاَنْلَسْرَا ْمُكْيَلِا اًلْوُسَر١ۙ۬ اًدِهاَش ْمُكْيَلَع ۤاَمَك ۤاَنْلَسْرَا ىٰلِا َنْوَعْرِف اًلْوُسَر S u rah al-Muzzammil, 73:16 Without any uncertainty or doubt (says Allah the Exalted) We have sent a Messenger of great grandeur as a Witness

10 over you; and this Messenger is like unto the Messenger We had sent to Pharaoh.S u rah al-Muzzammil, 73:18— َفْيَكَف َنْوُقَّتَت ْنِا ْمُتْرَفَك O ye who deny! Do tell how you will safeguard yourselves from the chastisement if you reject this Messenger; mean- ing that: if Pharaoh was chastised for rejecting Moses, peace be upon him, then how can you, O deniers, escape punishment? This noble verse alludes to the Book of Deuteronomy, chapter 18, verse 18.In short, there are many verses of the same type present in the Holy Qur’an and it is clearly evident from these verses that the Holy Prophet, peace be upon him, held the utmost and abso- lute certainty in his Messengership, Prophethood, veracity, and righteousness.Anyone who believes in the Old Testament and the New Testament can certainly not justly deny this because in Deuteronomy 18:18 and in chapter 3 of Acts it is clearly written that a Prophet like unto Moses, peace be upon him, is to come.Furthermore, it is also written in the Torah that a false prophet who calls himself the like of Moses, peace be upon him, by way of fabrication and falsehood, shall be killed.The Holy Prophet (may my father and mother be sacrificed for him), the Arab Prophet, claimed to be a Messenger like unto Moses, peace be upon him, as has been noted earlier.And reciting the noble verse, َو ُهّٰللا َكُمِصْعَي َنِم ِساَّنلا ( S u rah al-M a ’idah, 5:68)—which means that Allah the Exalted will protect you from the people— he even did away with guards and arrangements for his security.In

Reply to the First Question 11 absolutely no uncertain terms, he announced to Madinah’s Jewish and Christian communities that he would not be killed and, by the grace of Allah, he remained safe from being killed—peace and blessings of Allah be upon him.Christian gentlemen! If the Prophet of Arabia is false (God for- bid) in this claim of Prophethood (and by announcing َنْوَعْرِف اًلْوُسَر ۤاَمَك ۤاَنْلَسْرَا ىٰلِا —Like unto the Messenger We had sent to Pharaoh— which is that very claim to Prophethood that is mentioned in Deuteronomy 18:18 and Acts chapter 3; and it is absolutely clear that the Arab Prophet was not killed), then the Torah is not a holy book, but is instead totally wrong and false, since it is writ- ten in Deuteronomy 18:20 that the false prophet would be killed.However, if the Holy Torah is by way of Divine revelation and true, then our Guide, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, is a true Messenger and—as a matter of fact—the Messenger referred to in chapter 18 of Deuteronomy.It is for this very reason that the Noble Qur’an repeatedly declares both the Holy Prophet—Ahmad Mujtab a [ the Elect ] , Muhammad Mu st af a s as [the Chosen]—and itself to be ٌقِّدَصُّم اَمِّل ْمُكَعَم [fulfilling that which is with you].( S u rah A l-e-‘Imr a n, 3:82) What does this mean? It means that the Noble Qur’an and the Arab Prophet, by his advent, security, and being safeguarded from being killed, proved the Torah to be true.Now, take further heed: the Noble Qur’an makes the claim that there is no contradiction in the Quran.S u rah an-Nis a ’, 4:83— َو ْوَل َناَك ْنِم ِدْنِع ِرْيَغ ِهّٰللا اْوُدَجَوَل ِهْيِف اًفاَلِتْخا اًرْيِثَك

12 If the Noble Qur’an had not been the Word of Allah the Exalted, then there would necessarily have been contra- dictions—indeed much contradiction—in it.This is because contradictions can arise in two ways: First, that the themes of the Noble Qur’an be falsified by the law of nature, and the meanings of the Holy Qur’an be opposed to the Divine system and dictates of human nature, or that our natural faculties be unable to bear them.The second way a contradiction may occur is for the contents of the Holy Qur’an to be opposed to each other.Ponder! An unlettered Arab from unlettered Arabia ( ُۡ ۡ مَا اَسۡاَلُک ِّ ن �َع ۡ ج ِّ اَللّٰھُم َّ فَر ُۡ ۡ مَا اَسۡاَلُک ِّ ن �َع ۡ ج ِّ اَللّٰھُم َّ فَر ) [O Allah! Relieve me of that which I ask of You] recited this Qur’an to the people.Thereafter, thirteen centu- ries of the most intense research by natural philosophers failed to falsify any subject of the Holy Qur’an, the Word of the Gracious God, and, thus—through this experimentation—it became cer- tain that they would be unable to falsify it in the future as well.Regarding the second form of contradiction, I wish to say the following: The Noble Qur’an was recited to the people over a span of twenty-three years.During this lengthy duration of time the Holy Prophet, peace be upon him, was sometimes alone and sometimes governing over thousands upon thousands of people.Sometimes he was battling enemies and sometimes he was sitting among his friends; sometimes he was at home with his wives and sometimes

