On Permissible Criticism
Riyad as-Salihin (Gardens of the Righteous)
Riyad as-Salihin 1536
Ayesha relates that a man asked for permission to see the Holy Prophet whereupon the latter said: Let him come in, he is the worst of his family (Bokhari and Muslim).
احتج به البخاري في جواز غيبة أهل الفساد وأهل الريب.
Riyad as-Salihin 1537
Ayesha relates that the Holy Prophet said: I do not think that So and So, and So and So, understand anything of our faith (Bokhari).
Riyad as-Salihin 1538
Fatimah bint Qais relates: I went to the Holy Prophet and said to him: Abu Jahm and Mu‘awiah have made me a proposal of marriage. The Holy Prophet said: As to Mu‘awiah, he is poor and has no property, as to Abu Jahm, he does not put away his rod from his shoulder (Bokhari and Muslim). Muslim’s version is: Abu Jahm is given to beating women; and it has also been said that the reference is to his being most of the time, on a journey.
وفي رواية لمسلم : "وأما أبو الجهم فضراب للنساء" وهو تفسير لرواية: " لا يضع العصا عن عاتقه" وقيل: معناه: كثير الأسفار.
Riyad as-Salihin 1539
Zaid ibn Arqam relates: We went on an expedition with the Holy Prophet which proved very hard on people. In the course of it Abdullah ibn Ubayy said: Do not spend on those who are with the Messenger of Allah (saw) so that they may disperse; and also said: If we return to Medina, the one most honourable will drive out therefrom the one most mean. I went to the Holy Prophet and informed him of this and he sent for Abdullah ibn Ubayy, who denied on oath having said it. People began to say: Zaid has carried a false tale to the Holy Prophet. I was much grieved by this till sura Al-Munafiqun (Chapter 63) of the Holy Qur’an was revealed. Then the Holy Prophet sent for the hypocrites so that he might ask forgiveness for them but they turned their heads away out of arrogance (Bokhari and Muslim).
Riyad as-Salihin 1540
Ayesha relates: Hindah, wife of Abu Sufyan, said to the Holy Prophet: Abu Sufyan is a stingy one and does not give me that much which would suffice for me and my children unless I take something from his property without his knowledge. The Holy Prophet said: Take that much which would suffice for thee and thy children according to what is customary (Bokhari and Muslim).