Part VII
Revelation, Rationality, Knowledge & Truth, Part 6
Bahaullah applied this philosophy only partially and argued that the law in the Holy Qur’an being too heavy and cumbersome had lost its relevance to the people of the modem age. So by liberating mankind from this exacting
“‘purden’ he feigned to set them free, but not entirely so. He betook for himself the role of a new ‘Law-maker’, after cancelling the previous Law. But in the final analysis Bahaullah succeeded only in making a mockery of God and himself. The shariah that Bahaullah dictated to replace the law of the Holy Qur’an was no more and no less than a blatant affront to common sense, reason and rationality.
Between these two modern day disciples of St. Paul, i.e. Bahaullah and Maudoodi, nothing seems to have been left of the religion of Islam. As for the law in the Holy Qur’an, Bahaullah claimed to have done away with it in the name of emancipation. As for the institution of prophethood, Maudoodi ventured to abolish it by virtue of the same Pauline philosophy. Both failed to achieve their objectives in the sight of God. Both were applauded as great heroes in the sight of men who were already spiritually diseased.
But Maudoodi did not follow St. Paul entirely. He did not go as far as to suggest that the law in the Holy Qur’an should be annulled by God, lest the people should incur His wrath by failing to abide by it. He only applied the Pauline principle to the institution of prophethood. Even if non-law-bearing prophets are raised after the Holy Founder® of Islam, they are likely to be rejected by the majority of Muslims as prophets have been rejected before them. Thus according to Maudoodi’s logic, the threat of the curse would keep hanging over their heads like the sword of Damocles. In Maudoodi’s estimation by altogether doing away with the institution of prophethood after the Holy Prophet Muhammad*, God has bestowed untold blessings upon mankind, particularly upon the Muslims.
If the institution of prophethood is finally brought to a close, lest people should be cursed, it is tantamount to pronouncing prophethood itself to be a curse. Thus, the neo-Pauline philosophy of Maudoodi would require God to do away with the curse of prophethood altogether. What deliverance! What redemption! Good riddance is the other name for it!
But it should be clearly understood that this logic is applicable as much to the past as it is to the future. Why was Jesus® sent by God before the Holy Prophet*? Does not the Holy Qur’an categorically denounce the Jewish people as accursed for the crime of denying him? And what happened to earlier peoples? Did they not defy the Divine messengers sent to them and mock and ridicule them? A sad reflection on human arrogance indeed! Thus declares the Holy Qur’an:
vyehee
SNPS YN Shs Ce al Golan de es tot owe 36:31 © O yp jgoew
Woe to mankind. Never does a prophet come to them, but they scorn him and ridicule him!*
It is amazing why God did not think of bringing this curse to an end earlier in time. What happened to the Jewish people throughout the long history of their encounters with the prophets? Were they not cursed at the tongue of David*? What happened to the people of the Book between the time of Moses* and Jesus Christ**?
Was this universal human trend of treating all messengers of God inhumanly not sufficient to make God realize that prophethood was more of a curse than a blessing? Why was Noah* sent and why Abraham® and why Lot*? Did their rejection not cause the wrath of Allah to befall upon their people? But for some insignificant few, were they not obliterated from the face of the earth? Still, the idea that struck Maudoodi did not strike God. Was it because it was Maudoodi’s mind which had fabricated this myth of a god? Such infirmity of judgement behoves only a brainchild of his. God kept sending prophet after prophet but arrogant man continued to reject them, one after the other. The curse they thus earned cannot be blamed on the office of prophethood, they themselves are to blame.
Again, if this argument is accepted as valid at any particular point in time, it must also be accepted as valid at all times since the advent of Adam*. The fear of rejection of Adam* by his people, who would thus incur upon themselves the wrath of God, should have been enough justification for God never to have sent Adam*% at all. If the fear that people should reject a lesser prophet from among the followers of Hazrat Muhammad” is a legitimate reason for the cessation of prophethood altogether, then the same fear should have stood in the way of the advent of the Holy Founder* of Islam even more powerfully. Is he not the best among all the prophets? Of course he is — as the entire world of Islam testifies. Being supreme among them, for him to be rejected was to earn the worst curse of God ever inflicted. Alas Maudoodi seems to have completely forgotten that not only was the Holy Prophet™ rejected by most of the world’s population of his time, but also his truth is still denied by three-fourths of mankind today. At best, it is just one-fourth of the human population which can be described as believers in the Holy Prophet®. But can they really be defined as Muslims? Is their faith in the Holy Founder® of Islam genuine enough to include them among those who really believe? Maudoodi thinks otherwise. Out of the one billion population of the Muslims, nine hundred and ninety-nine in every one thousand are already condemned by him to be virtually non-Muslims:
LN Se gee th PW SE aly sree FSP LUIS sh P pli i7b994 688
Sete he Ie L pili Se duly! td PA eight YE ye Ba
‘This huge hotch potch body of the so-called Muslims is such as nine hundred and ninety nine out of every one thousand have no knowledge of Islam whatsoever. They are incapable of distinguishing right from wrong. Nor have their moral and mental attitudes been in the least Islamicised. From father to son, from grandfather to grandson, they have only inherited a Muslim name and no more.’
From Maudoodi’s account of the scheme of things, God had better not send any Divine book or messenger lest His poor creatures should be cursed forever.
Yet Maudoodi believes in the justification of God sending all His prophets since the time of Adam* to the time of the best among them. If their rejection brought a curse from God on those who rejected them, what exceptional harm would it do if one more like them is added to the list. But the paradox in Maudoodi becomes more of an eyesore when he is discovered to believe in the re-advent of Jesus Christ* as a prophet of God.
If instead of the old Jesus*, a new non-law-bearing prophet was to be raised from among the people of Islam, how could he in any way alter this eternal grand plan of cursedness? Why should only his advent be objectionable while all those before him since the time of Adam* served the same Divine decree of a perpetual curse?
REFERENCES
1. KAUFMANN, W. (1976) The Portable Nietzsche. Penguin Books. England, p.197
2. KAUFMANN, W. (1976) The Portable Nietzsche. Penguin Books. England, p.198
3. KAUFMANN, W. (1976) The Portable Nietzsche. Penguin Books. England, p.370-375
4. Translation of 36:31 by the author.