Reply to the First Question 13 in pursuit of enemies; sometimes he was speaking with the igno- rant and faithless people of Arabia and sometimes debating with the scholars of the Christians and the Jews.At times he was short of provisions and at other times he was self-sufficient, etc., etc.During such times of varying circumstances , the thoughts of a weak individual can never remain steady, and discord and deviation inevitably transpire.Yet, there is no discord in the Holy Qur’an even though it was revealed over a period of twenty-three years under varying circumstances.The Holy Qur’an has also said to its own credit: اًبٰتِك اًهِباَشَتُّم [‘a Book, whose verses are mutually supporting’].1 Having proven from the Holy Qur’an that neither the Holy Prophet, peace be upon him, entertained any uncertainty or doubt, nor any contra- diction exists in the Holy Qur’an, I will now focus on the question of the critic.Why? Because, as mentioned above, it stands proven to me from the Holy Book and the Praiseworthy Furq a n, 2 that the Most Noble Messenger, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, held the highest degree of certainty, and there is no contradiction in the Holy Qur’an; yet the critic alleges that the Holy Qur’an depicts the Guide of Islam as being riddled with doubt.The primary argu- ment of the critic is the following verse of S u rah al-Baqarah: S u rah al-Baqarah, 2:148— ُّقَحْلَا ْنِم َكِّبَّر اَلَف َّنَنْوُكَت َنِم َنْيِرَتْمُمْلا 1.S u rah az-Zumar, 39:24 [Publisher] 2.Furq a n (Discrimination) is another name of the Holy Qur’an.[Publisher]

14 The first Rebuttal— اَل َّنَنْوُكَت — la tak u nanna is a form of naf i [negation] not of nahy [prohibition], and it is to lay emphasis that the ّ ن [ n u n with shadd ] has been added to its end to make it اَل َّنَنْوُكَت.The ّ ن cannot come in cases of the past or present.Thus, اَل َّنَنْوُكَت is a future tense.As such, based on this analysis, the meaning of this verse is: This is the truth from your Lord (because this truth has become established based on revelation and arguments) so you will never be from among those who doubt.The Second Rebuttal— I accept [for the sake of argument] that la tak u nanna is not a form of naf i , but rather, of nahy.However, I would like to point out that nahy is of two types: one which demands the abandoning of an action and the other which demands the non-existence of the action.The objection of the critic is based on the understanding that, here, nahy should be taken to mean the abandoning of an action; that is, the per- son addressed should abandon the action of doubting.However, I contend that, here, doubting is non-existent and the intent of nahy is that just as doubting is currently non-existent, it should remain so in the future as well.The Third Rebuttal— O critic! What indication is there in the verse اَلَف َّنَنْوُكَت to make us believe that اَل َّنَنْوُكَت is addressed to the Guide of Islam, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him? I can affirm on the basis of the above-mentioned proofs that the Holy Prophet, peace be upon him, had full faith in his Messengership and there is no contradiction in the Noble Quran.Therefore, it is

Reply to the First Question 15 proved that اَل َّنَنْوُكَت is addressed to some wavering sceptic and not the Holy Prophet, peace be upon him.The Fourth Rebuttal— I accept [for the sake of argu- ment] that this phrase َّ َ تَكُوْنَن ال addresses our Holy Guide, peace be upon him.Nonetheless, the manner of speech in the Arabic and Hebrew languages is very close to each other, and the parts of the [previous]holy books that are unadulterated and the Holy Qur’an are both the words of the same Speaker and both have issued forth from the same Source.It is the idiom of both that the address is made to the Supreme Founder, but the intended audience are the followers of the Founder.The person addressed is one individual, but the intended addressee is another.▣ See Jeremiah: Alas! for that day is great, so that none is like it: it is even the time of Jacob’s trouble… ( Jeremiah 30:7–10) ▣ Fear thou not, O Jacob my servant, saith the Lord… ( Jeremiah 46:28) ▣ The Lord hath also a controversy with Judah, and will punish Jacob according to his ways… (Hosea 12:2) ▣ But truly I am full of power by the spirit of the Lord, and of judgment, and of might, to declare unto Jacob his transgres- sion, and to Israel his sin.(Micah 3:8) ▣ For the Lord hath turned away the excellency of Jacob, as the excellency of Israel… (Nahum 2:2) ▣ Woe unto thee, Chorazin (this is the name of a village which is not worthy of regret and rebuke)! woe unto thee, Bethsaida! (this is also a village)… (Matthew 11:21) ▣ O Jerusalem, Jerusalem (this is Baitul-Muqaddas), thou that killest the prophets… (Matthew 23:37)

