The Grave Day: 31 st January

Truth About the Split, Part 2

If what, Maulawi Muhammad Ali said on coming down from the mosque were supported only by the uncorroborated testimony of Maulawi Abdur Rahim Nayyar, I would not have incorporated it here. For, however, reliable as a reporter he would still have been the only witness of what was said, while my purpose here is to incorporate only such facts as have the most irrefutable evidence behind them. But as later events also proved that when Maulawi Muhammad Ali renewed his Bai‘at with Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) , he was actuated only by fear and expediency, we have no reason to disbelieve the statement of Maulawi Abdur Rahim Nayyar. There is also another incident which goes to corroborate M. Abdur Rahim’s story. Soon after this meeting on a certain occasion when I was present with Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) a message came to him from Maulawi Muhammad Ali to the effect that the Maulawi Sahib had resolved to leave Qadian as he had been insulted and humiliated. This also supports the statement of M. Abdur Rahim Nayyar.

There are hundreds of eye-witnesses to these events. Among the people who took part in this meeting, there are now some who have joined Maulawi Muhammad Ali’s party and others who have entered my Bai‘at. But I have every hope that if asked to make a statement on solemn oath members of both parties will alike testify to the truth of the facts as I have described them. It is hardly possible for anybody to hide facts of such importance relating to a gathering of such magnitude.

Before proceeding further with the narrative of these events. I wish to make a brief digression in order to present to my reader a picture of the moral condition of these men. This will enable them to judge for themselves how far Maulawi Muhammad Ali and his friends have been sincere in their dealings. When Khwaja Kamaluddin returned home from England for the first time he delivered a lecture on the subject of the dissensions. In this lecture he made a reference to this renewal of Bai‘at but gave it a most strange colouring. He represented the whole incident as though Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) convinced of the spiritual perfection of these men had asked them to enter into a special Bai‘at with him. Anyone who reads the description I have given of the incident will be in a position to understand that a person who can depict a Bai‘at, entered into under circumstances of the whole incident as a Bai‘at of fealty or a mark of favour, and thus tries to throw dust into the eyes of others can ill deserve our esteem. The actual words used by Khwaja Sahib were "He (Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) ) required from me a second Bai‘at. This is quite true. But what kind of Bai‘at was it? Bai‘at-e- Irshad. Can you say honestly that he got me to renew my Bai‘at'? It was indeed Bai‘at-e-Irshad and not a renewal of Bai‘at or Bai‘at-e-Taubah. After this there is yet another kind of Bai‘at and that, is Bai‘at-e- Dam. Now go and look up the books of Sufis to find out from what class of disciples they received Bai‘ate-Irshad. They receive Bai‘at-e-Taubah when they accept a disciple into their following, and when they observe in him the capacity for strict obedience, they receive from him the Bai‘at-e-Irshad, and when they come to possess full confidence in him, they receive from him the Bai‘at-e-Dam, (Vide Andruni Ikhtilafate-Silsilah Ahmadiyya kei Asbab, p. 58).

But to resume, Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) was annoyed at the action of these men and most seriously so. He made them renew their Bai‘at. But while other people had their hearts chastened by the experience, the incident served merely to fan the flames of hatred in the hearts of these men. The only difference the incident made in their conduct was that whereas formerly they sometimes exhibited their feeling in overt actions, after the incident they took care to conceal them, awaiting the psychological moment when this volcano of hate might be allowed to burst and demolish the edifice of Ahmadiyyat. From this time on, Maulawi Muhammad Ali fell into the hands of the other party who held beliefs different from those of the Community and his dissatisfaction gradually drove him so close to the other party that in course of two or three years by a process of imperceptible change, he came to identify himself wholly with their beliefs.

10 of 10 left today