Foreword – Glossary 33
The Truth About Salvation, Part 4
Regarding Jesus the Messiah (as) the Bible says:
Then he said to them, ‘I am deeply grieved, even
to death; remain here, and stay awake with me.’
And going a little farther, he threw himself on the
ground and prayed, ‘My Father, if it is possible,
let this cup pass from me; Yet not what I want
but what you want.’
This suggests that the Messiah (as) was forcefully put on the cross. Christians argue that while his soul was ready [for crucifixion] his body was frail, but if that were the case, the body ought to have been saved since it did not wish to be put on the cross, and yet it was still punished. If the argument that the Messiah (as), despite his unwillingness, was put on the cross for the atonement of humankind’s sins is to be believed, then any other community can also claim that the murder of one of their people was for their own atonement. This is a feeble contention, and until we have a reasonable argument in favour of atonement, it is unacceptable.
When Christians are unable to support their claims, they object that the concept of sacrifice is also existent in Islam. They ask that if the sacrifice of a goat can lead to one’s sins being forgiven, why can’t the sacrifice of Jesus the Messiah (as) also be a cause for pardon? However, when making this objection, they fail to keep in mind the differences between the sacrifice of a goat and the crucifixion of Jesus the Messiah (as). We do not claim that sacrificing an animal relieves the burden of our sins. Nor do we claim that the animal is sacrificed as a punishment for our sins. Instead, our claim is that we are sacrificing part of our wealth in order to attain God Almighty’s pleasure, in the hope that He will then forgive us our sins. Let me clarify this further: the sacrifice we make is that of our wealth, and secondly, we do this for the sake of God Almighty. Thirdly, we hope that this good deed will attain God Almighty’s pleasure, and, thereby, He will pardon us.
However, these points do not apply in the matter of Jesus’ (as) crucifixion, because (i) he is not anyone’s possession for them to claim that their sins will be pardoned through his sacrifice and (ii) nor are they the ones who sacrificed him. The only person that benefits from a sacrifice is the one who undertakes it and no one else. The Jews sacrificed Jesus the Messiah (as). For this, Christians claim that the Jews will go to hell, and that they themselves have achieved salvation through the sacrifice made by the Jews. If Jesus the
Messiah (as) is God’s son then the Christians have no claim over him. Since the Jews crucified him, and not the Christians, therefore, it is they who should benefit from it. However, Christians claim the opposite of this; they believe that by simply believing in his death, they attain salvation. For this reason, the Christian concept regarding salvation cannot be taken as correct in any way.
Instead, there is no room for doubt or suspicion in the approach taught by Islam. As I have already mentioned, Islam has expounded on the commandments of the divine law so that human beings can find peace and solace by following it, and save themselves from difficulty. It is much the same as the way railway operators have created timetables which inform people that those who turn up at a scheduled time will be able to purchase tickets and take the relevant train to their desired destination. Yet still, if somebody complains about this, and says that taking the train to a particular destination would cause them difficulty, then they would be considered most foolish. The same is true of the law. It would have been a curse if it contained such provisions that hurt people. But in Islam there is no such commandment that brings harm to people instead of benefit. Is theft, which has been forbidden by Islam, an act of virtue? Can adultery, which has been prohibited, be considered a good deed? Or can lying be considered something excellent even though it has been deemed a wrong? Definitely not.
This then is the case with all the commandments of the law which are essentially reference points or a guidebook [to living a better life]. If God Almighty Himself did not reveal the evils within the things He has forbidden, then human beings would only have recognised their ill effects after many years of experiencing and struggling with their negative consequences. Yet, by way of a gift, God Almighty disclosed them directly to people. How unfortunate that Christians have declared this divine gift to be a curse, whereas in truth, through His mercy, God disclosed the commandments and teachings of the law to the people as rules to be followed. Human beings do not possess the capacity to reach the best conclusion in everything. Therefore, God showed them that if He had not revealed to them the divine law, they would have suffered immensely and performed such deeds which, apart from just grief, would have brought them affliction as well. Nor would they have undertaken such actions as would have been beneficial to them and brought them great prosperity.