16 Such holy books can be found in hundreds of places.Now observe such usage from the Noble Qur’an: 1.اَهُّيَاٰۤي ُّيِبَّنلا اَذِا ُمُتْقَّلَط َءٓاَسِّنلا — O Prophet! When you people divorce women...( S u rah a t - T al a q, 65:2) 2.اَهُّيَاٰۤي ُّيِبَّنلا ِقَّتا َهّٰللا َو اَل ِعِطُت َنْيِرِفٰكْلا َو َنْيِقِفٰنُمْلا١ؕ َّنِا َهّٰللا َناَك اًمْيِلَع اًمْيِكَح —O Prophet, have the fear of God, and neither follow the disbelievers nor obey the hypocrites.Verily, Allah the Exalted is Aware of all that you (addressing the general public) do.( S u rah al-A h z a b, 33:2) 3.َو ْلَٔـْس ْنَم اَنْلَسْرَا ْنِم َكِلْبَق ْنِم ۤاَنِلُسُّر —Ask those Messengers who came before you ( S u rah az-Zukhruf, 43:46) In these places, note who is addressed by the word يا [O!] and who by ۡ طَلَّقۡتُم [you people divorce]; who is addressed by اِلٰی [to]; who appears to be addressed by the word َ تَعۡمَلُوۡن [do]; who is referred to by ۡ مَن [whoever]; and who is meant by قَبۡلِك [before you].The Fifth Rebuttal— I concede [for the sake of argument] that َّ َتَكُوْنَن ال is in the form of nahy [prohibition], and even that nahy conveys the meaning of abandoning [an action], and even that the person addressed is the Chief and Pride of all Creation, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, and furthermore, that he is indeed the one intended to be addressed; nevertheless, I assert that ْ تَكُن َ ال is given in the form of nahy, with the ّ ن [ n u n with shadd ] added for emphasis.The emphatic ّ ن never comes for the past or the present;

Reply to the First Question 17 upon whichever verb it comes, it transforms it into a future verb.Therefore, the meaning of 1 اَل َّنَنْوُكَت َنِم َنْيِرَتْمُمْلا would be as follows: O Muhammad, you have never been the one to doubt in the past nor the present.Now, as you face the future, remain likewise without any doubt or uncertainty.This is a divine prayer so to speak, which is certainly accepted.Furthermore, given that your temperament is not one to entertain any doubts about such a teaching [as Islam], therefore, My aims have now become firmly established with arguments.The Sixth Rebuttal— I allow, for the sake of argument, that reluctance actually occurred; so, can such hesitation result in dis- missal of a person from the office of prophethood based on the principles accepted by the Christians? Most certainly not.Consider the Books of Exodus and Judges from the Torah of Moses, peace be upon him.Moses, peace be upon him, was selected by Allah the Exalted to save the Children of Israel.Thereupon, Moses says: ‘Who am I, that I should go unto Pharaoh, and that I should bring forth the children of Israel out of Egypt?’ (Exodus 3:11) Then, Moses, peace be upon him, started offering excuses that he could not speak well and so Allah the Exalted said emphat- ically, ‘You go; I am with you.’ Even then—according to the Christians—on account of his weaknesses, he was not satisfied, so he submitted that someone else be sent to Egypt.Thereupon, 1.S u rah al-Baqarah, 2:148; S u rah al-An‘ a m, 6:115 [Publisher]

18 the anger of the Exalted Maker (says the present-day Torah) was roused.See, ‘And the anger of the Lord was kindled against Moses.’ (Exodus 4:14) And all that Gideon had done is manifest from Judges 6:36–40.1 How he persistently experimented! Let fair-minded Christians ponder over this.1.And Gideon said unto God, If thou wilt save Israel by mine hand, as thou hast said, Behold, I will put a fleece of wool in the floor; and if the dew be on the fleece only, and it be dry upon all the earth beside , then shall I know that thou wilt save Israel by mine hand, as thou hast said.And it was so: for he rose up early on the morrow, and thrust the fleece together, and wringed the dew out of the fleece, a bowl full of wa- ter.And Gideon said unto God, Let not thine anger be hot against me, and I will speak but this once: let me prove, I pray thee, but this once with the fleece; let it now be dry only upon the fleece, and upon all the ground let there be dew.And God did so that night: for it was dry upon the fleece only, and there was dew on all the ground.(Judges 6:36–40) [Publisher]

10 of 10 left today