Istifta

A Verdict Required

What do the revered, the discerning, and the wise declare regarding these Divinely revealed testimonies which are written below? Does an examination of them result in the satisfactory conclusion that the prophecy regarding Lekh Ram’s death was actually fulfilled or not? If the fact is proven with the utmost clarity in their opinion with full conviction and satisfaction that the below-written prophecies taken in the form of documentary evidence are declarations beyond human conjecture and contrivance and are supernormal, then purely for the sake of Allah and supporting truth—which is the wont of the valiant, courageous, and righteous servants of God—record your signature at the end of this essay for the purpose of attestation.

I have firm faith that God Almighty will reward them for this truthful testimony and will grant them a full share of success and prosperity in this world and the next. Otherwise, the manifestation of the evil consequences of concealing true testimony is inevitable according to Divine law. However, if in someone’s view, the Divinely revealed testimonies mentioned below do not afford satisfaction; rather, in their opinion, it was actually a human scheme that was paraded as a Divinely revealed prophecy, the result of which was that ultimately—on account of this shrewd conspiracy—Lekh Ram was murdered on 6 March 1897 in Lahore, then such an individual has the option not to record his testimony on this document, and he may proceed to count me amongst the murderers. But if, in his view, these Divinely revealed testimonies are worthy of credibility from which I am entitled to benefit, then I make no demand for religious sympathy at this time, but rather human sympathy, and that, too, only up to the extent that the law grants me the right on the basis of true and proper justice. I solicit this with the utmost respect from the sagacious by way of an istifta’ [demand for a verdict].

And what is it that I seek from the scholarly circles through the means of this Istifta’? Only this that they diligently record their opinion by way of a fatwa [religious verdict] on all [the evidence] that I present before them of a well-arranged and complete series of prophecies concerning the death of Lekh Ram, and that they testify with the zeal of their clear conscience whether reason and righteousness deem it obligatory to ascribe the extraordinary disclosure of this series of revelations to God Almighty. And can it occur to the mind of an intelligent man that all these branches of the prophecy which are beyond human capabilities, should spring forth at once in support of a lie? It is necessary to state at this point that whatever is in the hands of the Aryah gentlemen to refute this prophecy, it is no more than that—out of ill will—instead of reflecting upon the wondrous works of God, they have adopted the habit of giving the possibility of human schemes the very status which is unique to the works of the Omnipotent God. Since this prophecy had been in existence for a little more than four years and it had become known to the Hindus through speeches at various gatherings as well as writings, that it was written in the prophecy that Lekh Ram’s life would end in a terrifying manner, and, moreover, that his demise would occur during the days of Eid within six years, and the prophecy in its explicit wording indicated an incident of murder, they, therefore, deemed it highly improbable that a prophecy from Almighty God would come with such explicit details and signs. They did not consider it plausible that any man could disclose all these matters of the unseen before their occurrence and then demonstrate their complete fulfilment.

Hence, they attributed this Divinely revealed prophecy to human machination and repeatedly published in newspapers, with great insistence, that making such a clear prophecy and stating the date, day, and manner of death in such an open and unveiled manner prior to the event is not the practice of God; nay rather, the truth is that this very person—namely, this writer—is Lekh Ram’s murderer, and this prophecy is the product of deep conspiracies and long-contemplated strategies. It was on this very basis that they collectively exerted pressure to implicate this writer as the culprit, blackening column after column of newspapers in expressing this notion. They made reports to the Government, so much so that on Thursday, the 8th of April 1897, British officers came to Qadian and searched my home.

During the search, letters bearing Pandit Lekh Ram’s signature were discovered. Moreover, the document of agreement was also found, wherein conditions regarding the manifestation of celestial Signs having been established, and with the mutual consent of both parties, a true prophecy had been designated as the criterion for discerning truth from falsehood. Accordingly, the contents of the document were read out in the presence of the District Superintendent of Police. It was written therein that the prophecy that would be made regarding Pandit Lekh Ram would serve as a decisive verdict between the religion of Islam and the Aryah faith.

If the prophecy were to prove true, it would stand as a testimony to the truth of Islam and would be evidence of the falsehood of the Hindu religion. Conversely, if it were to prove false, it would testify to the truth of the Hindu religion and signify—God forbid—the falsehood of Islam. This condition was written upon the insistence of Pandit Lekh Ram himself, and since I had complete trust in the promises of Allah the Almighty, I too accepted this condition. Now, the difficulty that necessitated the soliciting of this Istifta’ is not only that the Aryah gentlemen accused the author of a clandestine conspiracy, but that some esteemed individuals from our own community also concurred with them, and desired to somehow falsify this magnificent prophecy, the refutation of which, according to the agreement documents, would amount to the refutation of Islam itself.

