The Heavenly Decree

The reality of the fatwa of heresy issued by Miyan Nadhir Husain; the true nature of his artificial victory, and an invitation to him and his followers to come to Though Miyan Nadhir Husain is himself not immune to fatwas of heresy—and has been declared first among the heretics of India, he shows as much zeal in declaring other Muslims to be kafirs [non-believers] as is shown by pious people in converting others into

Islam. He has a deep desire for unduly labelling Muslims as kafirs, even if there exists not a single reason for doing so. His faithful acolyte, Muhammad Husain Batalawi, who styles himself a Shaikh [a religious scholar and teacher], follows in his footsteps. In fact, the Shaikh excels his mentor in his passion for declarations of kufr [unbelief]. The creed of this teacher and his pupil seems to be that, even though they see ninety-nine clear proofs of faith in a person, and one proof [to the contrary] which they themselves fail to grasp because of their lack of understanding, they still find it appropriate to call such a person a kafir. I, too, have been subjected to such treatment by these gentlemen. Anyone who carefully reads my books Brahin-e-Ahmadiyyah and Surmah Chashma-e- Aryah, will clearly see the devotion with which I serve Islam and the passion with which I propagate the excellence of the Holy Prophet (sa). In spite of all this, Miyan Nadhir Husain, and his acolyte Batalawi, did not rest till they had declared me a kafir. [The state of] Miyan Nadhir Husain is particularly lamentable. In his old age, sitting on the very edge of the grave, he shows no fear for the hereafter and has completely abandoned honesty and fear of God to declare me a kafir. He has exposed a very ugly side of his nature when so close to his end.

It should be the duty of every sensible, virtuous and God-fearing person from among the clergy to refrain from pronouncing a person kafir unless they have factual, certain and categorical reasons whereby someone clearly admits—and does not deny—his statements on the basis of which he has been branded a kafir. Until this happens, they should not hasten to give the label of kafir to anyone. It is worth asking if Miyan Nadhir Husain has followed this righteous path or not. There can be no doubt that Miyan Nadhir Husain has completely abandoned the path of honesty and prudence.

I published three posters in Delhi, declaring, again and again, that I am a Muslim, and Islam is my faith. I conveyed the message under the oath of God Almighty that there is nothing in my speeches or writings which is contrary to Islamic beliefs—God forbid. This is merely a misunderstanding on the part of my opponents. I believe with all my heart and soul in all the tenets of Islam and abhor everything to the contrary. Hadrat Miyan Sahib, however, paid no heed to what I said and declared me a kafir without investigation or verification. Indeed, having heard my clear professions: [I am a believer, I am a believer], he still kept on saying: [You are not a believer]. Everywhere in his speeches and writings and in posters issued by his acolytes, he dubbed me a kafir, faithless and a Dajjal [Antichrist], and announced publicly that this person is a nonbeliever and devoid of faith. This incitement by Miyan

Sahib stirred a furious storm among the common people, and the people of Punjab and India were greatly agitated. The people of Delhi were particularly fired up by these flaming words of Miyan Sahib. There are sixty or seventy thousand Muslims in Delhi, and it would be a rare person among them who has neither participated in uttering abuse, curse and ridicule upon me, nor heard such things. All this is to the account of Miyan Sahib who has accumulated it for the hereafter in his last days. He covered up true testimony and firmly instilled in hundreds of thousands of hearts the idea that I was in fact a kafir and accursed and outside the pale of Islam.

I was in Delhi at the time and when I saw all this commotion, I published a special announcement addressing Miyan Sahib, and also wrote some letters to him. With deep humility and modesty I made it clear that I am not a kafir; that Allah knows I am a Muslim, and I believe in all the articles of faith which the Ahl-e-Sunnah wal Jama‘at profess, that I believe in the Kalimah , that I face the Qibla when praying, that I am not a claimant to Prophethood and that, in fact, I consider such a claimant to be outside the pale of Islam. I wrote also that I do not deny the existence of the angels. I swear by the Lord that I believe in angels exactly as they have been described in the Sharia. I also said that I do not deny Lailatul Qadr [the Night of Decree], rather I believe in it exactly as detailed in the Holy Qur’an and Ahadith. I also made it clear that I believe in the existence of Gabriel and in Prophetic revelations and do not deny them; that I do not deny Resurrection and the Day of Judgement; that I do not harbour doubts as to the greatness, the perfect power and signs of my Lord in contrast to the half-baked ideas of the naturalists, and that I do not reject miracles due to their improbability in the eyes of reason.

I have declared it many a time in public gatherings that I have complete faith in the limitless powers of God Almighty, and that I consider unlimited power to be an essential attribute of Divinity. If one believes in God but considers Him powerless in anything, such a god is no God at all. And if God is that weak—Heaven forbid—then those who believe in Him are doomed and all their hopes are frustrated. He is undoubtedly capable of doing everything, but it has to be worthy of His Majesty and His Holiness. It should not go against His perfect attributes, nor contradict His true promises.

