Niyog
The Sanatan Faith
I briefly discussed the issue of Niyog, as appropriate, in my book Nasim-e-Da‘wat [An Invitation], and I know that it is very beneficial and sufficient for a seeker after truth. However, I have heard from certain people that after receiving my book, Nasim-e-Da‘wat, Pundit Ram Bhajdat, President of the Punjab Aryah Religious Council, spoke of me in his last speech at the Aryah Samaj convention in Qadian, saying that had I discussed the matter with him, he would have elucidated for me all the merits of Niyog.
Therefore, with due respect, I submit that I have elaborated this subject in my book, Nasim-e-Da‘wat, with good intentions, in accordance with the requirements of human dignity and pure conscience. I did not wish to create a debate. It was merely a sincere admonition. I am not alone in this matter; thousands of honourable Hindus and Khalsa Sikhs would never consider it acceptable for a married woman from a respectable family to enter into an illicit relationship with someone else for the sole purpose of satiating a desire for children while her husband is yet alive.
As far as the ‘benefits’ of Niyog are concerned, perhaps the pundit refers to children born of Niyog that [as many as] eleven (11) boys are born ‘for free’, and hence the progeny [of Hindus] increases. I hope the pundit does not mind my saying so: Such progeny is merely a blemish for a respectable man, not a means of pride. In my opinion, if a chaste woman does not bear offspring, then it is better for her to remain childless and die without children than to senselessly sleep with a stranger and bear children who would be deemed illegitimate by sane reason.
If truth matters, then how can these children be considered the biological progeny of such an unfortunate cuckold when the child is not born from his sperm? These children are in fact the progeny of their biological father. It would be better if that woman had died before bearing such a child.
Pundit Ram Bhajdat must not insist in this shameful tradition of Niyog. As this practice is against human dignity, it would be better to remove it from the tenets of the Aryah Samaj. An open circular should be issued, declaring: ‘Dayanand has made a grave mistake on account of his celibacy and a lack of understanding of the deep sense of honour that a respectable husband bears for his wife in living together. Therefore, the Aryah Samaj eliminates this tenet from their principles.’ This statement should bear many signatures, so that no one may have the courage to object. Otherwise, they must remember that Niyog is a stigma for their religion.
I cannot accept that any chaste woman would readily submit to Niyog; rather, I fear that, if insisted upon, a woman might swallow poison to give up her life.1٭
O gentlemen! Leave everything else aside and swiftly abolish this affliction from your religion and do not baselessly attribute it to the Vedas. Do not expect honourable Aryah men and women to subscribe to this tenet. It seems to me that the tradition of mutabanna 2 has found its way into Hinduism because of Niyog. When respectable men and women noticed this impure tradition, they initiated the tradition of mutabanna instead. The dignity of a man would not permit him to compel his wife to take part in the shameful practice of Niyog, so they preferred to accept mutabanna. Although mutabanna is an innovation, it is a thousand times better than this shameless and filthy practice. It is such a foul custom that even the lowest of the low would be ready to shed blood instead of adopting this practice for his wife.
So why should we not feel sorry for Aryas, who blindly accepted the views of Dayanand? After all, the followers of the Sanatan creed are their brothers in faith. Have they not been studying the Vedas for a long time? Why then do they not accept this shameful custom? Sadly, Aryas rage when they are kind-heartedly advised to abolish this tradition and not make their wives enter into such a foul custom. Their state is truly bizarre for they do not feel any shame in such practices.
A few days ago, I invited several Aryas to my residence. They included an Aryah, Kishan Singh, who became an Aryah after becoming upset with the views of revered Bawa Nanak. He forsook a righteous and pious man whose heart permeated with the love of God. He is now a staunch devotee of Pundit Dayanand. The others included Lala Sharampat, Lala Malawamal of Qadian, and Pundit Saum Raj, Secretary of the Aryah Society of Qadian. There were also several followers of the Sanatan faith present. I expounded that it is not appropriate to engage one’s wife in such a practice, especially in this town. The assembly was embarrassed and kept its silence. However, Pundit Saum Raj eventually said that there was nothing untoward about this custom. On hearing this, that he is not at all ashamed of involving his wife in such a filthy practice, the followers of the Sanatan faith started chanting aloud the name of Rām. The other Aryas cloaked their faces to hide their amusement. Almost thirty people witnessed Pundit Sahib’s disgraceful confession.
It is deeply regrettable that instead of abolishing this practice, the Aryas become excited and object, ‘Do the Muslims not practice mut‘ah?’;1 that is, they do not divorce women with whom they have entered into the nikah [religious marriage]. It has been repeatedly elaborated that there is a glaring difference between divorce, which is practiced the world over when necessary, and the custom of forcing one’s wife to enter an illicit relationship. Yet, they fail to understand. The respectable and decent followers of the Sanatan faith feel immense embarrassment. One commits the sin and the other feels guilt.
It has been repeatedly stated that if a person, after entering into a nikah [marriage], divorces his wife at any point—or sets a predetermined time for divorce—meaning that after a certain period of time I will divorce [her], the name of which some Shia consider to be mut‘ah—this [type of ] nikah bears no semblance with your custom. In our religion, a nikah [of this type] where the time of divorce is fixed is prohibited. This is categorically forbidden by the Holy Qur’an. In pre-Islamic Arabia such marriages were practiced but were prohibited in the Holy Qur’an and have become unlawful after the revelation of the Holy Qur’an. Today, only a few Shia sects follow it, but they are caught in a custom of ignorance.
It is not justified for a learned person to point out the faults of someone else in order to cover up his own faults. Can one criminal be exonerated by referring to the crime of someone else? There is clear guidance about marriage in the Book of God. There is no mention of a marriage where the time for divorce is predetermined. Besides, in this situation the objection is principally against divorce, whereas there is no faith group in the world that is against divorce, for there may arise circumstances where divorce becomes unavoidable. So whenever Aryas are advised to eschew this shameful action, their only reply is that Muslims also have the tradition of divorce.
Dear ones! Which religion does not allow this tradition? When acrimony increases between a husband and wife, then separation is the only recourse. It would be better for you to stop such criticisms and instead turn away from Niyog. It is futile to claim that there are rewards and hidden benefits associated with Niyog.