A Gift for An-Nadwah
God’s help comes with my every breath,
Where are the enlightened so that they might see?
Today, 2nd October, 1902, I received an announcement published by Hafiz Muhammad Yusuf, pensioner, which was addressed to me. According to him, he has long averred that certain persons who intended to mislead others by falsely claiming to be prophets or messengers sent by God, lived for 23 years or more [after making their claim]; (23 years being the duration of the Holy Prophet’s mission). He further writes that a close friend of his, Abu Ishaq Muhammad Din, has published a book, Qat‘ul-Watin, in which he has catalogued the names of such false claimants and the length of time of their 'mission' with reference to historical sources. It appears that Hafiz Sahib does not admit the validity of the
Him and invoke His blessings upon His noble Messenger (sa) .
he want to. Rather they are rejected in Qat‘ul-Watin and, in his and Muhammad Din’s view, the following verses are also abrogated and of scant significance:
All these verses, including the verse in which God says that if the Prophet (sa) had attributed lies to Him, He would have seized him and cut his jugular vein, are seemingly dismissed in Qat‘ul-Watin. Thus, according to Hafiz Sahib, the warnings God issued in them are invalid and even if some Prophets had made false claims—God forbid—they would not have been destroyed. He
trivial statement to Us, We would surely have seized him by the right hand,—Al-Haqqah, 69:45-46 [Publishers]
Mu’min, 40:29 [Publishers]
[Publishers]
which was said to them. So We sent down upon the transgressors a punishment from heaven,—Al-Baqarah, 2:60 thus posits that there are no provisions in the governance of God against liars, creating a vacuum for all manner of deceit.Accordingly, had any of the Prophets spoken falsehoods about God, they would not have been held accountable for it in this life. This also carries the implication that the laws of man are superior to those of God; for they are at least framed with provisions to apprehend and punish those who produce false testimony. Consequently, as far as Hafiz Sahib is concerned, it is not a miracle that the Holy Prophet (sa) was granted a 23 year period for the completion of the revelation of the Holy Qur’an, that his life was safeguarded
extent that despite the maximum efforts of their opponents, they remain alive long enough to fully establish their religion. If this premise were accepted, then there could not exist any fair or indispensible means for verifying the claims of the Prophets and the distinction between truth and falsehood would forever be blurred by a cloud of uncertainty. Thus it is immediately clear that blessing a Prophet with a long life and helping him sow the seed of his religion in the earth, despite the many ill-intentions and intrigues of his opponents, is a miracle which God performs for His true and perfect Messengers. But if we were to suppose that His favour also extended to false claimants, then these miracles would lose their legitimacy and a true Prophet would have no distinction. How incredible! Hafiz Sahib has with one stroke sought to ruin the foundation of Islam. Is this what it means to be a Hafiz? [Author]
from the attacks of his opponents and that he died in accordance with the Divine Will once his life had been completed. It has been prophesied that I too will be granted approximately 80 years in order to complete my mission. But as far as he is concerned, the fulfilment of such prophecies cannot be considered a sign of a claimant’s truth. Under the dictates of his religion, no amount of Divine protection can establish the truthfulness of either the Holy Prophet (sa) or myself, because it is also possible for liars to fall within its purview. But, if this were accepted, the whole of the teaching of the Holy Qur’an, which declares that liars will be caught, disgraced, ruined and made to fail, would have to be considered false.
One’s intellect can readily accept the idea, as found in the earlier scriptures that a person who strives to destroy the works of God should himself perish. But, in Hafiz Sahib’s opinion, there have been many people who have falsely claimed to be Prophets and the recipients of Divine revelation and have persisted in their claim for as long as thirty years. During this time, they continuously asserted their truth and fabricated revelations until their dying breath and departed this life in a state of disbelief. God prolonged their lives and allowed their work to flourish and did not punish them. Moreover, there is no evidence to suggest that they repented or publicly expressed their remorse so as to let the people know that they had returned to the fold of Islam.
Hafiz Sahib states that sufficient proof of this can be found in Qat‘ul-Watin. He also writes that he does not wish to receive the 500 rupee reward. Instead he desires that at the annual gathering of the Nadwatul-Ulema beginning on 9th October, 1902, in Amritsar, which will be attended by some of India’s most renowned scholars, I should promise to repent if the historical authenticity of the examples cited in Qat‘ul-Watin is accepted by the designated arbiters i.e. the Nadwatul-Ulema. That is, if they decide that my case is similar to that of other liars who claimed to have received Divine revelations, recorded them and spread news of them throughout the world and fabricated lies against God, and yet they were not destroyed. On the contrary, like me, they were blessed with a community of followers. If this be how they are persuaded I should repent before their gathering.
I would happily let the Nadwatul-Ulema arbitrate between Hafiz Sahib and myself if God had blessed them with the necessary foresight, if they were just, righteous and had sufficient time to thoroughly investigate our respective claims. But, since I am given to doubt regarding their [earnestness and judicial faculty], I have decided not to make the journey to Amritsar. In truth, I do not esteem any of them as righteous, (if in the future God brings a change to their character, it will be out of His grace), nor do I believe them to possess knowledge of truths in the Holy Qur’an, for such understanding rests on the principle in the Holy Qur’an
َاملُۡﻄَﻬَّﺮُوۡن . With this in mind, how can I accept their arbitration?
Instead, if some of their ulema were to come to Qadian, with the purpose of seeking the truth, I could communicate my message to them in person. Otherwise the work of God continues and cannot be halted by anyone. Surely there is no sense in seeking judgement from one’s adversaries.
Nevertheless, I will take the opportunity, which Hafiz Sahib’s announcement has provided me, to convey my message to the people of An-Nadwah. Hafiz Sahib should know that the less than cogent accounts found in Qat‘ul-Watin about false claimants of Prophethood, cannot be considered plausible until it is established that these liars remained vigorous and adamant in their claim and were unrepentant. This can only be proved through historical sources which show that they died in a state of falsehood, their funeral prayer was not led by a Muslim [on account of their being outside the pale of
Islam], and that they were not buried in a Muslim cemetery. Furthermore, a book or record of their lies, which they considered to be the word of God, must be shown to exist somewhere so that one can inquire into whether their claims were categorical and whether they enunciated that they were Prophets in a real sense or as a reflection thereof. That is, in order to reach a proper understanding of how they perceived of their revelations, in so much as, whether they claimed that their revelations were from God every much as the revelations of past Prophets. If so, the verse َ ﺗَﻘَﻮَّل would also be applicable to them. It seems Hafiz Sahib is unaware of the fact that conviction and certainty are intrinsic to the injunction contained in this verse. As I have stated numerous times before, the words I speak most certainly emanate from God, in the same way that the Holy Qur’an and the Torah emanated from Him. I am a Prophet of God in a Zilli and Buruzi sense. All Muslims are obligated to obey me in matters of religion and to accept me as the Promised Messiah. Those
Messiah was not a Prophet in his own right but achieved the mantle of Prophethood by completely immersing himself into the person of the Holy Prophet (sa). In this way he was a reflection of the Prophet’s spiritual light. [Publishers]