Argument from my ArticleKufr-o-Islam
Truth About the Split, Part 2
Regarding the main subject of my article, I wrote that as we believed the Promised Messiah (as) to be one of the Prophets of God, we could not possibly regard his deniers as Muslims. It is true we did not consider them to be kafir billah, (deniers of God), but how could we doubt that, they were kafir-bil-ma’mur (deniers of a God’s Messenger)? Those who say that they regarded Mirza Sahib as a righteous person and so did not deserve to be called kuffar, ought to consider whether a righteous person ever spoke an untruth. If Mirza Sahib (as), was indeed a righteous person, what possible objection could there be to their subscribing to his claim. After this, the article proceeded to quote passages from the writings of the
Promised Messiah (as) to show that he regarded his deniers as kuffar. Some of the passages, quoted in the article, are reproduced here in brief: To the apostate Abdul Hakim of Patiala, he wrote: "At any rate, when the great God has revealed to me that every body whom my Call has reached and who has failed to accept my claim, is not a Muslim, and is liable to account before God, how can I at the instance of one individual, whose heart is steeped in a thousand darknesses, ignore the command of God. It is easier to cut off such a one from my Community. Accordingly from this date I hereby exclude you from the Community of my followers." Following this, I proceeded to explain the purport of the above passage in the following words. "The above words apply not merely to those who take an active part in denouncing the Promised Messiah (as); but every person who fails to accept him is not a Muslim. Further on, I explained, in the words of the Promised Messiah (as) himself, the meaning he attached to the expression "reaching of Call." This was that the Promised Messiah (as) had made his Call reach every part of the globe, and hence the whole world might be said to have received his Call. It was unnecessary for this purpose that the information should be carried separately to each individual. After this, I went on to prove from the writings of the Promised Messiah (as) that those who did not explicitly style the Promised Messiah (as) as a kafir but nor did they accept his claim, were to be classed with those who styled him as a kafir; so also were those who only waited for fuller information and put off entering into his Bai‘at. Then in my own words.
I summarised the purport of the quotations as follows: "Thus, according to these quotations, not only are those deemed to be kuffar, who openly style the Promised Messiah (as) as kafir, and those who although they do not style him thus, decline still to accept his claim, but even those who, in their hearts, believe the Promised Messiah (as) to be true, and do not even deny him with their tongues, but hesitate to enter into his Bai‘at, have here been adjudged to be kuffar." After this, some more quotations were given in support of the main contention, and the weakness implicit in the overture for friendship was exposed, and the Promised Messiah’s (as) fatwa (pronouncement) which forbade Ahmadis to pray behind non-Ahmadi Imams was quoted. And lastly, it was argued from a verse of the Holy Qur’an that such people as had failed to recognise the Promised Messiah (as) as a Rasul even if they called him a righteous person with their tongues, were yet veritable kuffar.
Such was my article which was twice read through by Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) , and corrected in several places in his own hand, and regarding the purport of which he remarked that he had no difference whatsoever. Now, after reading the above and after perusing those passages which I have quoted, is it possible for any intelligent person to imagine that Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) could possibly take the article to say no more than that those who did not accept Hadrat Mirza Sahib were only deniers of Hadrat Mirza Sahib?
The question now remains, how was it that Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) at all put his signature to the incorrect version of the article given by Khwaja Kamaluddin? In answering this, we should remember in the first place that, in view of the circumstances described above, it is altogether impossible to conclude, from the mere fact of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) signing the announcement by Khwaja Sahib, that he disapproved of my article. This, because the written approval which Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) accorded to my article and the corrections he himself made in it still exist. Nor can it be supposed that Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) misunderstood the purport of my article, because it was impossible even for a mere schoolboy to receive the article in the sense attributed to it by Khwaja Kamaluddin. Seeing, therefore, the impossibility of both these alternatives, the only alternative left is to believe that either Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) did not actually read the Khwaja’s announcement, and authorised its publication merely upon hearing about it from Khwaja Sahib or that the ambiguous announcement, wherein Khwaja Sahib by the deft use of a tortuous style had tried to undo the effect of my article, had been wrongly understood by Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) . The announcement by Khwaja Sahib as well as the substance of it, given by Maulawi Muhammad Ali, would show that Khwaja Sahib had intended to attain his end by the use of ambiguous language. But for this, he could well have declared in plain words that non-Ahmadis were Muslims. He had no business to try and interpret my article while I was alive and was well able to interpret it myself. If any doubt really existed regarding its intention, he ought to have referred the matter to me. The very line of action, adopted by him, shows that he aimed at hood-winking the public, and it was to this end that he employed an equivocal style of expression. If Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) really read the announcement and sanctioned its publication, then he must have misunderstood its purport; and there is corroborative evidence in support of this view.
It happened that when the announcement by Khwaja Kamaluddin was published, there was general whispering among the people that Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) was vacillating, sometimes saying one thing and sometimes another; that while on the one hand, he had put his signature to my article, he had, on the other, also signed the announcement by Khwaja Sahib. One gentleman brought this to the notice of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) . I was at the time sitting nearby. Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) denied that there was any discrepancy between his actions, and said that he had signed the announcement by Khwaja Sahib only because Khwaja Sahib had assured him that he had nothing to object to in Miyań Sahib’s (the present writer’s) article and that his announcement had been prepared only to save those thousands of Ahmadis who lived on the frontier from being molested by their opponents, and that it was simply to appease the frontier-men, that he had expressed the sense of the article in language calculated to avert trouble. I remember that there were present at the time two or three other persons also, and, so far as I remember, there was present also an Ahmadi from the frontier, who had in a letter already made reference to this very question. Very likely, it was Mufti Muhammad Sadiq who brought this question to the notice of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) . I do not know whether Mufti Muhammad Sadiq still remembers the incident but for myself I am prepared to affirm it on oath. I now ask Maulawi Muhammad Ali and his friends whether he or they are prepared to affirm on oath that Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) really understood the purport of my article in the sense alleged by Maulawi Muhammad Ali. I am sure, they will never venture to do so, and will only make excuses to escape the oath. They know full well that it is impossible to understand my article in any but its own evident sense.