Islam not only teaches us the difference between benefit and ruin, but also on how to practice these good deeds and save ourselves from torment. This is because our everyday experience of the world shows us that merely warning a person of danger and loss is not sufficient, because until one commits a wrong deed, they are unaware of its harmful consequences. In such a situation, a higher power is required to adequately restrain them from committing the act in this state (of unawareness). For example, when a child puts their hand into a fire, it burns. But if their parents are watching over them, they would prevent the child from doing so. Why? This is because the effect of pain from fire is concealed from the child who does not have adequate knowledge regarding the pain that the fire causes. Yet, if the child fears being reprimanded from their parents, they would refrain from doing this. People are less fearful of those things that are not completely known to them, even if they are aware of the dangers. To actually experience and see something instils fear. For example, we see that even thieves refrain from stealing in the presence of the police. Similarly, a religion that can visualise God, can lead to salvation from sin. One who follows such a religion would continue to commit sins because of their lack of comprehensive awareness, but upon acquiring knowledge of their consequences they would eventually start refraining from wrongdoing, and when they would attain complete knowledge of this, they would eschew sin altogether. The only religion conforming to this is Islam. Firstly, Islam proves the existence of God through rational arguments. Furthermore, in every era, there have been followers of Islam who have shown signs to prove the existence of God Almighty. All the prophets of the past showed signs to prove the existence of a living God. According to Christianity, after the Messiah (as), no one was able to achieve this and the world stopped giving birth to such people, and so the concept of atonement was introduced. Yet, the advent of prophets has always been the most substantive way of proving the existence of a living God, and it is the prophets who show the path to salvation for humankind.
Was salvation unattainable in the time of Moses (as) when the concept of atonement had not been introduced? If anyone were to claim that Moses (as) achieved salvation because he believed in the atonement of Jesus (as), then I could also very well claim that he attained salvation because he believed in me. Christians do not have any evidence that Moses (as) believed in atonement through Jesus (as) and, therefore, both their assertion and my own would be equally acceptable. But, Christians believe that Abraham (as), Moses (as), Jacob (as), Isaac (as), and all other prophets were saved despite the concept of atonement never having existed in their time. Therefore, it can be deduced that their salvation was the result of the law, and not through atonement; their law had the same purpose, which was to show the truth of a living God.
Islam makes the same assertion. First, it testifies to God Almighty’s existence through rational arguments. Once an individual initiates belief and starts following Islamic commandments, they are able to recognise God. God’s help is given to them, and they are informed about events of the future. They are saved from sin and attain salvation and achieve success as well; this is what Islam teaches about the path to redemption.
Christians claim that, just as a magistrate would be deemed unjust for acquitting a criminal, the same would be true if God exonerated a sinner. However, the difference between God and a magistrate is immense. When a criminal is presented before a magistrate it is not because they have wronged the magistrate, but committed an offence against the government; the magistrate cannot exonerate them of their own volition. On the other hand, a sin committed by a person is an act against God, and therefore, He can choose to forgive it. Besides, the claim that courts do not pardon criminals is inaccurate, since there are many instances in which those who are guilty are reprieved because of various reasons. Only recently, the court sentenced some criminals to death, but the viceroy then changed the sentence to life imprisonment. Is there anyone who can claim that this did not happen? Certainly not! Moreover, another reason why courts do not acquit criminals is their inability to determine whether a claim to remorse is genuine or made out of pretence to save themselves from punishment. An exonerated criminal could turn out to be a repeat offender. But God Almighty has knowledge of even the smallest things; He knows whether the remorseful sinner will refrain from sins. Therefore, there should not be any objection against God for pardoning an individual. According to Islam
God accepts sincere repentance.
At the conclusion of Huzoor’s address, the Christian gentleman who asked the initial question proceeded to enquire over the assertion in the Holy Qur’an that God sets a seal over the hearts and ears of people and when this is the case, how could such people achieve salvation? Huzoor responded in the following terms: