Part VII
Revelation, Rationality, Knowledge & Truth, Part 3
No man with common sense would hold a brief for such senseless and irrational understanding of God’s designs. Rationality and common sense must be granted their due role in the interpretation of religious prophecies and parables. The golden age of the ultimate unification of man could only be consummated if a single Reformer appeared in the name of God, in a single religion of His choice. This, the only rational solution of the problems confronting the religious world of the latter days, has been firmly rejected by the very people who needed it for their survival. They continue to cling, instead, to their empty vision of a golden age which is nothing but a mirage.
The above scenario is a genuine attempt to explain the self-contradictory position of each religion regarding the role it will play in the ultimate redemption of mankind. They open the doors of hope and shut them themselves. The case of the Muslims is only opposite in sequence. They begin to shut the doors by pronouncing the absolute finality of the Holy Prophet* and no sooner have they done so than they begin to open them again. In reality, however, their stance remains unchanged. Hence the drama played on the Muslim stage is essentially no different from the one played on the stages of other world religions. Despite declaring the total uncompromising finality of the Holy Prophet™ they cling no less eagerly to the figure of Prophet Jesus*. They claim that he will certainly come after the Holy Prophet* yet the manner they assign to his coming makes his coming impossible. Thus, for all practical purposes their position remains unaltered.
he Rationale of Finality The finality of any prophet can be observed with
reference to his message as well as with reference to his status. It is possible for a prophet to be final in his message and his status, yet it is also possible for another lesser prophet to come after him without violating his finality. It is this aspect of prophethood that we are going to thoroughly examine now.
The belief in the finality of the law in the Holy Qur’an and in the finality of the Prophet* to whom this law was revealed, is unanimously held by all Muslims. The Holy Qur’an — a complete code of life — claims for itself a promise of eternal Divine protection from interpolation by human hands. If this claim is right, as the Muslims believe and demonstrate it to be, the bearer of such a book must be accepted as the last law- bearing prophet. This is clearly understandable and is so endorsed by the entire world of Islam without exception. But from the non-Muslim vantage point, it is difficult to comprehend how any Book could fulfil the needs of all ages and defy the requirements for change during the times to come. Add to this the claim in the Holy Qur’an of universality and the problem will increase manifold. How can it be logically explained that any Divine Book could satisfactorily address the ethnic and parochial problems of all mankind alike? There are Europeans, Americans, Africans, Arabs, Russians, Israelis, and numerous people of Asian origin with different ethnic backgrounds and inherited cultures. Their political and social traditions also differ so widely that it is difficult to visualize how a single universal code of religious law could satisfy them with equal justice.
In answer to both these questions, the Holy Qur’an claims that all its teachings are founded on the human psyche which is common to mankind and unchangeable in relation to time. Any teaching which perfectly corresponds to the human psyche becomes unchangeable. It is this principle that the Holy Qur’an alludes to when it says:
J AS SSS Sp GS gles Spas
30:31 *O}aby So set thy face to the service of religion as one devoted to God. And follow the nature made by Allah — the nature in which. He has created mankind.
There is no altering the creation of God. That is the right religion. But most men know not?
Indeed the nature created by God cannot be altered. Even the atheist must concede that human nature has remained universally unaltered since time immemorial. But a Book of Law corresponding to this unalterable nature can itself be changed all the same by the interference of humans. The Holy Qur’an takes care of this danger by declaring it is a well-protected book.
15:10 * ofa od JUL, SU OY FES UL
Verily, it is We Who have sent down this Exhortation, and most surely We are its Guardian.’
History has proved this claim to be right. Hence the Prophet* who was bestowed this Book has to be accepted as the last law-bearer. Nothing in this claim is irrational, but when it is suggested that even non-law-bearing prophets cannot come, the jurisdiction of finality is overextended without any rational justification. No sooner have they made this claim of absolute finality than they venture to demolish it themselves. The cracks begin to appear the moment they hasten to exempt Jesus* from this all- pervasive law of finality.
When confronted with this dilemma, they dismiss it with a mere wave of their hand as though it were no dilemma at all.
The reappearance of Jesus* as a prophet after Prophet Muhammad, they argue, does not contradict his absolute finality on the following counts:
e Jesus would be brought back from a stock of prophets who had already been commissioned before the advent of Prophet Muhammad*. Thus his finality will not be violated. It can only be violated if a prophet is raised after his advent even if that prophet brings no new law and is selected by God from within his own Ummah (people).
e Jesus’ prophethood would be the one granted to him during his advent prior to Islam.
e Moreover because during his second advent he would be subordinated to the Holy Prophet*, he would no longer be held as independent.
Hence by being an older prophet and by becoming subordinated, he would not violate the seal of prophethood. As such, their concept of finality only means that new prophets cannot be commissioned while old prophets can be brought back; but this is sheer absurdity. What manner of an All-Wise God would He be who would pass the verdict of absolute finality in favour of anyone despite His knowledge that a prophet would certainly be needed after him? The question of old or new is irrelevant. Central to the issue is the question of need.
The need for another prophet after the advent of the last is an intrinsically contradictory belief. Faced with this dilemma the Ulema always twist the issue by arguing that the need for the advent of a prophet may occur after the final prophet had come and gone. Yet, the absoluteness of his finality would remain intact as long as the new need is fulfilled by an old prophet. But anyone should be able to see through this transparent effort at cheating. The difference of old or new is just a childish attempt to confuse the issue. If Jesus* of Nazareth reappears and submits to the supremacy of Prophet Muhammad®, he would still be a prophet after him. To fulfil the new need by borrowing an old prophet from a bygone people is far worse than fulfilling the same need by raising a new prophet from within the people of Islam. If the former does not violate the Doctrine of Finality the latter most certainly cannot.