A Discourse upon the Demise of Bashir
The Green Announcement
Let it be known that the demise of my son Bashir Ahmad, who was born on Monday, 7 th August 1887, and called back by his Creator, aged sixteen months, on Monday, 4 th November 1888, at the time of the morning prayer, has raised a great outcry amongst foolish and ignorant people. Many, including my own relations, have expressed opinions based on malice and ignorance, and the enemies of religion, who are given to dishonesty and slander, have started fabricating stories in connection with the demise of this child. I never intended to issue any announcement or statement about the passing away of this innocent boy, nor was such a course of action required, for there was nothing about his death that could have misled any reasonable person, but when the commotion reached its peak and begun adversely affecting simple-minded and gullible Muslims, then, solely for the sake of Allah, I decided to publish this announcement.
The reader should remember that some of my opponents have written disparaging articles about the demise of my son in their newspapers and other publications. They say that he was the same child about whom I had claimed, in my announcements of 20 th February 1886, 8 th April 1886, and 7 th August 1887, that he would become a man of glory and greatness and wealth, and nations would be blessed through him, and some of them even concocted a revelation to the effect that the boy would marry the daughters of kings. The reader should understand that those who have raised these objections have either been
Peshawar, who has referenced all the three above-mentioned announcements in an announcement of his own in order to further his claim, and has acted dishonestly throughout. For instance, in quoting the announcement of 8 th April 1886, he only alludes to the passage in which I said that a boy would be born soon within the nine-month period of a pregnancy, but he fails to mention the next sentence in which I said that hitherto it was not clear whether this was the [promised] boy or whether he would be born at a later date within the stipulated nine-year period. He omitted this part intentionally, for it contradicted his assertion and falsified the basis of his false surmise. His other injustice is that, in his announcement, he fails to acknowledge the announcement previously issued by the Aryas and printed at Chashma Nur Press in Amritsar, in which they acknowledged that it was not clear from any of my three announcements whether the deceased boy was the Promised Reformer or whether he was to come afterwards. This announcement was in itself enough to falsify Lekh Ram’s contention, and I invite the reader to once again read this announcement which, for all practical purposes, had better been entitled, 'God loves not the deceivers.' [Author]
misled or they wish to mislead others. The fact is that no one can cite a single word from any of my announcements published before the child’s birth in August 1887, and which have been cited by Lekh Ram of Peshawar in support of his own assertion, in which I claimed that this particular boy, who is now deceased, would be the Promised Reformer and blessed with a long life. On the other hand, I clearly stated in my announcements of 8 th April 1886, and in that of 7 th August 1887—which was issued on the day of Bashir’s birth with reference to the former announcement—that Divine revelation had not yet disclosed to me whether this particular boy was the Promised Reformer who was to be blessed with a long life, or whether he would be born afterwards. I am amazed that though Lekh Ram was driven by his prejudice to raise objections on the basis of these announcements, and made characteristic use of foul and abusive language in doing so, he did not bother even to read the announcements carefully, which would have saved him the embarrassment of this hasty action. It is unfortunate that the pundits who sermonize in bazaars and preach that shunning falsehood and adopting the truth are the principles of the Arya faith, do nothing to stop these habitual liars from uttering such falsehood. It is indeed unfortunate that these principles are always preached but never practised.
The long and short of it is that the above mentioned statements of 8 th April 1886 and 7 th August 1887 are completely silent on what qualities the child would possess. They both testify that the matter was still unclear in the light of Divine revelation. It is true that in my announcement of 20 th February 1886 the above mentioned qualities were attributed to a future child, in general terms and without being very specific, but nowhere did I write that these qualities applied to the particular boy who would be born on 7th August 1887. In fact, the announcement does not even specify the time or date of the child’s birth. It is, therefore, the height of obstinacy and dishonesty to say that the announcements specified the deceased child as the bearer of these qualities. I have all those announcements in my possession, and I believe most of my readers have them also; if they can read them again they will be able to better judge for themselves.
Upon the birth of the boy who is now deceased, I received be born very soon, within the nine-month period of a pregnancy and no longer than that. It has, however, not been made clear to me whether this is the [promised] boy or whether he will be born later within the stipulated nine-year period." See the announcement of 8 th April 1886, printed at Chashma-e-Faid Qadri Press, Batala. The text of the announcement of 7 th August 1887, is as follows: "Readers! I give you the good news that the boy whose birth I had prophesized in the announcement of 8 th April 1886 came into this world on 16 th Zil-Qa‘ad, or 7 th August." See the announcement of 7 th August 1887, printed at Victoria Press, Lahore.
Now, is there even a hint in any of the three announcements—which Lekh Ram of Peshawar has so eagerly quoted—that the deceased boy would be the Promised Reformer and blessed with a long life? Think and reflect! [Author]
hundreds of letters from far and near inquiring whether he was indeed the Promised Reformer who was to be the guide for the people. I told them that until then I had not received any clear revelation pertaining to this matter. It was, nevertheless, conjectured that he might be the Promised Reformer, and for good reason, because many of his personal qualities had been mentioned in various Divine revelations, and they spoke of the purity of his soul, the excellence of his nature, the greatness of his ability, and the enlightenment and inherent goodness of his soul, and they all bespoke his perfect potential. But in view of the fact that all these were inherent qualities, which did not require that the child should attain maturity, I did not make any categorical statement on the basis of Divine revelation that this was the [promised] boy who would grow to maturity. I also delayed the publication of Siraj-e- Munir in expectation of some Divine revelation that would reveal the truth about this boy, for only then could I write about it confidently and comprehensively. Since I never expressed any definite opinion about the deceased boy on the basis of revelation, and never published a single revelation in this connection, I am only left to wonder who whispered all these things into the ears of my opponents? Nonetheless, even if I had issued a clear and categorical announcement stating that this child could well be the Promised Reformer and blessed with a long life—basing this view on the fact that Divine revelation had revealed the noble qualities of the deceased child and had given him names such as Mubashar [the Promised One], Bashir
[Bearer of glad-tidings], Nurullah [Light of Allah] Sayyeb [Heavenly Rain], Charagh Din [Light of Faith], etc., which reveal his perfect potential and inherent light—such an interpretive statement would not have been objectionable in the eyes of fair-minded people. On account of their just and perceptive minds, they would have understood that I had reached this conclusion on the basis of a few titles which were not very specific and admitted of more than one meaning and interpretation. And even if they considered this explanation to be an error of judgement, they would have deemed it as unimportant and inconsequential. The ancient Divine law relating to revelations, dreams and visions that are not very specific may not be understood by those who are slow of understanding and blind of heart, but people of wisdom and insight readily understand that an error in interpreting a prophecy is nothing objectionable. Many eminent Prophets and Messengers have made errors in interpreting some of their visions and prophecies, but it did not surprise or alienate their clear-minded and enlightened companions who saw that the error lay not in the substance of the revelations or visions but only in their interpretation. It is thus obvious that errors of judgement committed by religious scholars and mystics do not diminish their status, and if we add to
All this happened because Moses (as) himself had not been given any clear information about the intervening difficulties and the length of their trials, and it was his own inference that the ignoble Pharaoh would soon be defeated through manifest signs. But God, in accordance with His eternal practice towards all His Prophets, and in order to try Moses (as) in the early stages of his mission, and to fill him with the awe of His Istighna, kept these intervening difficulties hidden from him. If all the coming trials and afflictions had been revealed to him beforehand, he would have been reassured and his resolve would have been strengthened. But in that case he would not have been overawed by the ordeals by means of which God had intended to raise his and his followers’ spiritual status and make them recipients of Divine reward in the hereafter.
In the same way, Jesus’ disciples had believed that the promises of worldly success and prosperity that the Messiah (as) had made to them would be fulfilled very easily and in a short time. Some of the gladtidings the Messiah (as) gave them even seemed to imply that he would soon establish a great kingdom, and some of his disciples even began collecting weapons in anticipation. The Messiah (as) also spoke of his second coming in a manner which suggested that the disciples and their contemporaries would still be alive when he returned to the world in glory, and it seems that Jesus (as) was himself inclined towards this view which he impressed upon his disciples, but, as it turned out, his interpretation was wrong and he had made an error of judgement.
this the fact that I never made any categorical announcement that turned out to be wrong, one can only wonder why my narrow-minded opponents heaped such venom on me at the demise of Bashir Ahmad? Do they have any evidence to prove that I issued such announcements, or are they merely exposing the baser impulses of their souls for everyone to see? I am truly amazed at the way some naïve Muslims are readily plagued by doubt and suspicion. If they indeed possess an announcement of mine in which I categorically stated, on the authority of Divine revelation, that this particular boy would be the Promised Reformer and blessed with a long life, why do they not produce it? Let me assure them, however, that I never issued such an announcement.
Another amazing thing mentioned in the Bible is that close to four hundred Prophets made a prophecy about the victory of an Israelite King, but it was not fulfilled and the King was met with defeat. See I Kings 22:19.