Cover Page
The True Islamic Concept of Jihad, Part 5
He further writes: To fight the British government or to provide any help to those who fight it (even if they are their own Muslim brothers) is obviously a rebellion and is forbidden. (Ibid.)
[ 16 ] === PDF-Seite 35 === khutba4.book Page 17 Friday, March 3, 2006 11:51 PM
A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam
He also writes in his book Iqtisad fi masa’il al-jihad, on p. 16: It is clear from these arguments that India, despite being under the rule of a Christian government, is a ‘land of peace.’ It is not permissible for any king—be he an Arab or a non-Arab, whether he is the Mahdi from Sudan or Hadrat Sultan Shah of Iran, or even if he is the Amir of Khurasan—to fight them in the matter of religion.
For people who were citizens of the country, it was already incumbent to obey the king or the government of the time. But Maulavi Muhammad Husain Batalvi is passing his verdict for other countries as well. According to him, some of you may be living outside the sphere of the British government, but it is forbidden even for you to fight the British government. He writes: It is forbidden for the Muslim world to oppose and rebel against the British government. (Isha‘at-us-Sun- nah, vol. 6, no. 10:187) Even in this age there is no possibility of a religiously justifiable jihad, since there is no imam of the Muslims with the required traits and conditions. (al- Iqtisad-e-masa’ il al-jihad, p. 42)
Who is your imam today? Is it necessary to have a military government for this type of leadership? When did God establish leaders in the religious world through the agencies of military governments? Maulavi Muhammad Husain
[ 17 ] === PDF-Seite 36 === khutba4.book Page 18 Friday, March 3, 2006 11:51 PM
The True Islamic Concept of Jihad
Batalvi continues: At this time, neither is there a leader of the Muslims with the requisite traits and conditions of leadership, nor have they the numerical strength with which they can hope to conquer their opponents. (Ibid.)
Sir Syed Ahmad Khan said about the people who participated in the rebellion of 1857: This was an illegitimate act of the rebels. It had noth- ing to do with Islam. (see Risalah Baghawat-e-Hind for details)
Hadrat Syed Ahmad Raza Khan Brelvi, imam of the Breilvi sect, writes: India is a ‘land of peace.’ It is not correct to call it a ‘land of conflict.’ (Nusrat-ul-Abrar, Lahore, p. 129)
Prohibition of Fighting the British Under Islamic Law
Hadrat Syed Ahmad Breilvi Shahid—who fought in a jihad, and advanced towards the Frontier Regions9 with the intention of jihad, and also fought the Sikhs—was a holy person whose heart bore honour for the Muslims. But as far as the British government was concerned, let us hear about it in the words of his biographer, Muhammad
9. In this booklet the term Frontier Region refers to the North Western Frontier Province of India (now Pakistan) and contiguous regions of Afghanistan.
[ 18 ] === PDF-Seite 37 === khutba4.book Page 19 Friday, March 3, 2006 11:51 PM
A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam
Ja‘far Thanisary. He writes in Sawaneh-e-Ahmadi Kalan, on p. 71: Someone asked him: Are the British not the deniers of Islam who rule this country? Can’t you fight them and take India back? He said: Although the British government denies Islam, it does not oppress or carry out excesses against the Muslims. Nor does it stop them from their obligatory religious duty and worship. We do our propagation in their country openly and spread our faith. It never forbids them. Our main mission is the spreading of God’s Unity and the rekindling of the way of the Leader of the Messengerssa. If we do whatever we like in this country, then how can we carry out jihad against the British government and shed blood on both sides without justification? After listening to this cogent answer the ques- tioner kept silent and understood the real purpose of jihad. (Sawaneh-e-Ahmadi Kalan, p. 71)
But even to this day, the opponents of Ahmadiyyat do not understand this point. ‘Allam‘ah Shibli Nu‘mani states: Since the golden age of the Messenger of Godsa until today, it has been the principle of the Muslims that whichever government they live under, they remain loyal and obedient to it. It was not only their action, but also the teaching of their religion which is both implied and clearly mentioned in the Holy Qur’an,
[ 19 ] === PDF-Seite 38 === khutba4.book Page 20 Friday, March 3, 2006 11:51 PM
The True Islamic Concept of Jihad
the Hadith, and the Fiqah [Islamic jurisprudence]. (Maqalat-e-Shibli, vol. 1, p. 171)
Khwajah Hasan Nizami states: The principle of jihad is known to every child in our midst.
Meaning, as long as the British government was there, every child knew the same principle that the Promised Messiahas used to state. But ever since the government departed, the entire principle has changed. Now, every child is told something entirely different. What was it that every child used to know? Khwajah Sahib states: They know that when disbelievers interfere in reli- gious matters and the just imam, who has the com- plete means of waging a war, passes the verdict to fight, then fighting becomes obligatory on every Muslim. But the British neither interfere with our religious affairs, nor do they carry out any excesses in any other matter which can be called oppression. Nor do we have the means to wage war. In such a situa- tion, we would never listen to anyone and will not put our lives in danger. (Risalah Sheikh Sanusi, p. 17, by Khwajah Hasan Nizami)