Final Letter
A Verdict Required
Thus, since he was absolutely ignorant and did not even have the ability to present a sruti from the Vedas relevant to every point, he cunningly avoided mentioning my original demand in his writings. For shame—mocking and taunting—he would constantly pester me for a Heavenly Sign. In short, I reproduce here my final letter, which was written in response to his last note, and it is as follows:
Dear Pandit Sahib, I have read your letter. Understand it with full certainty that I neither refuse debating nor manifesting a Sign. Nonetheless, you do not seek the truth with sincerity of intention, needlessly imposing absurd conditions. Your tongue does not desist from filthy language.
You write that if I do not wish to debate, then ask the Lord of the Throne, Khairul-Mākirīn [the Best of Planners] for a Heavenly Sign regarding me. How very mocking and taunting these words are, as if you do not believe in the God Who can punish the brazenly reckless! As for your insinuation that God is upon the Throne and engages in makr, this is your own lack of understanding. Makr refers to subtle and hidden
planning, which is not inappropriate to attribute to God. And the word ‘Arsh [Throne] is used to denote the grandeur of God Almighty, for He is loftier than all those who are lofty and possesses majesty. It does not mean that, like a human being, He is in need of a raised platform to serve as a throne. The Holy Qur’an itself states that He sustains everything but He is Qayyum [Self-Subsisting and All- Sustaining], Who requires no support from anything. Thus, when the Holy Qur’an affirms this, how unjust it is to raise an objection against the ‘Arsh!
You are wanting in Arabic and you do not even know the meaning of makr. There is nothing improper in the concept of makr that precludes it from being ascribed to Allah the Exalted. Those subtle and hidden works of Allah for the purpose of punishing the wicked are called makr. Look at a dictionary and then raise your objection. If, as you say, I am ignorant of the Vedas, what harm is there in that insofar as I debate holding fast to your accepted principles? You, however, transgress way beyond the principles of Islam, perpetrating blatant slander.
First, you should have asked me the context in which it is believed that God exists on the ‘Arsh, and then—if there was room for it—you should have raised the objection. Likewise, you should have first asked about the meaning of makr and then raised an objection. As for Signs, they are with the Lord. He is the Omnipotent Who may show them to you.
وَٱلسَّلَٰمُ عَلَىٰ مَنِ ٱتَّبَعَ ٱلۡهُدَىٰٓ
[And peace be on those who follow the guidance].
The humble one, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad