The Answers

Three Questions by a Christian and their Answers, Part 2

Then, in Surah Al-Najm, God says:

That is: The heart of the Holy Prophet (sa) never denied the heavenly signs of his truthfulness that he saw, which means that he was never in doubt about them. The eye wandered not to the right, nor to the left, nor did it transgress the limit, rather it settled right on the truth and stuck to it. Surely, he saw the greatest of the signs of his Lord. O readers, and lovers of the truth! Consider with justice and fairness, how expressly God Almighty has informed us that the Holy Prophet (sa) possessed perfect insight and full conviction, and his Prophethood was true, and great signs were shown in his support.

In short, there is not a word, not a jot, in the Holy Qur’an, which even remotely suggests that the Holy Prophet (sa) was ever in doubt about being a Prophet, and about the Holy Qur’an being the Divine word. The truth is that the perfect certainty, insight and conviction, to which the Holy Prophet (sa) laid claim, and then proved, finds no parallel in any existing Scripture.

Let it be noted that the Gospels attribute to Jesus (as) words which imply that, in his last days, he had begun to doubt whether he was really a Prophet and whether he enjoyed Divine support. For instance, right on the eve of his departure from this world—a time for the men of God to manifest their conviction and the blessings of their faith—Jesus uttered the words 'Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani?', which means, 'O my God, O my God, why hast Thou forsaken me?' What is more, it was also his wont to run away from places where he apprehended the mischief of his opponents, despite the fact that God had already given him assurances of security. Both these circumstances betray doubt and bewilderment. And when we see him crying and supplicating through the night for the tragedy—of which he had prior knowledge—to be averted, we realize that he was in doubt about everything.

We have set out these illustrations only to point out the folly of the Christians, who have raised these objections against the Holy Prophet (sa). Otherwise, we are quite capable of answering these questions, and vindicating our dear Messiah—who was not above human weaknesses and frailties—of all such allegations, by simply negating his divinity and 'sonship'. But it will be an arduous task indeed for our Christian brothers to do so.

Let it be clear that the two verses quoted by the critic to prove that no miracle was shown by the Holy Prophet (sa), do not at all support such an inference. On the contrary, the verses prove that the Holy Prophet (sa) performed all the miracles which a true and perfect Prophet should be able to perform. The point is elaborated below.

The first verse, which the critic quotes out of context, is reproduced here in full, along with adjacent verses, to make the meaning clear:

That is: They say, 'Why are not signs such as those (which you ask for, i.e., signs of chastisement) sent down to him?' Say, 'The signs are with Allah and within His power and I am only a Warner', i.e., my duty is simply to warn you of the Day of Punishment, and I do not bring it down on my own. Allah further says: Is this sign of mercy not enough for them, (who want to have the sign of chastisement inflicted on them), that We have sent down to thee (O Unlettered Prophet (sa)), the Book (comprising all perfections), which is recited to them? i.e., the Holy Qur’an—which is a sign of mercy—serves the same purpose which the unbelievers want to achieve through the signs of chastisement. The purpose of the unbelievers of Mecca in demanding a sign of chastisement was that it should bring them the conviction which mere seeing could not do, for they feared that mere seeing might delude them and they may suffer from optical illusions. To remove this suspicion and misgiving, Allah says: You want a sign that should bring conviction to you. Why then ask for a sign of punishment? Is not the sign of mercy—the Holy Qur’an—sufficient for this purpose, whose bright and refulgent rays dazzle your eyes, and which reveals to you its inherent excellences, its verities and its miraculous qualities, the like of which you can never produce. The Holy Qur’an is already exerting its miracu- lous influence on you and your people. It is descending