Consequently, Maulawi Abu Sa‘id Muhammad Husain Batalawi, Editor of Isha‘atus-Sunnah, along with a few other maulawis, widely publicised their opinion that this prophecy has proven to be false. Consequently, they even sent a letter addressed to me, in which they had written that, ‘I have concluded in good faith that the prophecy has not been fulfilled; that is, the death of Lekh Ram was an accidental occurrence in which God had no involvement.’ Moreover, they emphasized the question why it should be accepted as proven fact that the prophecy came out true, and why it should not be accepted that this was a coincidental death that happened to take place during the time period specified for the prophecy.

I cared naught whatsoever for this denial so far as my personal interests were concerned; however, since the agreement documents were seized during the time of the search and were read out in the presence of the District Superintendent of Police, and every friend and foe became aware of them, it is now unpardonable to overlook such a truth, the neglect of which would be an unjustified attack against Islam. It was verily due to this dire necessity that this entire episode had to be presented before the sagacious so that they might see the egregious extent of deliberate injustice that was perpetrated. What a pity that these people failed to realize when publicizing these opinions that such interpretations would leave no prophecy of any Prophet intact in the world, since everywhere the door remains open to the whim that it was a coincidental occurrence. Hence, if this opinion is indeed true, they must concede that there is no evidence whatsoever for the Prophethood of any Prophet, and that all such events are mere coincidences.

The Torah and the Holy Qur’an have established prophecy alone as the primary evidence of Prophethood. A mischievous individual can very easily dismiss any true prophecy as a mere coincidence. However, I emphatically affirm that all these doubts are akin to those harboured by an atheist who, by deeming all these created objects as a meaningless series of events, casts doubts upon the existence of Allah the Almighty and dismisses the entire system of the universe as a coincidental occurrence. Later, when the realization dawns upon him and he is encompassed by the grace of God, and he contemplates the quintessential and impregnable design of this universe, attaining insights of the intricacies of Divine creation and His penetrating wisdom, he is compelled to abandon his former opinion. Thus, one should certainly understand that these objections are also of the same nature, and these objections continue to arise in the heart only so long as one fails to observe the subtle aspects of a prophecy and one deems the Divine management of Allah the Almighty to be imperfect.

The truth of the matter is that such doubts always arise in the minds of those whose hearts are deprived of the true cognizance of God. Astonished by God’s works, they tend to incline towards denial and interpret events in accordance with the perspective to which their own crude and superficial thoughts are limited, and they go on emphasising these. I ask them, if Lekh Ram died by means of murder on a coincidental basis, then on that same basis it was also possible for a coincidental event to occur whereby no one intended to kill him, or—if someone did—he would have failed in his intention. Or, if he made any attempt, it was possible that it would not reach the point of death. Then what is the reason why all the possible coincidences of the other aspects did not come into being, but this coincidence, which is possessed of its own inherent challenges in relation to the other aspects, came to pass? Did God do this or someone else? Hence, that All-Knowing and All-Hearing God to Whose justice both parties had submitted this case, and regarding Whom one party had even announced that He revealed to me that He would do just that—why should it be assumed about Him that He did not give a just verdict? And why should it be considered that He espoused the cause of a liar?

If it is accepted that it is also the practice of God that He fulfils even the prophecies of such a liar who presents those prophecies as proof of his truthfulness, then it is as if the deliberate plan of God—by equating liars with the truthful—is to obliterate and overturn the entire foundation of truth. If it is true that God is the Defender of the truthful, fulfilling His promises and not the fabrications, then it is incumbent upon an unbiased individual to accept the fundamental rule that if any prophecy is made in the name of God and it comes true, it is indeed from God. And if this principle is not accepted, then all the Books of God will be left without proof, and the paths of believing in their truth will be closed. It is towards this indeed that Allah the Almighty alludes and says:

Meaning that, this is the sign of a truthful person that some of his prophecies are fulfilled. The condition of ‘some’ is added because in the prophecies of warning, the delaying or averting of punishment is permissible in the state of taubah [repentance] and turning back to God, even if no condition is stipulated. Thus, it is possible that some prophecies of punishment may be postponed and not be fulfilled within their appointed time, as happened for the people of Jonah. In short, to doubt a prophecy made in the name of God that is fulfilled and to dismiss it as coincidence is—so to speak—an attack against the religious institution of God Almighty and a resolve to demolish the entire edifice of Prophethood.

10 von 10 heute frei