Reply to the Second Question
A Response to Three Questions of a Christian
Reply to the Second Question While reflecting upon this question, I studied the Noble Qur’an several times, but despite careful consideration and deep ponder- ing, I could not find any verse of the Holy Qur’an from which the critic extracted such a question.This humble one has divided the issue raised by the critic into three parts for ease of discussion.First Part of the Critic’s Question ‘If Muhammad s as had been a Messenger, he would not have responded so helplessly to questions put to him at that time saying that God knows; meaning, I do not know.’ My humble self submits that all the questions that were put to the Holy Prophet, peace be upon him, by opponents and disci- ples that could possibly be answered, were indeed answered by the Holy Prophet, peace be upon him.The Qur’an contains the answers to the following listed questions; unbiased minds should pay heed:
20 The First INQUIRY— When the Noble Qur’an mentioned the month of Ramadan and the moon to start fasting, people inquired about the moon of Ramadan and other moons.Accordingly, the Holy Qur’an mentions this question after mention of the month of Ramadan and states: S u rah al-Baqarah, 2:190— َكَنْوُلَٔـْسَي ِنَع ِةَّلِهَاْلا They ask you concerning the moons other than that of Ramadan; meaning, what needs to be done during those months? The response to this question is given immediately after the ques- tion as follows: S u rah al-Baqarah, 2:190— ْلُق َيِه ُتْيِقاَوَم ِساَّنلِل َو ِّجَحْلا Say in reply to this question that they are a means for measuring time for the general good of mankind and in some moons the rites of the Pilgrimage are performed.The Second INQUIRY— S u rah al-Baqarah, 2:216— َكَنْوُلَٔـْسَي اَم اَذ َنْوُقِفْنُي They ask what should be spent.The response given by the Holy Qur’an is: — ۤاَم ْمُتْقَفْنَا ْنِّم ٍرْيَخ ِنْيَدِلاَوْلِلَف َو َنْيِبَرْقَاْلا َو ىٰمٰتَيْلا َو ِنْيِكٰسَمْلا َو ِنْبا ِلْيِبَّسلا S u rah al-Baqarah, 2:216
Reply to the Second Question 21 Whatever of wealth you spend should be for parents and relatives and orphans and the poor and wayfarers.The Third INQUIRY— S u rah al-Baqarah, 2:218— َكَنْوُلَٔـْسَي ِنَع ِرْهَّشلا ِماَرَحْلا They ask you concerning the Sacred Month as to what is the commandment regarding fighting therein.The reply given is: S u rah al-Baqarah, 2:218— ْلُق ٌلاَتِق ِهْيِف ٌرْيِبَك١ؕ َو ٌّدَص ْنَع ِلْيِبَس ِهّٰللا Respond to them that fighting in this month is an evil act, and it necessarily results in interfering in worship like H ajj and ‘Umrah.The fourth INQUIRY— S u rah al-Baqarah, 2:220— َكَنْوُلَٔـْسَي ِنَع ِرْمَخْلا َو ِرِسْيَمْلا They ask you concerning wine and gambling.The response given is to tell them: S u rah al-Baqarah, 2:220— ۤاَمِهْيِف ٌمْثِا ٌرْيِبَك Drinking [wine] and gambling are a grave and evil sin.The fifth INQUIRY— S u rah al-Baqarah, 2:220— َكَنْوُلَٔـْسَي اَم اَذ َنْوُقِفْنُي They ask what should be spent.
22 The reply given is to tell them: َوْفَعْلا —Spend what you can spare after [fulfilling] your needs.The sixth INQUIRY— S u rah al-Baqarah, 2:223— َو َكَنْوُلَٔـْسَي ِنَع ِضْيِحَمْلا They ask whether or not intercourse is permissible with a woman during menstruation.The reply given is: S u rah al-Baqarah, 2:223— ْلُق َوُه ىًذَا ١ۙ اوُلِزَتْعاَف َءٓاَسِّنلا يِف ِضْيِحَمْلا Tell them that copulation during the days of menstruation is painful.Keep away from the company of women during the days of menstruation.The Seventh INQUIRY— S u rah al-Baqarah, 2:221— َكَنْوُلَٔـْسَي ِنَع ىٰمٰتَيْلا They ask you concerning the orphans.The response given is to tell them: S u rah al-Baqarah, 2:221— ٌحاَلْصِا ْمُهَّل ٌرْيَخ Safeguarding the wealth, honour, and nurturing of orphans — indeed their reformation and betterment care- fully in every way — is an act of goodness.
