Who Wrote the Tracts?
Truth About the Split, Part 2
Replies to Anonymous Tracts.
The distribution of the tracts among members of the Community, acted as a bombshell. The Community founded by the Promised Messiah (as) now realised the serious nature of their responsibility, and desired that a suitable reply should be written to the tracts. Fear of the disfavour of the Community and the displeasure of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) now induced the authorities of the Paigham-e-Sulh to publish a brief note disavowing the remarks, which had previously been published in that paper in support of the tracts. But the language used in the note was so equivocal that while, from one point of view, the note seemed to denounce the sentiments expressed in the tracts, from another point of view it seemed to lend support to those sentiments. Another group, however, was destined to make a proper rejoinder to the tracts. This was the Anjuman Ansarullah. As the writer of the tracts had made the Anjuman Ansarullah the special object of his attack and the Paigham-e-Sulh had also addressed its remarks to them, Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) , was pleased to entrust the Ansarullah the duty of replying to the tracts.
The reply was published under the direction of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) in the form of two tracts. The first was named Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya, and was a reply to the tract Izharul Haq No, 1. The second was named Izhar-e-Haqiqat, and furnished a reply to Izharul Haq No. 2. Both these tracts were shown to and were corrected by Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) . At one place, Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) added these words: "A thousand shames upon the Paigham-e- Sulh, which in publishing its letter delivered to us a declaration of war and cast the apple of discord."
After the publication of these tracts, I tried also to induce members of the party, in whose interest the anonymous tracts seemed to have been written and published to issue a refutation of them. But as they were only dissembling and were at heart in sympathy with the views expressed in the tracts, they avoided such a course on various pretences—all except Mir Hamid Shah Sahib who was good enough lo furnish written answers to the questions sent to him among others. Incidentally, Mir Hamid Shah Sahib was the only one out of this group who was granted the grace to enter later into my Bai‘at.
Whether the purpose, which the authors of the anonymous tracts had in view in publishing them, was fulfilled or not would be known only to the authors of the tracts. According to us, one benefit which accrued from their publication was that it afforded us an opportunity to refute publicly the doctrines which Maulawi Muhammad Ali and his partisans had so long been promulgating in secret. And God be thanked, the whole of their intrigue was now exposed to the light of day.
After the publication of these tracts everything was quiet for some time. The manager of the Paigham-e-Sulh and Babu Manzur Ilahi had to sue for Hadrat Khalifatul Masih’s pardon and the whole affair seemed to have closed. But these people did not abandon their plans. Khwaja Kamaluddin now asked for permission to offer prayers behind non-Ahmadi Muslims, pleading as his ground the special circumstances of England. According to him the people there knew nothing about the Ahmadiyya Movement, and it was not desirable to acquaint them with differences among different sects which prevailed in Islam. At length, observing how weak Khwaja Sahib was in his faith, Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) granted him the permission on which he was so keen. The first use Khwaja Sahib made of the permission was to pray behind Maulawi Zafar Ali Khan, the well-known editor of the Zamińdar, one of the bitterest enemies of the Ahmadiyya Movement and its most foul-mouthed detractor. Apparently. Khwaja Sahib attributed to the soil of England the virtue which Hindus impute to the river Ganges, the virtue that is of purifying everyone who visited its shores. In India, it might indeed be unlawful to pray behind Maulawi Zafar Ali Khan, but no sooner did he put his foot on English soil, than all his sins dropped away from him making it legitimate for anybody to offer his prayers behind him.
I have said that after the publication of replies to the tracts there was peace and quiet, but this was only outwardly so. The fire of rancour smouldered within the breasts of the people, and this fact was manifested on the occasion of the Annual Jalsa in December 1913. It happened in this way.
In the course of his address on the occasion of this Jalsa, Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) once again made a reference to the anonymous tracts and expressed his strong disapproval of them. Upon this, the Paighame-Sulh promptly published a distorted version of his address stating that the Khalifa had expressed his strong disapproval of the booklets published in reply to those tracts by the Ansarullah. The object was to restore the effect of the anonymous tracts and to destroy the effect of the replies, although, as a matter of fact, the replies had been published under the direction of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) and after having been shown to him and after corrections had been made by him. As a matter of fact, the last time the manuscripts of the replies were shown to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) and permission was sought for making them over to the press, Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) wrote as follows: "Publish them in all sincerity. I shall pray, and you too must not cease to pray that the wicked may receive understanding of the consequences of their act.—Nuruddin." This note is still with me. It is not surprising that whereas Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) promises to pray that these replies might prove effective, and in case the author of Izharul Haq does not desist, he utters an imprecation against him. the Paigham-e-Sulh was so blinded by opposition to the truth that it represented Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) as being displeased by the replies issued by the Ansarullah? The fact was that the Paigham-e-Sulh wanted to promote opinion in favour of the Izharul Haq tracts, and to produce prejudice against the replies. But its effort was defeated. For, on the 15th January 1914, Hadrat Khalifatul Masih (ra) published an announcement to the following effect:
"Last year many foolish people tried to create dissensions in the Community, and distributed a pamphlet called Izharul Haq among members of the Community, which cast aspersions on me also. The object of the writer in publishing the pamphlet was to create a split in the Community, but God out of His grace has saved both myself and the Community from this danger."