Apathy to Propagation of Ahmadiyyat
Truth About the Split, Part 2
It is obvious from this account that the vision was not fulfilled at the hands of Khwaja Sahib, for while the vision indicated that it was the Promised Messiah (as) who caught those birds, the converts won through the activities of Khwaja Sahib had no connection whatsoever with the Promised Messiah (as). The view of Islam presented by Khwaja Sahib to these new converts was the same as was owned by the bitterest opponents of the Promised Messiah (as) like Maulawi Muhammad Husain of Batala and Maulawi Sanaullah of Amritsar. Though the vision had nothing to do with the work that Khwaja Sahib was doing, a fact made more and more evident by-subsequent events—yet to win the support of Ahmadis Khwaja Sahib persisted in giving wide publicity to the vision and its fulfilment at his hands. This publicity, however, was strictly confined to the Ahmadiyya Community. Among non-Ahmadis it was announced that this propaganda was being carried on behalf of the broad principles of Islam, and the enterprise therefore deserved the financial support of the entire body of Muslims and all should contribute to this good work. (It may be noted that during the earlier days of his stay in England, Khwaja Sahib took care to keep everybody in the dark regarding the nature of the work he was doing).
At the time Khwaja Sahib reached England the Balkan War was in progress. He published a tract in connection with that war in which after quoting a revelation of the Promised Messiah (as) regarding Turkey:
i.e.: "Turkey has been defeated in a land hard by, but soon they will be victorious after their defeat", he drew the attention of the Turks to the advent of the Promised Messiah (as). The news of the publication of this tract by Khwaja Sahib pleased Ahmadis, who thought that at last Khwaja Sahib had returned to the right path. But in the meantime, the conversion of a few Englishmen to Islam brought to Khwaja Sahib the support of the general body of non-Ahmadi Muslims, but they gave him to understand that the support would be withdrawn in case he made any mention of the Ahmadiyya Movement in the course of his proselytising activities. Thus it was that Khwaja Sahib, who had shown such courage in publishing in Turkish lands, this prophecy of the Promised Messiah (as) relating to Turkey assumed such a deep silence when the prophecy was actually fulfilled that he never again even mentioned the subject.
The year 1913 was marked by two important events. On my return from the Hajj I was much impressed by the need for strengthening the press at Qadian. This need was suggested to me by Maulawi Abul Kalam Azad’s paper Al-Hilal, which was largely subscribed to by Ahmadis, so that there was reason to apprehend that some Ahmadis might be influenced by the poisonous writings of that paper. Accordingly, I bestirred myself for the purpose, and secured the permission of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) for the publication of a new paper from Qadian, which in addition to religious matters, should contain matters also of general interest, and thus enable Ahmadis to satisfy their need for religious as well as general reading from the organs of the Movement. After I had obtained the permission of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) , I heard that our friends Dr. Mirza Ya‘qub Baig, Dr. Sayyid Muhammad Husain Shah and Shaikh Rahmatullah also proposed publishing a paper from Lahore. As soon as I received the news, I sent a note to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) saying that as the friends named above were preparing to publish a paper from Lahore, and that as this paper would serve the purpose I had in view the publication of my paper, if Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) should permit, might be dropped for the present. To this Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) replied that there was a difference between the objects of the two papers, and that I should therefore continue the preparations I had started for my own paper. So, I went on with my preparations. In the early part of June the Paigham-e-Sulh was issued from Lahore, and towards the middle of the same month the Al-Fadl made its appearance from Qadian. The publication of these two papers meant to outsiders only the addition of two papers to hundreds already existing in the journalistic world of India, but for the Ahmadiyya Movement their appearance proved to be an event of the greatest moment in its history.
The publication of the Paigham-e-Sulh brought to the surface the poison that had so long been accumulating in the body of the Community, and attempts to obliterate the distinctive features of the Ahmadiyya Movement began to be made openly. The Jama‘at of Qadian was made the object of special attention in the articles published in the paper, and overtures for peace began to be made to the enemies of the Movement. The main purpose of the paper probably was to promote public support for the mission of Khwaja Kamaluddin to England, but as was natural, space had also to be found for the discussion of matters which were in dispute among Ahmadis. In order to obtain circulation for it among non-Ahmadis the Promised Messiah (as) began to be addressed simply as Mirza Sahib ‘alaihir Rahmah, this form of address being less objectionable to non- Ahmadis. Praises were lavished up on the enemies of the Movement. The Sultan of Turkey began to be called Khalifatul Muslimin. In short, every effort was made to obliterate the distinctiveness of Ahmadiyyat and to make Ahmadis and non-Ahmadis merge into one common mass.
Not long after the appearance of the two papers, the Muslims of India became highly excited over the demolition of a bath attached to a mosque in Cawnpore. The men who lost their lives in the riot in connection with this affair were acclaimed as Shahids (religious martyrs), and virulent articles were published in the public organs criticising the action of the Government. On this occasion the Paigham-e- Sulh made common cause with the other public organs in their attack upon the Government. The managers of the Paigham-e-Sulh sent a special agent to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) to consult him about the question. Articles by Maulawi Muhammad Ali were also published. These were openly in support of the agitators. The views of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) were, however, so far distorted in the process of publication that they came to have a meaning quite different from the one intended and the conclusion was drawn from them that on this occasion, Government had been guilty of excess, and that they were not justified in demolishing any part of the mosque. Such, however, were not the views of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) who had directed me to write that a bath formed no part of the mosque, and that consequently people were not justified in disturbing the peace over it. When the articles published in the Paigham-e-Sulh were brought to the notice of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) , he strongly disapproved of them and made me write two articles under his personal direction, the notes of which are still in my possession. In these articles special emphasis was laid upon the point that baths attached to mosques formed no part of mosque and that those who were engaged in agitating over the affair were wrong and were in fact acting hypocritically. He desired me, however, not to publish the articles over his name but to publish them on my own account. When these articles were published, a report was circulated that in these articles I had abused Maulawi Muhammad Ali who was the author of the articles published in the Paigham-e- Sulh.
Accordingly, Dr. Muhammad Sharif of Batala, at present Civil Surgeon Hoshiarpur (who has subsequently moved to other places) who was at that time probably at Sargodha, in the course of a visit to Qadian, mentioned the matter to me. I told him that the articles were not really mine, but had been written almost at the dictation of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) . To this, he answered: "How could Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) , who holds Maulawi Muhammad Ali in such regard, use such language in reference to him?" Upon this, I sent for a copy of the paper in which the article to which he objected, had been published, and wrote the following in the margin: "This article was dictated to me by Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) and the strong language which it contains was used by him and was not put in by me." I then made over the paper to the Doctor Sahib asking him to go and lay it before Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) , and find out for himself whether the articles were written at his dictation or at my instance. He took the paper to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) . As he was then in a hurry to leave Qadian he could not see me before his departure. However, he returned the paper to me through a relative of his saying that what I had said was quite true. This gentleman holds a respectable office, and is one of those who share the views of Maulawi Muhammad Ali, and is not a follower of mine. Maulawi Muhammad Ali, therefore, can inquire from him on oath whether what I say is true or not.
In short, the Cawnpore mosque controversy served further to divide the Jama‘at into two sections. It led one section to drift more and more towards the extremist wing of Indian politics, and induced the other to adhere more closely to the teachings of the Promised Messiah (as). And God be praised that the latter party formed by far the larger section of the Ahmadiyya Community.
While these events were taking place in India, Khwaja Sahib in England came across a certain Lord Headley who had for a long time acknowledged the truth of Islam. He had been a follower of the faith for nearly 40 years, but as he never happened to find a regular congregation of Muslims, he knew not how to make a public announcement of the fact of his conversion. After he met Khwaja Sahib, he made a public declaration of his change of faith stating that he had actually been a Muslim for forty years.
The news was trumpeted to the world by Khwaja Sahib that through his efforts a British peer had accepted the faith of Islam. Immediately Khwaja Sahib became a popular idol, and from all sides a chorus of praise was raised for the service he had rendered to Islam. But to the people who knew that Lord Headley had been a Muslim for forty years, the whole affair caused considerable surprise, and they were astonished to find that Khwaja Sahib had been distorting the truth. But Khwaja Sahib was set on the one object of winning success and popularity for his mission. It did not matter whether the means employed by him were fair or foul. His announcement of the conversion of Lord Headley appears to me to have misled many of those Ahmadis who are now the followers of the Lahore party. The conversion seemed to them to be a sign of Divine assistance, indicating that therefore Khwaja Sahib must be right. In actual fact, of course, there was no Divine assistance but rather moral suicide on the part of Khwaja Sahib, and as long as the Ahmadiyya Movement lives and by the grace of God it will continue to live till the end of days, the misrepresentations and craft employed by Khwaja Sahib will ever be remembered with surprise and amazement.
The apparent success which attended Khwaja Sahib’s activities proved too strong a temptation for a section of the Community, and as I have already said, they began to look upon it as a sign of Divine assistance. They now thought that on the question of the proper method of propagation their own judgment had been at fault. They thought that success was to be attained only by adopting the policy of Khwaja Sahib. These views were supported and encouraged by articles published in the Paigham-e-Sulh. The controversies, however, led to one good result. They exposed to view the machinations, which had previously been carried on in secret and thus served to put the Community upon its guard. No doubt, a section of the Community was carried away by the tide but the loss proved a source of safety for the rest.
When the internal dissensions of the Community had once been made public, there remained no longer any reason for further secrecy. In the Paigham-e-Sulh attacks began to be made openly on the Ahmadis who lived at Qadian, and refutation of those attacks were published in the columns of the Al-Fadl under the direction of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) . It is true that members of the Paigham party, whenever they became aware of having incurred the open displeasure of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) used to run up to him and sue for his pardon, but no sooner did they return from his presence than they reverted to their own ways. This period was fraught with the gravest danger for the Movement, because even its enemies had now become aware of the disputes which for some years had been dividing Ahmadis into opposite ranks. Nor were they slow to take advantage of this state of affairs. They began openly to encourage the Lahore party, and to induce them by various means to persist in the dispute till at last Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) was compelled once to call the Paigham-e-Sulh (lit. message of peace) Paigham-e-Jang (lit. message of war).
The truculence of the new party was, however, confined to the columns of their newspaper. They still continued to entertain a fear of Hadrat Khalifatul- Masih and as they dared not write anything openly against him their fettered activities naturally led some followers of Maulawi Muhammad Ali to take a leaf out of the book of the anarchists of Bengal, so that they began publishing a series of tracts which bore the name neither of its publisher nor of its author. Two tracts in this connection, were published by them under the titles of Izharul Haq No. 1 and Izharul Haq No. 2.