Interpretation of Hadrat ‘A’ ishah’sra Hadith by Learned Scholars

True Insights into the Concept of Khatm-e-Nubuwwat

Similarly, Sheikhul-Imam Hadrat Ibn-e-Qutaibah (died 267 A.H.) referring to the above words of Hadrat ‘A’ishahra writes: :

The interpretation, put for th by her (Hadrat ‘A’ishahra), does not contradict the words of the Holy Prophet sa . The Holy Prophet sa meant that there would be no Prophet after him who would abrogate his law. (Ta’wilu Mukhtalifil-Ahadith, p. 127)

This is exactly the belief of all Ahmadis. We have inherited it not only from the Promised Messiahas but also from the earlier righteous ones of the Muslim ummah. An eminent divine, Hadrat Imam Muhammad Tahir (died 986 A.H), writes on page 502 of his book Takmelah Majma‘ Biharul-Anwar: " "

Hadrat ‘A’ishah’sra statement, ‘Call him Khatamul-Anbiya’, but do not say that there would be no Prophet after him’

[ 57 ]

WP-khutba-12.book Page 58 Thursday, June 29, 2017 5:28 PM

True Insights into the Concept of Khatm-e-Nubuwwat

was made keeping in view the advent of Hadrat ‘Isa (Jesus Christ). The Imam adds that Hadrat ‘A’ishah’sra advice was in no way in conflict with the hadith, La Nabiyya ba‘di, because by those words, the Holy Prophetsa only meant that there can be no law-bearing Prophet in the future who will abrogate his Shari‘ah and Law. According to Imam Tahir, there were two reasons why Hadrat ‘A’ishah ra forbade the use of the phrase “No Prophet after him.” First, it blocks the coming the Messiah. See how the verdict of a righteous scholar differs from the clerics of today! When the clerics of today say that the Mes- siah can come, but no one else, they misinterpret the phrase. If the Holy Prophetsa meant a total termination of prophethood after him, he would have said la yakuna ba‘di Nabbiyyun—no Prophet would be raised after me. What he said was: La Nabiyya ba‘di—there is no Prophet after me. If these people insist that La Nabiyya ba‘di means total termi- nation of prophethood, then they close the door to the sec- ond coming of the Messiahas. The second reason that Imam Muhammad Tahir gives is that the Holy Prophet sa was not closing the door of prophethood, but only of the law-bearing prophethood that would abrogate his law.

[ 58 ]

WP-khutba-12.book Page 59 Thursday, June 29, 2017 5:28 PM

A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam

Hadrat Imam ‘Abdul-Wahhab Sha‘rani (died 976 A.H.) wrote:

The Holy Prophet’ssa statements that there will be no Prophet or no Messenger after him only meant that there will be no law-bearing Prophet after him. (al- Yawaqit wal-Jawahir, vol. 2, p. 35)

This is exactly the same meaning as emphasized by the Promised Messiahas. Yet, this meaning is so repugnant to our opponents. Hadrat As-Sayyidush-Sharif Muhammad bin Rasulil- Husaini, a prominent scholar of the Indo-Pakistan subcon- tinent who is known for his commentary of Mishkat, a book of hadith, has been quoted before. He further writes: " "

According to the ulema, the words La Nabiyya ba‘di, occurring in the hadith, simply mean that there would be no Prophet after the Holy Prophet sa who would abrogate his law. (al-Isha‘ah li Ishratis-Sa‘ah, p. 149)

In short, the most prominent holy men in the ummah have held the same view of La Nabiyya ba‘di as expressed by the

[ 59 ]

WP-khutba-12.book Page 60 Thursday, June 29, 2017 5:28 PM

True Insights into the Concept of Khatm-e-Nubuwwat

Promised Messiahas. Yet, the Promised Messiahas is called a ‘kafir’ [disbeliever] while these holy men are highly regarded and extolled. Even the White Paper of the Gov- ernment of Pakistan accepts them as top scholars and great thinkers in Islam. Amongst them is Hadrat Shah Waliyyul- lah Muhaddith Dehlavi, who is universally acknowledged as the Mujaddid (reformer) of the 12th century and whom I have quoted earlier as well. He writes: :

From the words La Nabiyya ba‘di used by the Holy Prophetsa, we learn with certainty that there would be no Prophet after him who would bring a new Law or Shari‘ah. (Qurratul-‘Ainain fi Tafdilish-Shaikhain, by Waliyyullah Dehlavi, p. 319)

Hadrat Hafiz Barkhurdar (died 1093 A.H.), son of Hadrat Imam Sheikh Naushah Ganj, the leader of the Naushah Qadiriyyah order, who is held in high esteem throughout the Indo-Pakistan subcontinent, writes:

The words La Nabiyya ba‘di simply mean that there will be no law-bearing Prophet after the Holy Prophetsa . However, Allah may appoint a Prophet

[ 60 ]

WP-khutba-12.book Page 61 Thursday, June 29, 2017 5:28 PM

A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam

and a saint as He wills. (Sharah li Sharhil-‘Aqa’id, known as Nibras, p. 445)

Let us review the beliefs of the Ahle-Hadith till the advent of the Promised Messiahas. Hadrat Nawwab Nurul-Hasan Khan, son of Nawwab Siddiq Hasan Khan, explaining his view of the hadith ‘La Nabiyya ba‘di’ says: The so called hadith ‘la wahya ba‘da mauti’ – [divine revelation w ill be stopped after my death] is unfounded. We have a hadith ‘La Nabiyya ba‘di’ which according to the learned means that after the Holy Prophet sa there would be no Prophet who would abrogate his law. (Iqtirabus-Sa‘ah, p. 162)

It is worth noting that, in explaining the meaning of La Nabiyya ba‘di, the phrase “According to the learned...” is used. Similar words, as quoted earlier, have been used by Shah Waliyyullah and Mulla ‘Ali Qari. It would therefore appear that an inclination to distort the meaning of this hadith had set in by that time. Two distinct groups had emerged: One comprising these God-fearing holy men and the other consisting of the common people led by their ulema who have been called by a prominent scholar as ignorant and deprived of common sense. That is why these wise people used references to other learned and scholarly people to drive home the real meaning of La Nabiyya ba‘di as explained in the passages above.

[ 61 ]

WP-khutba-12.book Page 62 Thursday, June 29, 2017 5:28 PM

True Insights into the Concept of Khatm-e-Nubuwwat

10 of 10 left today