Maulawi Muhammad Ali Refuted by his own Arguments
Truth About the Split
Moreover, if we were to accept their view as correct, it would expose us to serious criticism from our Christian critics. The Messiah of Islam, they would say, like the Messiah of Judaism, had answered his enemies saying that he was a Nabi in the same sense in which the previous Prophets were called Ambiya’. If, in the presence of such an explanation, Muslims felt justified in making a difference between his Nubuwwat (prophethood) and that of the previous
Ambiya’, could not Christians claim a similar privilege, viz. to claim for Jesus (as), notwithstanding, his own assertion to the contrary, a godhood in a sense different from the godhood of the previous Ambiya’? The argument with which Maulawi Muhammad Ali would confront the Christians clearly amounts to this that since Jesus (as) himself had explained that he was 'god' only in the sense in which the previous Prophets were called 'gods', there was no justification on the part of his followers "to reject the explanation given by Jesus, "and to claim godhood for him in any other but the same sense. (Vide page 6—The Split). Under the circumstances, may we not ask him how, in the case of the second Messiah—in view of his assertion that he was a Nabi in the same sense in which the previous Prophets were called Ambiya’—the Maulawi Sahib would justify himself in saying that the old Prophets were Ambiya’ in one sense but the Promised Messiah (as) a Nabi in another sense? If in spite of the answer which the Promised Messiah (as) gave to his opponents, Maulawi Muhammad Ali considers himself justified in regarding the older Prophets as genuine Ambiya’ and the Promised Messiah as a mere titular Nabi ('not actual prophethood'; not the perfect prophethood of a real Prophet.' Vide page 149—The Split), then consistently with the same rule he ought to interpret his quotation from the New Testament in the sense that the previous Ambiya’ were really Divine, whereas to Jesus had been granted merely the name of God, or in the alternative, to accept the Christian view that the old Prophets merely bore the name of God whereas Jesus was really Divine. In view of the above facts, let me now appeal to the "good sense and moral courage" of the Maulawi Sahib to consider and decide whether the verses quoted by him from the New Testament, point to his party or to mine as counter-part of the misguided followers of Jesus (as).
The Christians, notwithstanding the explanation of Jesus (as), that he was 'god' in the sense in which the previous Prophets were 'gods', persisted in asserting that the word carried one sense when applied to the Prophets and another when used in reference to Jesus (as). So the author of The Split and his party, notwithstanding the clear statement of the Promised Messiah (as) that he was a Nabi in the same sense in which the previous, Prophets bore that title (as may well be seen from the quotations from his writing given above), would still persist in saying that the older Prophets were Ambiya’ in one sense and the Promised Messiah (as) a Nabi in another sense. The difference between the author of The Split and his followers and the misguided followers of Jesus (as) lies in this, that the latter while altering the meaning of the words 'God' and 'son of God' remained faithful to their Master attributing to him through excess of love a rank higher than was really his due; but the author of The Split and his friends, out of excessive hostility, would only attribute to their Master a rank much lower than he actually occupied. But the truth is that it rested neither with the one nor with the other to elevate or depreciate the rank of their respective Masters.