The Removal of a Misgiving Harboured by Dr Martyn Clarke
The Truth Revealed
Harboured by Dr Martyn Clarke
In his announcement of 12 May 1893, which was published as a supplement to Nur-i-Afshan Ludhiana, Dr Sahib was either deceived by the book Isha‘atus-Sunnah of the Sheikh from Batala or intended to deceive the people by alleging that reliable ulema of Islam—so to speak—have declared this humble one to be a kafir [disbeliever]. It is, therefore, documented here to announce to all and sundry that all reliable ulema of Islam upon whom God Almighty has conferred the mastery of doctrine and its practice, and to whom He has gifted the light of profound insights of faith, are with me and at this moment there are nearly forty of them. Most of the people who side with the other party are maulawi [i.e. learned] only in name and are utterly deprived of excellences in intellect and conduct. Should this statement of my humble self appear to be an exaggeration beyond belief in the view of Dr Sahib, he can see for himself by attending a debate between those ulema who oppose me and the learned ulema who are in the group of this humble one.
In fact, such a debate is about to take place on 15 June 1893 in which the opposing party will be Maulawi Ghulam Dastagir and all the ulema representing his religious point of view from Lahore, and from this side, one or two learned scholars will be nominated. Then the Reverend Gentleman [Dr Clarke] can see with his own eyes the side on which the godly ulema and reliable scholarship are and the side on which the maulawis in name alone and the tongue-tied are. As the famous [Persian] adage goes,
[Urdu or Persian text in the original, see the original page]
[‘Hearing, when was it ever like seeing’]? A unilateral statement coming from the pen of a narrow-minded enemy never holds any weight or respect in the view of an intelligent person; rather, each and every truth becomes apparent at the time it is tested.
Apart from this, Dr [Clarke] Sahib is also well aware that the seat of Islam’s reliable ulema is at the Haramain Sharifain [Two Sanctuaries]—
زادھما ا ہّٰللّٰ مَجۡدًا وشرفًا وبرکۃ [may Allah increase both holy sites in glory, honour, and grace]—and these very cities of Arabia, namely Makkah and Madinah, are considered the abode of the Faith. So, the beloved and reliable scholars of these blessed places are also joining with this humble one. Thus, as an illustration, I am listing below the writings of three noble personalities.