In spite of all these proclamations, Miyan Sahib pronounced a confirmation of the fatwa of heresy against me and declared me kafir and faithless. In order to delay the date of 20th October 1891, which had been publicised in the aforementioned announcements, Miyan Sahib repeatedly put forward the excuse that I was not a Muslim. He asked me to first prove my faith in Islam, only then would he enter into a debate with me. I again submitted with all due respect that I was not a kafir, and that I believed in all the tenets which Allah—glorified be His name—has prescribed for Muslims. Furthermore, as mentioned in my announcement of 23 rd October 1891, I also wrote a statement with my own hand that I believe in all the articles of Islam. Alas! Miyan Sahib still continued to consider me and refer to me as a kafir. The sole excuse for not entering into a debate regarding the life or death of the Messiah was his insistence that I was a kafir, and that there was no point in debating with kafirs. If only he had an iota of fear of God in him, he should have withdrawn this fatwa of kufr against me when I issued the announcement about my being a Muslim and declaring my Islamic beliefs. He should have owned up his error publicly and given clear testimony to my faith in Islam with the same zeal as he had shown while announcing me to be an apostate before the crowd, and could have saved himself from a false assertion. He would have created for himself an excuse before God Almighty by withdrawing an unfounded fatwa. But this he did not do. Instead, as long as I was at Delhi, I continued to hear reports that Miyan Sahib was using foul and unspeakable language against me and had not withdrawn his fatwa of heresy. Every effort was made to stop him from this ugly behaviour and stop his tongue, but he had grown so accustomed of calling me a kafir that he could not restrain himself from doing so. His Nafsi Ammarah had so overwhelmed him that no room was left in his heart for the fear of God.

I do not wish to dwell further on his declaration of heresy. Everyone will be answerable for his own words and deeds; they shall be answerable for their deeds, and I shall be for mine. But it is such a pity that he continued to dwell upon unjustified accusations and acts of slander, and paid no attention whatsoever to the truly debatable and controversial issue of the death of the Messiah (as) . I wrote to him, time and again, that I do not oppose him in any of his beliefs except that of the Messiah (as) being physically alive. I most certainly believe him [the Messiah (as)] to be dead and among the dead. Why should I not believe him to be dead when my God and my Lord in His Glorious Book, the Holy Qur’an, counts him among the dead? Not even once does the Holy Qur’an speak about his extraordinary life or second coming. Rather, it calls him dead and says no more. Not only do I reject Jesus’ bodily existence and later return to earth in view of revelations vouchsafed to me, but I also consider this concept absurd and false in the light of the clear and categorical injunctions of the Holy Qur’an. If this statement of mine is a lie and a heresy, then come and let us have a debate about it. If you can prove the physical existence of Hadrat ‘Isa (as) from the Holy Qur’an and Hadith, I shall not only revoke my claim, but shall burn all my books containing this subject. If you are unable to discuss it, then come and declare upon oath that there is no mention of the death of the Messiah (as) in the Holy Qur’an and only his life is mentioned. Or that there is a Sahih Marfu‘ Muttasil Hadith which testifies to the physical life of the Messiah (as) by offering a contrary interpretation to the word Tawaffa [died].

If no clear sign from Almighty Allah appears within one year which proves that your oath was false, i.e., if you do not suffer some great calamity, I shall instantly repent at your hand. It is indeed a pity that, despite repeated requests, Miyan Sahib neither came forward for the debate, nor took the oath, nor even did he desist from calling me 'kafir, kafir'. Albeit, in order to hide his humiliation for having avoided the debate, he published false announcements in which he wrote that he had kept inviting me for a debate till the end and had also been ready to take the oath, but it was I who had been afraid of him and had not come out to face him. Such falsehood from one calling himself Miyan Sahib and Shaikhul Kul ! How should I say

have mercy on him.

Readers, if you possess the light of discernment, you can understand that all this is a baseless lie and depraved boastfulness of Miyan Sahib and his followers. I published announcement after announcement that Miyan Sahib should come forward and debate the death of Christ with me. And it was for this very purpose that I stayed on in Delhi for one full month at great cost and inconvenience. A discerning person can well understand that if Miyan Sahib was truly sincere in holding a debate, why should I have shied away? It is said that truth knows no fear. I am as ready for a debate on the death of Christ now, as I was then. If Miyan Sahib agrees to come to Lahore for the debate, I shall bear all his personal travel expenses. If he agrees to come, I can send him the amount in advance upon his written commitment. I myself do not wish to go to Delhi for the debate, because I have witnessed the clamour of the people of Delhi and have heard their malicious and vile talk.

I can go as far as to say that if I avoid the debate on the death of Christ, may Allah curse me a thousand times for [being an obstacle in the path of Allah]. And if it is Shaikhul Kul Sahib who avoids the debate, let there be half the curse on him. Should he want to avoid coming in person, I can even allow him to hold the debate in writing from where he is, so that the truth can become manifest. In short, I am ready in every way, and all I await is Miyan Sahib’s formal reply. The reason for my special interest in relation to Miyan Sahib is that people consider him to be the superior-most in his knowledge, and he is like the root among the religious scholars of India. If the root is cut, the branches too shall invariably fall away. This debate will let the world know the arguments which Shaikhul Kul has regarding the bodily life of the Messiah (as) , on the basis of which he has so inflamed the public. But do remember my prediction that he will never come out for the debate. And if he does at all come, he will be so humiliated that he will have nowhere to show his face. I feel so terribly sorry for him that, due to his love for the fame and popularity of this transient world, he has covered up the truth, abandoned righteousness and embraced falsehood. He knew well that the death of the Messiah (as) is clearly proven by the Holy Qur’an and Sahih Marfu‘ Ahadith, and yet he dishonestly and deceptively held back his testimony in this regard. Acting as a sworn enemy of the truth, and through mere prevarication, he propagated among the people that it is written in the Holy Qur’an that Messiah, son of Mary, was lifted to the heaven alive in his physical body, and that there is no mention of his death whatsoever.

10 of 10 left today