That is: The Holy Qur’an guides to the path of peace and leads people out of every darkness into light. It is a cure for whatever disease there is in the hearts. Allah has sent down water which has quickened the earth after its death. He has sent down water so that every valley may flow according to its measure. He sends down water and the barren earth becomes green. The skins of those who fear their Lord creep at it, then their skins and their hearts soften to the remembrance of Allah. Remember, it is in the Holy Qur’an that hearts can find true comfort. Faith is inscribed in the hearts of those who follow the Holy Qur’an, and they are blessed with the Holy Spirit. The Holy Spirit has brought down the Holy Qur’an, so that it may strengthen the hearts of the believers, and be a sign of guidance and glad-tidings for Muslims. It is We Who have sent down the Holy Qur’an, and it is We Who shall surely be its Guardian, i.e., the Holy Qur’an will remain forever pristine, both in respect of its form and upon hearts and bringing about a wonderful transformation. It is restoring life to those who have long been dead, and restoring vision to those who have been blind through generations. The Holy Qur’an is curing a variety of diseases associated with disbelief and heresy. Lepers of acute prejudice are being washed clean of their prejudices. The Holy Qur’an gives light and drives away darkness. It brings about union with God and produces signs indicative of this union. Why turn away from this sign of mercy which bestows everlasting life, and ask instead for a sign of death and destruction? Allah goes on to say that the unbelievers seem to want only the signs of chastisement and want them soon, and do not have any desire to witness the signs of mercy. The Holy Prophet (sa) is asked to tell them that had it not been for the fact that signs of chastisement come at their own appointed time, they would surely have tasted Divine chastisement long ago. Punishment shall come, and it shall come unawares.

Come and judge, do you find in these verses any denial of miracles? On the contrary, the verses proclaim that, since characteristics, and it shall remain under the shelter of Divine protection. Allah further says that the Holy Qur’an contains all the knowledge, wisdom and truth that is to be found in Divine scriptures. And no man or jinn will be able to produce the like of it, even though they should help one another.* [Author]

the unbelievers demanded signs of death and destruction, they were first of all told that they have in their midst the Holy Qur’an, which is a life-giving sign, and which has been sent, not to destroy them, but to grant them everlasting life. And if a sign of punishment were to come, it would surely destroy them. Why then do you wish to die? If you want nothing but chastisement, then you will surely have what you ask for, and you shall have it very soon.

Thus, in these verses, God promises a sign of chastisement, and, at the same time, draws attention to the signs of Divine mercy inherent in the Holy Qur’an, which bring about a miraculous change in people’s hearts. The critic’s assumption that this verse implies a negation of all miracles, without any exception, only betrays his ignorance of the rules of Arabic grammar. It should be remembered that the scope of negation is always limited to the intent of the speaker, whether indicated in words or by implication. If someone says, 'Cold weather has passed', it is obvious that this statement reflects the condition of the speaker’s own town, although he may not even have mentioned it by name. Who would ever think that such a statement could apply to all the cold countries, and that warm sunshine had replaced cold weather everywhere. It would obviously be wrong to argue that since this negation pertains to a class as a whole, it, therefore, applies to the whole world?

It is well known that the vanquished idolaters of Mecca finally believed in the Prophethood of the Holy Prophet (sa) and accepted his miracles as true miracles. And even as unbeliev- ers, they did not deny his miracles outright. On the contrary, they were so bewildered by what they saw, that when they went to the Byzantine and Persian Empires they proclaimed that the Holy Prophet (sa) was a man with magical powers. Thus they admitted the signs, albeit in their own way, and these affirmations are to be found in the Holy Qur’an. They could not possibly have denied these manifest signs of the Holy Prophet’s (sa) Prophethood with such conviction, while they were so overawed by them. If they had indeed denied these miracles so forcefully, how could they have accepted Islam with such conviction that it became a small matter for them to shed their blood and sacrifice their lives for its sake. The assertion they frequently made during the time of their disbelief, and which is recorded in the Holy Qur’an, was that—owing to their lack of insight—they considered the Holy Prophet (sa) to be a magician. Allah says:

That is: And when they see a sign, they turn away and say that this is a feat of magic.

He again says:

That is: They wondered that a warner had come to them from among themselves, and the unbelievers said that he is a magician and a great liar. Since the unbelievers called the Holy Prophet (sa) a magician, and later accepted the same signs as miracles, and the whole of the Arabian Peninsula accepted Islam and became forever a witness to the miracles of the Holy Prophet (sa) , it is, therefore, wrong to say that these people could have denied the miracles in such a categorical manner even though it went against their common perception.

·

10 of 10 left today