8. (انگریزی میں) ایک اسلامیات کی نشست میں ہم حضرت عیسیٰ علیہ السلام کی وفات پر بات کر رہے تھے۔ میں نے حاضرین کو بتایا کہ لفظ ’رفع‘، جو ان کے لیے استعمال ہوا، قرآن کریم میں بہت سے دوسرے لوگوں کے لیے بھی استعمال ہوا ہے، مثلاً سیدنا ادریس کے لیے۔ اس لیے اگر ہم کہیں کہ وہ زندہ نہیں ہیں تو میرے خیال میں ہم درست ہیں؛ لیکن لوگوں کی تشریح کے مطابق وہ اٹھا لیے گئے اور چھٹے آسمان پر کہیں زندہ ہیں۔ یہ ایک بحث تھی، اور میں وضاحت چاہتا ہوں کہ میں درست تھا یا وہ۔ مجھے بتایا گیا کہ اگر وہ مان لیں کہ مسیح زندہ نہیں ہیں تو اسلام کے بارے میں ان کا اپنا عقیدہ بالکل متزلزل ہو جائے گا، جیسا کہ دوسرے مسلمانوں کا؛ اسی لیے وہ میری بات ماننے سے ڈرتے ہیں۔

اردو مجلسِ عرفان، 8 فروری 1987

Automatic transcript of an audio recording, corrected with AI

can you understand him do well? I can you can? yes please so you are listening to the organization then? is that right? yes please will you ask the question in English? yes i will appreciate it because that will be the answer that will be precise for me sir i will give you the direct answer question i want to get across this i will tell you in an islamic study meeting and then we were discussing about the death of jesus christ and i told them in the audience that Christ then if the word rafad which was used for him it was used for many other people in the Holy Qur’an it was also used for saydna idris so if we say therefore that he is not alive well i think we can't be right but the interpretation of so i was trying to tell you the interpretation of the people they said he was sticking up and so he is living somewhere in the sixth heavens how about that you are? well it was an argument but I want to be clarified whether I was right or whether they were wrong and because he told me that if they are upset that Christ is normal living it means their own belief about Islam is completely shaken as with their own other Muslims so that is why they are afraid to accept my yes you are quite right but let me further explain and develop the same argument which you have been already the word tavafad is never used in the sense has never been used nor shall it ever be used by the Arabic knowing people how could God make such a blunder that he should use the same word in application to jesus christ and mean instead of death he should mean there abode the ascension that is a very clear cut argument based on the Arabic usage of the words well supported by the most authentic wherever you read this word tavafahum if God is the subject and the man or living being is the object then invariably all the Arabic dictionaries would translate it as God called him to die God called him to die never once will you ever come across any dictionary which would translate it in the sense that God called him to be ascended to heaven called him to be raised bodily now the same person about whom the holy quran says that God called him to die or promised him that he would cause him to die has been referred to with another word by rafa allahu alai that word is explained by the word tavafah the meaning of rafa here is can be well understood and the best understood I should say under the influence of the word tavafah that clarifies the word rafa so the non-amini muslims instead of concentrating on the word tavafah which they know is not helpful to them at all it was trying to tell this point they are the people who talk about tavafah that's right but it never means raising somebody body body in you what they present instead is not the word tavafah but the word rafa and they claim that the holy quran has said bal rafa guzullahu ilaihi but God according to them called raised him to the heaven bodily spirited all this is the translation which they make and they insist that all right if tavafah means death rafa means raising of somebody body body this is what is to be debated first otherwise this debate will continue if you don't bring this into focus this word I would like to read that you know what I will explain I will explain further first of all as I said there is no contradiction in the holy quran so if in any other place the holy quran has categorically declared that jesus christ peace be upon him to be dead then in no other place can holy quran the same holy quran claim him to be alive or to be have ascended to have ascended heaven bodily to heaven and to be still alive otherwise there will be contradiction in the holy quran so all this debate should be carried out in the light of all that has been said about jesus christ in the holy quran and with this one positive agreement between amethyst and non-amethyst that no meaning would be attributed to any word of the holy quran which results in a belief in contradiction in the holy quran because that will be an allegation against the holy quran in its authenticity

آج 10 میں سے 10 باقی