Beliefs Concerning the Mahdi

The True Nature of the Mahdi

It is necessary that I should enlighten the Honourable British Government about the belief regarding the Promised Mahdi that is held by the Wahabi sect whose followers call themselves the Ahl-e-Hadith, and whose self-proclaimed leader is Maulvi Abu Saeed Muhammad Husain of Batala; and also my and my community’s belief [regarding the Mahdi]. For, the root cause of this entire dispute, and that of their enmity towards me, is that I do not believe in the Mahdi in whom they believe. It is for this reason that they consider me a disbeliever; and in my view they are in the wrong. Hence, I write below my belief about the Mahdi as against that of theirs. Although, this belief, which is held by the Ahl-e- Hadith—who in fact are called Wahabis—can be found in hundreds of their magazines and books, yet I deem it appropriate to mention some aspects of this belief from the books of Nawwab Siddiq Hasan Khan. For, Maulvi Muhammad Husain—the leader of Wahabis—believes that Siddiq Hasan Khan is the Mujaddid (مُجَدِّد) of this century (see Isha’at-us-Sunnah) and his books constitute the guidance of a Mujaddid. And according to him it is incumbent on all of the Ahl-e-Hadith to follow them. And these beliefs are:

Belief of Our

Opponent Maulvis

Regarding the Mahdi

Nawwab Siddiq Hasan mah, page 373 and his

64, mention the belief of ing the Mahdi, the gist of which is: ‘As soon as the

Mahdi appears, he will kill Christians to such an

extent that those, who were left alive, would no longer have the courage to govern or rule. And all traces [of the desire]

to rule will be erased from their hearts and, having been humiliated, they will run away.’

My and My Community’s Belief Regarding the Mahdi

My and my Community’s belief about the Mahdi and the Promised Messiah is that all those types of Hadith, which are about the coming of the Mahdi, are by no means reliable or authentic in their entirety. In my view they are susceptible to three types of objections or, in other words, they are not outside three categories. First those Hadith that are fabricated, inauthentic and false. And their narrators are open to the charge of dishonesty and falsehood. And no righteous Muslim can rely on them. Second, those Hadith

Then, on line 8 of page

374 of the same book

Nawwab Siddiq Hasan

Khan writes: ‘After this victory, the Mahdi will invade, and conquer,

India. And the King of

India will be brought before him, with an iron collar, put around

his neck, and all the treasures and banks of the Government will be plundered.’ This point is further explained on page 64 of Iqtarab-us-

Sa’ah, lines 13 to 18, as follows, ‘The kings of

India will be brought before the Mahdi with

iron collars put around their necks; and Bayt-ulthat are weak and Majruh (مَجْرُوح); or, are such that, on account of their mutual contradictions and inconsistencies, they have become unreliable. And either no known Compilers of Hadith has mentioned them; or has mentioned them by pointing out their defects or unreliability. And they have not authenticated their Riwayat (رِوَایَت) i.e., they [the Compilers] have not borne witness to the truthfulness and integrity of the narrators.

Third, those Hadith that are in fact authentic and their authenticity becomes known by their being reported by various chains of Belief of Our Opponent

Maulvis Regarding the

Mahdi (Cont’d)

Maqdis will be adorned with their treasures.’

(After this, he gives his

own opinion and the words that he uses in its support are): ‘I say that at present there is not even a single king in India. There are only a few Hindu and Muslim rulers. However, they are

not even rulers in their own right; they are only nominal rulers. The true kings of this country are the Europeans, and perhaps till that time— that is the time [of the advent] of the Mahdi—they will remain so. And it is they who

will be captured and brought before him, i.e.,

[authentic] narrators, yet either they have been fulfilled [in respect of their prophecies] sometimes in the past and the wars that they mention have come to an end since long ago, and now no possibility of warfare exists, so that one should wait for it; or they are such that they do not at all mention worldly Khilafat and actual wars: they only give the glad tidings about the coming of a Mahdi, that is, a rightly-guided man. And through indications, but rather, in so many words, too, it has been mentioned in them that he [the Mahdi] will not have a worldly kingdom and Khilafat. And that he will not wage wars,

Belief of Our Opponent

Maulvis Regarding the

Mahdi (Cont’d)

the Mahdi.’ Earlier, this same person has written:

‘They will be brought before the Mahdi in iron collars.’ In Hujajul-Kiramah it is written that such a time is near and all this will likely

10 of 10 left today