The Answers

Three Questions by a Christian and their Answers, Part 3

On the other hand, the context makes it as clear as day that wherever the Holy Qur’an mentions the objection of the unbelievers that no signs have been given to the Holy Prophet (sa), it also clarifies that these people are only speaking of the signs of their own asking.

In short, the critic has drawn a far-fetched conclusion from the negation [of miracles] mentioned in the above verse, and has gone far beyond the bounds of the text. The Arab contemporaries of the Holy Prophet (sa) could never have dreamed of drawing such a conclusion, for, in their heart of hearts, they were fully convinced of the truth of Islam. That

earth and we see you climb the ladder to heaven before our very eyes. And we shall not accept even this sign, unless you come back with a book which we can read and hold in our hands.' They also demanded that the Holy Prophet (sa) should make canals of water to flow in Mecca, which was always short of water, just as they flowed in Iraq and Syria; or that all their ancestors who had died since the beginning of the world should come back alive, including Qusayy bin Kilab, for that old man always spoke the truth, and they wanted to ask him whether the Holy Prophet’s claim was true or not. They sought all these self-conceived signs, which they made even more complicated by piling up conditions that have been mentioned at several places in the Holy Qur’an. To a discerning mind, such demands provide a clear proof of the manifest miracles, evident signs and Prophetic visage of our lord and master, the Holy Prophet (sa). Only God knows how disconcerted were the spiritually blind unbelievers by the light of the truth of the Holy Prophet (sa), and what wonderful heavenly blessings and heavenly support was being showered on him which so overawed and bewildered them, and they tried to escape with such unreasonable demands. The showing of such miracles would fall outside the scope of 'belief in the unseen'. God, obviously, has the power to place a ladder to the heaven which all people could see; and He could restore to life, not just thousands, but millions of the dead, and could make them bear witness to the truth of the Holy Prophet (sa) in the presence of their progeny; God could do all this, but, if you think about it, such a full disclosure would have left no room for 'belief in the unseen'—on which depends all merit and reward—and the world would become a picture of Doomsday. Just as it shall be of no avail to believe when the Day of Judgement has arrived—for it will be is why they all eventually accepted Islam, barring a few who met their punishment as had been promised. Remember, that similar negations are to be found in the words of Jesus (as) as well. The Pharisees demanded signs, but Jesus (as) said regretfully: "Why doth this generation seek after a sign? Verily, I say unto you, There shall no sign be given unto this generation." (Mark, 8:11)

Just note how clearly Jesus (as) refuses to show miracles. If the critic would only ponder over this, he would find that his objection is nothing as compared to this objection. This is because the critic has only cited a denial of miracles by the unbelievers. And it is not a general denial, but a denial of some specific signs. And a denial by opponents can obviously not be credible, for they are likely to say things contrary to the facts. But here Jesus (as) himself refuses to show miracles to his people. He says, "There shall no sign be given unto this generation." There could not be a more emphatic refusal to show miracles, nor could there be a negation more general in intent.

The critic then goes on to object to another verse, which he has, again, taken out of context. If it had been taken in its context, it would become clear to all fair-minded observers that it does not contain even a word which suggests a denial of miracles. Rather, the words make it amply clear that miracles had certainly been shown. The verse in question and the accompanying verses, read as follows:

The Glorious God says: Although We shall destroy every township before the Day of Resurrection, or shall punish it with a severe punishment, and this is what has been written down in the Book, We do not send afresh some of those past signs of chastisement (that have already descended as punishment upon people of the past), which were rejected by them. Thus We gave Thamud the she-camel, a clear sign, (as a fore-warner of the impending punishment, but they rejected it unjustly, and the she-camel caused the ponds of water to dry up for the people of Thamud, residents of the town of Hijr, and spared no grazing ground for their animals. They were thus caught in great suffering and distress because it ate and drank in plenty.) And We send not signs of punishment but as a warning, i.e., signs of punishment are sent so that people may be fearful. Why then go on demand- ing signs which the former peoples saw and which they rejected, and were not at all frightened or deterred by them? Divine signs, let us say, are of two kinds: (1) Signs consisting of warning and punishment, which can also be called signs of Divine wrath. (2) Signs of glad-tidings or peace, also known as signs of Divine mercy. Signs of warning are shown to people who are hard-hearted, disobedient, faithless and of Pharaonic dispositions, so that they may take heed and their hearts may become overawed by the Might and Majesty of God. Signs of glad-tidings are meant for seekers after truth, sincere believers, lovers of guidance, and meek and humble people, who think lowly of themselves and seek to strengthen their faith. These signs are not meant as warnings. Their purpose is to bring comfort to God’s loyal servants, to deepen their faith and conviction, and to lay the hand of His grace and mercy on their troubled hearts. The believers, therefore, always continue to receive such signs through the Holy Qur’an and keep advancing in faith and conviction.

Signs of Divine mercy bring peace and solace to the believers, dispel the anxiety which man is naturally prone to and bring tranquillity to his heart. As a reward for following the Book of God, he receives signs of glad-tidings throughout his life. Signs of peace and comfort keep descending upon him, so that he continues to advance in certainty and knowledge and reaches the stage of Haq-ul-Yaqin. Another blessing of these signs of glad-tidings is that, while they help a believer to advance in certainty and Divine knowledge and spiritual power, he also advances in his love for God, for he experiences His favours and His physical and spiritual bounties—both visible and hidden—with which the signs of gladtidings abound.

Hence signs of glad-tidings are truly glorious and powerful and blessed signs, leading men to their goal and carrying the seeker to the stage of perfect cognition and personal love for God, which is the ultimate stage for His friends.

Much is contained in the Holy Qur’an about the signs of glad-tidings. It says that these signs are not limited, and makes an eternal promise that the true followers of the Holy Qur’an will always continue to be blessed with such signs. He says:

That is: For the faithful are signs of glad-tidings in the present life and also in the hereafter, which will help them advance to unlimited heights in the field of Divine love and knowledge in both worlds. These are the words of God that can never fail. To be blessed with signs of glad-tiding is the ultimate triumph. (This is what leads a person to the pinnacle of Divine love and knowledge).

Let it be known that the verse which the critic has quoted in support of his objection is concerned only with signs of warning, as this verse makes clear:

We would be quite mistaken if we were to consider all the signs of God to be the signs of wrath, and were to understand from this verse that He sends every sign for the sole purpose of warning, and for no other reason. As I have already mentioned, signs are sent for two purposes: as warnings and as glad-tidings. The Holy Qur’an, and also the Bible, speak frequently of these two kinds of signs. Therefore, the only logical interpretation of the verse in question is that the signs mentioned in it are only signs of wrath. Otherwise, we will have to admit that all Divine signs are signs of wrath. But this is not at all true, for it can neither be substantiated by the Holy Book, by human reason, nor by the conscience of a pure heart.

It is now clear that, of the two kinds of signs, only the signs of wrath are mentioned in this verse. The question that now remains to be answered relates to the true connotation of the verse Does it mean that God demonstrated no sign of warning at the hand of the Holy Prophet (sa); Or that such signs were not demonstrated by him as had already been shown to earlier people; Or that both were shown by the Holy Prophet (sa), with the exception of the signs of warning which had been shown to earlier people and had been rejected by them, because they did not consider them to be miracles.

·

10 of 10 left today