Part I

Revelation, Rationality, Knowledge & Truth, Part 24

‘He was indifferent to luxury and even to ordinary comfort; but he was by no means an ascetic.’

As for the nature of his Divine Revelation, the author of the above-quoted article, states:

“There has been much discussion about the “divine sign” (Satpdviov) of which Socrates used to speak as a supernatural voice which frequently gave him guidance, according to Xenophon telling him to act or not to act, according to Plato only restraining him from action, never instigating. Later writers, especially in Christian times, speak of it as a daemon, genius or attendant spirit. For this there is no authority whatever in Plato and Xenophon.’”

‘... he seems to have had certain vivid presentiments which he took for special divine monitions; and it is possible, as has been suggested, that he was subject to occasional hallucinations of hearing, such as may occur even in quite sane and healthy persons.’

Socrates’ revelation is thus respectfully dismissed as hallucination.

In reality, there is no contradiction in Socrates. Whatever contradiction there is, has to be in the mind of the author who apparently defended Socrates by suggesting that his hallucinations were not all that bad as those of psychic people suffering from mental aberrations. Hallucinations can also sometimes be experienced by sane healthy persons as in the case of Socrates.

What sympathy, what a condescending attitude to Socrates by some modern writer who has faith in Socrates but has no faith in his belief in God. However condescending that remark may be, it is no tribute to the greatness of Socrates who does not stand in need of any apology. Did not the same misfortune befall all the prophets of God before or after him? Each of them was accused of hallucination by the society he addressed though not as politely as the author of the said article has treated Socrates. All such accusers knew full well that the prophets they accused of such mental aberrations were neither frail in mind nor weak of moral health. They were the wisest people of their time, sound of head and heart, respected as such by the society in which they grew from the age of their childhood to that of full maturity. None of them is accused of behaving in any manner like a soothsayer prior to their claim to prophethood; none is ever reported even after that to act as though he were hallucinating. Hallucinations are always unpredictable, disjointed and incoherent. The voices that some hallucinators hear do seem to address them as though they were from God but they never reveal to them any philosophy or way of life which can be shared and practised by others. There is no logic in what they hear and no logic in what they say. Hallucinations never give birth to rationality.

To mix up hallucination with prophecy is but a morbid attempt to discredit Divine revelation. The experience of the prophets of God is essentially different! Truth, wisdom and rationality are their distinctive features while the hostile society they confront symbolizes dogma, falsehood and superstition. The message that the prophets deliver is always based on sound moral code. They breathe wisdom, they exude piety, they advocate rationality, they preach morality, justice, moderation, understanding, kindness, patience, service and sacrifice. Is this the prophetic message delivered to them during their maddest moments of ‘hallucination’? What hallucination indeed! One only wishes that their accusers had remembered their own hallucinatory experiences while they were stricken, for instance, by a severe attack of septic fever or typhoid. Do they ever remember a wise code of life bestowed upon them during those temporary derangements which could stand the test of time and deliver a new message to mankind to be taken seriously by them?

Rationality and hallucination never cohabit healthy minds. How we wish that whoever accused him of hallucination had further elaborated his statement by quoting from his own experience. Had a sane person ever learnt an exceptionally sound philosophy of life through his occasional outbursts of delusion? How we wish the author had remembered that all the wisdom and all the piety and all the rationality and faith, which Socrates displayed, he had learnt from the so-called voices of his ‘hallucination’! If his faith in revelation is to be rejected as based on hallucination, then all his philosophy of life, and all his wisdom must also be rejected by the same token. He can never be separated from his rationality.

We accept the whole of Socrates. Noble was his character, noble his vision, noble was the life he led. Such as he are never forged by hallucinations. Peace was with him when he was born, peace was with him while he lived, peace was with him when he died smilingly — while the throng of his admirers bitterly wailed and cried and sobbed around him. Athens had never seen the departure of a soul as noble as that of Socrates.

Allah be pleased with him! May He shower His choicest blessings upon him; but woe to his murderers. Athens will never see the like of him again!

19,

21,

REFERENCES

The New Encyclopaedia Britannica. Vol 24, 15th ed,

The New Encyclopaedia Britannica. Vol 25, 15th ed.

GUTHRIE, W.K.C. (1950) The Greek Philosophers. Methuen & Co, p.72

Translation of 2:33 by Maulawi Sher Ali.

Translation of 1:5-6 by Maulawi Sher Ali.

GUTHRIE, W.K.C. (1950) The Greek Philosophers. Methuen & Co, p.79

VLASTOS, G. (1991) Socrates, Ironist and Moral Philosopher. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, p.200

GRAYLING, A.C. (1995) Philosophy —. A Guide Through The Subject. Oxford University Press, Oxford, p.360

GRAYLING, A.C. (1995) Philosophy — A Guide Through The Subject. Oxford University Press, Oxford, p.364

vLASTOS, G. (1991) Socrates, Ironist and Moral Philosopher. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, p.157

VLASTOS, G. (1991) Socrates, Ironist and Moral Philosopher. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, p. 167

VLASTOS, G. (1991) Socrates, Ironist and Moral Philosopher. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, p.168

VLASTOS, G. (1991) Socrates, Ironist and Moral Philosopher. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, p.169

VLASTOS, G. (1991) Socrates, Ironist and Moral Philosopher. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 170-171

VLASTOS, G. (1991) Socrates, Ironist and Moral Philosopher. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, p. 173

VLASTOS, G. (1991) Socrates, Ironist and Moral Philosopher. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, p.174

·

10 of 10 left today