Sahih Muslim 4371: Excellent Qualities
It is narrated from Hazrat Sa'id bin Jubair (ra): I said to Hazrat Ibn Abbas (ra): Nauf Bikali claims that Moses (as) of the Children of Israel is not the Moses of Khidr. At this Hazrat Ibn Abbas (ra) said: The enemy of Allah is wrong. I heard Hazrat Ubayy bin Ka'b (ra) say: I heard the Messenger of Allah (saw) say: “Moses (as) stood up to address the Children of Israel, and he was asked: ‘Who among the people knows the most?’ At this Moses (as) said: ‘I know the most.’” The Messenger of Allah (saw) said: “At this Allah the Exalted reproached him, because he did not say: ‘Allah knows best.’ Then Allah revealed to him: ‘At the place where the two seas meet there is a servant from among My servants who is more learned than you.’ Moses (as) said: ‘O my Lord! How can I reach him?’ Moses (as) was told: ‘Put a fish in a basket; where you lose the fish, there he will be.’ Then he (Moses (as)) set out, and with him set out his servant Joshua bin Nun. Moses (as) carried a fish in a basket, and then Hazrat Moses (as) and his young man both walked on until the two of them came to a rock, and Moses (as) and his young man fell asleep, and the fish began to stir in the basket until it came out of the basket and fell into the sea.” The narrator says: “Allah held back the flow of the water from it until it became like a tunnel, and a path was made for the fish, and Hazrat Moses (as) and his young man marvelled. Then the two of them kept walking for the rest of their day and the night as well, and the companion of Moses (as) forgot to tell him. Then when Moses (as) rose in the morning, he said to his young man: ‘Bring us our morning meal. Surely, we have suffered much fatigue on account of this journey of ours.’ (Qur’an 18:63).” He (saw) said: “Moses (as) did not feel fatigue until he had passed beyond the place to which he had been commanded to go. He said: ‘Didst thou see, when we betook ourselves to the rock for rest, and I forgot the fish— and none but Satan caused me to forget to mention it to thee—it took its way into the sea in a marvellous manner?’ (Qur’an 18:64). He said: ‘That is what we have been seeking.’ So they both returned, retracing their footsteps (Qur’an 18:65).” The narrator says: “The two of them kept following their footsteps until they came to that rock, and they saw a man wrapped in a cloth. Moses (as) greeted him, and Khidr said to him: ‘Where is (the greeting of) peace in your land?’ He said: ‘I am Moses.’ He asked: ‘Moses of the Children of Israel?’ He said: ‘Yes.’ He said: ‘You have knowledge from Allah which Allah has taught you and which I do not know, and I have knowledge from Allah which He has taught me and which you do not know.’ Moses (as) said to him: ‘May I follow thee on condition that thou teach me of the guidance which thou hast been taught?’ (Qur’an 18:67). He said: ‘Thou canst not keep company with me in patience. And how canst thou be patient about things the knowledge of which thou comprehendest not?’ (Qur’an 18:68-69). He said: ‘Thou wilt find me, if Allah please, patient and I shall not disobey any command of thine.’ (Qur’an 18:70). He said: ‘Well, if thou wouldst follow me, then ask me no questions about anything till I myself speak to thee concerning it.’ (Qur’an 18:71). He said: ‘Yes.’ Then Hazrat Khidr (as) and Moses (as) both set off along the shore of the sea. Meanwhile a boat passed by them, and the two of them spoke to them to take them on board. They recognised Khidr and took both of them on board without any fare. Then Khidr (as) pulled out one of the planks of that boat. Hazrat Moses (as) said to him: ‘These are people who took us on board without fare.’ ‘Hast thou staved it in to drown those who are in it? Surely, thou hast done an evil thing.’ (Qur’an 18:72). He said: ‘Did I not tell thee that thou wouldst not be able to keep company with me in patience?’ (Qur’an 18:73). He said: ‘Take me not to task at my forgetting and be not hard on me for this lapse of mine.’ (Qur’an 18:74). Then the two of them came out of the boat, and while they were walking on the shore, what do they see but a boy playing with other boys. Khidr took him by the head, pulled it up with his hand and killed him. At this Moses (as) said: ‘Hast thou slain an innocent person without his having slain any one? Surely, thou hast done a hideous thing!’ (Qur’an 18:75). He said: ‘Did I not tell thee that thou wouldst not be able to keep company with me in patience?’ (Qur’an 18:76). This was harder than the first. He said: ‘If I ask thee concerning anything after this, keep me not in thy company, for then thou shalt have got sufficient excuse from me.’ (Qur’an 18:77). So they went on till, when they came to the people of a town, they asked its people for food, but they refused to make them their guests. And they found therein a wall which was about to fall, and he repaired it (Qur’an 18:78).” (He was saying that it was leaning.) “Khidr gestured with his hand and set it straight. Moses (as) said to him: ‘These are people to whom we came, but they did not show us hospitality and did not give us food.’ ‘If thou hadst desired, thou couldst have taken payment for it.’ (Qur’an 18:78). He said: ‘This is the parting of ways between me and thee. I will now tell thee the meaning of that which thou wast not able to bear with patience.’ (Qur’an 18:79).” The Messenger of Allah (saw) said: “May Allah have mercy on Moses (as). Would that he had been patient, so that the account of the two of them would have been related to us.” The narrator says: The Messenger of Allah (saw) said: “The first time it was forgetfulness on the part of Moses (as).” He (saw) said: “A sparrow came and sat on the edge of that boat, then it pecked in the sea. Khidr (as) said to him: ‘My knowledge and your knowledge have not diminished the knowledge of Allah even as much as this sparrow has diminished of the sea.’” Sa'id bin Jubair said: He (Ibn Abbas (ra)) used to recite: “wa kana amamahum malikun ya'khudhu kulla safinatin salihatin ghasba”, and (the other verse) he used to recite thus: “wa ammal-ghulamu fa-kana kafiran”.
AI-translated by Islam-Today