Reply to the Second Question 23 The Eighth INQUIRY— S u rah al-M a ’idah, 5:5— َكَنْوُلَٔـْسَي اَم ۤاَذ َّلِحُا ْمُهَل They ask what is made lawful for them to eat.The reply given is to tell them: S u rah al-M a ’idah, 5:5— َّلِحُا ُمُكَل ُتٰبِّيَّطلا All things considered clean and desirable among the pure-natured of the major civilizations have been made lawful for you.The Ninth INQUIRY— S u rah al-Anf a l, 8:2— َكَنْوُلَٔـْسَي ِنَع ِلاَفْنَاْلا They ask you about the division of the spoils of war.The reply given is to tell them: S u rah al-Anf a l, 8:2— ُلاَفْنَاْلا ِهّٰلِل َو ِلْوُسَّرلا The division of the spoils is the prerogative of Allah, then His Messenger.The tenth INQUIRY— S u rah al-Kahf, 18:84— َكَنْوُلَٔـْسَي ْنَع يِذ ِنْيَنْرَقْلا They ask you about the story of Dhul-Qarnain.
24 The response given is to recite to them the story, starting with: S u rah al-Kahf, 18:85— اَّنِا اَّنَّكَم ٗهَل يِف ِضْرَاْلا [We established him in the earth.] and it was completed to the extent needed.This Dhul-Qarnain is the one mentioned in Daniel 8:4.The Eleventh INQUIRY— S u rah Ta H a , 20:106— َو َكَنْوُلَٔـْسَي ِنَع ِلاَبِجْلا They ask you, will such strong mountains remain forever? The reply given is to tell them: S u rah Ta H a , 20:106— اَهُفِسْنَي ْيِّبَر اًفْسَن My Lord will destroy the mountains and shatter them into pieces.The Twelfth INQUIRY— S u rah Ban i Isr a ’ i l, 17:86— َو َكَنْوُلَٔـْسَي ِنَع ِحْوُّرلا They ask you who has made the Quran.The answer given is to tell them: ْنِم ِرْمَا ْيِّبَر —This Qur’an is by the command of my Lord; and it is indeed His Word.Bear in mind that I have translated روح — r uh to mean the Quran.This is for several reasons: First, in the Holy Qur’an itself this revelation and the Divine Word
Reply to the Second Question 25 has been called r uh, and some parts of the Holy Qur’an explain other parts.See: S u rah ash-Sh u r a , 42:53— َو َكِلٰذَك ۤاَنْيَحْوَا َكْيَلِا اًحْوُر ْنِّم اَنِرْمَا And thus have We revealed to you the روح — r uh by Our command.Secondly, before and after the verse under discussion, there is mention only of the Noble Quran.However, it is possible to take the word r uh to mean the angel who used to bring revelation, who is called Jibr a ’ i l [Gabriel] by the Muslims.We could also say that the question was asked whether r uh was a creation or something outside of creation.The answer given was that the r uh is حادث — ha dith [a nascent creation] and came into being by the direct command of the Lord.The Thirteenth INQUIRY— S u rah an-Nis a ’, 4:154— َكُلَٔـْسَي ُلْهَا ِبٰتِكْلا The Jews and the Christians—the People of the Book— ask of you: S u rah an-Nis a ’, 4:154— ْنَا َلِّزَنُت ْمِهْيَلَع اًبٰتِك َنِّم ِءٓاَمَّسلا That you cause a Book to descend upon them from heaven.The People of the Book asked this question because Muhammad, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, claimed to be a Prophet like unto Moses and the one concerning whom the prophecy is found in chapter 18 of the Book of Deuteronomy in the Torah.
26 The prophecy concerning that Prophet was written in the Torah as follows: I will raise [them] up a Prophet [from among their breth- ren,] like unto thee [Moses], and will put my words in his mouth[; and he shall speak unto them all that I shall com- mand him].(Deuteronomy 18:18) Thus, necessarily, no such book shall descend for that Prophet from heaven which should be all written down already because the Torah states: ‘I will put My words in his mouth.’ Thus, in reply to this question it was stated: S u rah an-Nis a ’, 4:154— ْدَقَف اْوُلَاَس ىٰۤسْوُم َرَبْكَا ْنِم َكِلٰذ اْۤوُلاَقَف اَنِرَا َهّٰللا ًةَرْهَج [They asked Moses a greater thing than this: they said, Show us Allah openly.] The remaining five Queries are the ones, in reply to which the Holy Prophet, peace be upon him, said: ‘My Lord knows.’ First: S u rah al-A‘r a f, 7:188— َكَنْوُلَٔـْسَي ِنَع ِةَعاَّسلا َناَّيَا اَهىٰسْرُم They ask you, when will the Hour of Judgment come to pass? The reply given was: S u rah al-A‘r a f, 7:188— ْلُق اَمَّنِا اَهُمْلِع َدْنِع ْيِّبَر Say to them: The knowledge thereof is only with my Lord.
Reply to the Second Question 27 Second: S u rah adh-Dh a riy a t, 51:13— َنْوُلَٔـْسَي َناَّيَا ُمْوَي ِنْيِّدلا They ask: When will the Day of Recompense be? No answer was given to this, probably for the reason that it forever remains [the Day of Recompense], or because they were referring to the Day of Judgment.Third: S u rah an-N a zi‘ a t, 79:43— َكَنْوُلَٔـْسَي ِنَع ِةَعاَّسلا َناَّيَا اَهىٰسْرُم They ask: When will the Hour come? The reply given to this was: S u rah an-N a zi‘ a t, 79:44–45— ىٰلِا َكِّبَر اَهىٰهَتْنُم َمْيِف َتْنَا ْنِم اَهىٰرْكِذ۰۰ Why are you concerned with these matters? The knowl- edge thereof rests only with the Lord.Fourth: S u rah al-A h z a b, 33:64 — َكُلَٔـْسَي ُساَّنلا ِنَع ِةَعاَّسلا They ask concerning the Hour.The reply given to this was: S u rah al-A h z a b, 33:64— اَمَّنِا اَهُمْلِع َدْنِع ِهّٰللا The knowledge of it is with Allah alone.
28 Fifth: S u rah al-A‘r a f, 7:188 — َكَنْوُلَٔـْسَي َكَّنَاَك ٌّيِفَح اَهْنَع They ask you respecting the Hour as if you were really engaged in figuring out such things.The answer given to this was: S u rah al-A‘r a f, 7:188 — اَهُمْلِع َدْنِع ِهّٰللا The knowledge of this is [only] with Allah.In any case, no defect arises in Prophethood by not giving an answer to this question because Jesus says, ‘But of that day and hour knoweth no man, no, not the angels of heaven, but my Father only’ (Matthew 24:36).And at another place he says, ‘But of that day and that hour knoweth no man , no, not the angels which are in heaven, neither the Son, but the Father’ ( Mark 13:32).The critic and his ilk should ponder over the verdict of Jesus concerning this Hour.If not providing the time of such an Hour creates some fault in Prophethood and Messengership, then a fault will arise not only in the Prophethood and Messengership of Jesus, but also in the presumed ‘Divinity’ of Jesus as believed by the Christians.
Reply to the Second Question 29 Second Part of the Critic’s Question Question— He would not have misstated the number of A sha b- e-Kahf [the People of the Cave].Reply— Neither the Noble Qur’an nor the Noble Messenger has mentioned the number of the A sha b-e-Kahf , so it cannot be understood why the critic has made the allegation of misstate- ment.When the Holy Prophet has given no such number and has not mentioned it at all, how does the allegation of misstatement arise? It appears to me that the critic has been misled by someone in raising this question, because the account of A sha b-e-Kahf in the Holy Qur’an has the following verse concerning their number: ٌةَعْبَس َّو ْمُهُنِماَث ْمُهُبْلَك١ؕ ْلُق ْۤيِّبَّر ُمَلْعَا ْمِهِتَّدِعِب اَّم ْمُهُمَلْعَي اَّلِا ٌلْيِلَقَنْوُلْوُقَيَس ٌةَثٰلَث ْمُهُعِباَّر ْمُهُبْلَك١ۚ َو َنْوُلْوُقَي ٌةَسْمَخ ْمُهُسِداَس ْمُهُبْلَك اًۢمْجَر ِبْيَغْلاِب١ۚ َو َنْوُلْوُقَي Translation: People will say, ‘They were three, the fourth was their dog.’ Others say, ‘They were five, the sixth was their dog,’ guessing at random.And yet others say, ‘They were seven, the eighth was their dog.’ You should tell them (O Muhammad): ‘My Lord alone knows their number.None knows them except a few.’ ( S u rah al-Kahf, 18:23) From this holy verse it is manifestly clear that people will say vari- ous things and will give different counts regarding the number of A sha b-e-Kahf, but these people’s guessing at random is not wor- thy of any reliance.In short, the Holy Prophet of Arabia has made no mention of any number regarding the A sha b-e-Kahf.
30 Third Part of the Critic’s Question Question— And he would not have said that the Sun becomes concealed in, or sinks into a murky pool, whereas the Sun is 90 million times larger than the Earth, so how can it possibly be con- cealed in a pool of murky water? reply—Dear critic! It is nowhere written in the Noble Qur’an that the Sun becomes concealed in, or sinks into a murky pool.The Christian priests have wrongly believed for a long time that it is written in the Holy Qur’an, whereas it is not so written in the Quran.The fact is that at one place, the Noble Qur’an gives the account of that Dhul-Qarnain who is mentioned in the Book of Prophet Daniel 8:4.And it is stated therein that when that King of Media and Persia went on achieving victories and reached the western region of the Levant, then, in the western part of that particular territory, at one place Dhul-Qarnain saw what appeared to be the ‘Sun setting in a pool of murky water’.It is most likely that Dhul- Qarnain had occasion to witness this scene when he reached the banks of the Black Sea or the Danube.I accept that the Sun is a great deal larger than the Earth, but because it is so very distant from us, it appears to be very small, and due to the spherical shape of the Earth, it appears to us at the time of sunset that it is setting behind some part of the Earth or the peak of a mountain, or behind a tree on the horizon for the viewer, or if there is water and marshy land to the west of us, as was the case for Dhul-Qarnain, then the Sun will appear to be setting into that water and marshy land at the time of sunset.