The Answers
Three Questions by a Christian and their Answers, Part 7
Who will witness the descent of Jesus when mankind shall be lying dead under the debris of thousands of stars? How will the earth itself remain secure and firm in its orbit, when its own survival is dependent upon the gravity of the stars? And who shall be the chosen ones (mentioned in the Gospels) whom Jesus (as) will gather together from the farthest parts of the earth, and whom shall he warn and reprove, while the falling of stars necessitates universal death and destruction, and would, in fact, turn the earth upside down. Just consider, do the above statements not go against the science of astronomy? The New Testament attracts yet another objection from the same point of view: It is written in the Gospel of Matthew, "And lo, the star, which they (the Magi) saw in the East, went before them till it came and stood over where the young child was." (2:9)
Will the Christians kindly tell us, in the light of astronomy, the name of the wonderful star that moved along with the Magi. What kind of movement was it, and to which laws did it conform? I cannot see how the Gospel of Matthew can escape criticism from astronomers. Some Christians get frustrated and respond: "These are not the words of Jesus at all. They are only the words of Matthew, and we do not consider Matthew’s statements to be the revealed word." What an answer! It completely exposes the true nature of the New Testament as a revealed book! Even if we accept, for the sake of argument, that these are not the words of Jesus (as), and are in fact the words of Matthew or someone else, Jesus’ own statement (which is believed to be the revealed word and regarding which I have just raised an objection) is of a similar nature and spoken in the same style. Let them at least try to conform his statements the laws of astronomy! And if this statement is not a revealed one, and is only a man-made addition in the New Testament, then why do you claim that each and every statement of the Gospels you possess is the revealed word? Why do you not proclaim, clearly and unambiguously, that, apart from the little that came from Jesus’ own mouth, everything else in the Gospels was written by their compilers according to their own way of thinking and in their own wisdom and understanding, and it cannot be considered free of errors. This concept, as I have learnt from the everyday writings of clergymen, is now being expressed publicly. It is now being commonly admitted that the miracles which the Gospels mention as historical facts, are not the revealed word, but have been written by the compilers of the Gospels in view of their own surmise, hearsay, or whatever they learnt from external sources.
With this admission, the clergymen have sought to deflect much of the criticism that is levied at the Gospels, and they now admit that about nine-tenth of the Gospels is the word of man and only onetenth revelation. One of the many losses they have incurred due to this admission is that they have forfeited the miracles of Jesus (as), and no longer have any evidence to prove them. Although the Gospel writers have recorded Jesus’ miracles as historical facts, his own unsullied account, which is called the 'revealed word', appears not only to be at odds with their account, but presents quite the opposite picture. Jesus (as), in his own statements that are known as 'revealed', has often refused to show any miracles, and clearly refused to show miracles to those who demanded them. Even Herod, when he asked Jesus (as) for a miracle, was not shown any. Many other people also wanted to see his signs and asked him to show them, but he declined and could not do so. So much so, that he prayed to God all night for the sign that he should remain safe from the hands of the Jews, but even this he was not granted, and his prayer went unheard. Then, after he had been put on the cross, the Jews, in all sincerity, said that they would all believe in him if he could only come down alive from the cross, But even this he could not do. It is clear from these instances that, as far as the revealed text of the Gospels goes, Jesus was not a man of miracles. Any statements, which might lead us to think that Jesus (as) showed some miracles, are in fact multi-faceted and admit of more than one interpretation. There is no reason whatsoever to take them literally, or to stretch their meaning so far as to associate them with the miracles related by the writers of the Gospels on their own authority.
There is not a single statement uttered by Jesus (as) himself, which manifestly proves the occurrence and existence of those miracles. On the contrary, his own emphatic statements show that not a single miracle was ever manifested by him.
I cannot understand why Christians do not trust Jesus’ own 'revealed' words. Why do they rely upon other statements and stretch them more than they deserve, when, according to their own admission, they are not revealed, and have been included in the Gospels as historical narratives, and are altogether unconnected with revelation, and are completely at variance with the revealed statements. Hence, when the revealed and un-revealed statements are completely at odds with one another, the only way to resolve the incompatibility is to consider the un-revealed statements to be unreliable and mere exaggerations by the Gospel writers. The fact that they did exaggerate here and there is quite apparent, as we find in the last verse of John, with which the Holy Gospel ends. It reads:
"And there are also many other things which Jesus did, which, if they should be written every one, I suppose that even the world itself could not contain the books that should be written."
Can exaggeration go any further? Is the world, which contains all the wonders of heaven and earth, unable to accommodate a description of what Jesus did during three or so years of his life! Who will give credence to the statements of people who make such exaggerations!
Hindus have written similar books regarding their Avatars. With cunning and deception, they too have built an edifice of lies. They too were influenced by these fabrications, and from one end of the country to the other, their hearts became filled with Ram and Krishna. Books which are replete with fabrications are like tombs that are made to look bright and shiny from outside, but contain nothing within. How is it possible for people to know the truth about these books, while they were born several hundred years later, and made to believe that these books are so holy and pristine as though they have only just descended from heaven. How can they know how these books were compiled? Few are the eyes that can cut through the veils, and fathom the truth, and catch the culprit; and countless are the souls that are liable to fall under the spell of falsehood. This is what has caused a whole world to go astray and many more continue to go the same way. These ignorant people have not considered the important question of evidence or lack of evidence, and have chosen not to be cautious of the natural tendency to contrive and scheme, which has been witnessed in mankind from time immemorial, and have thus allowed themselves to be trapped in this satanic snare. Like an evil alchemist who takes a thousand coins from a simpleton and promises to turn them into gold worth a million or two, these cunning people have deprived the ignorant of their true and pure faith and have assured them of false piety and false blessings which have no practical existence, nor any evidence. In the end, they have made their people worse than themselves, in wickedness, deceit, world-love and pursuit of their baser self. Remember, even a fragment of evidence given by the Holy Qur’an with regard to the miracles and prophecies shown by the Holy Prophet (sa), is a thousand times more substantial than the evidence of a mountain of Gospels regarding the miracles and prophecies of the Messiah (as). Why?
Because, according to the statements of Christian scholars themselves, the Gospels are only the words of the disciples. What is more, the accounts have not even been witnessed by the disciples first hand, nor do they provide any link of how they learnt of these events, nor even do they claim to have personally witnessed them. On the other hand, whatever is written in the Holy Qur’an regarding the miracles of the Holy Prophet (sa), is the testimony of the Holy and Truthful God Himself. Even a single verse would have been enough, but—God be praised—the Holy Qur’an is full of such testimonies. Just think of the difference: there is the testimony of God on the one hand—which admits of no lies—and, on the other, we have uncorroborated tales and testimonies that are replete with exaggerations.
There is nothing strange about these fabrications; such things have happened before and continue to happen to this day. Christians themselves admit that, in their early period, many people wrote books in which they described the astonishing feats of their elders, and ascribed them to God. In due course, it was even claimed that these books were from God.
Now, since it has been the ancient practice of Christians and Jews to indulge in such fabrications, there is no reason why Matthew and the other Gospels should be made an exception of. Much like the accounts of a money-lender, which reveal their hidden secrets through obvious discrepancies and errors, the mischief which the four Gospels ventured to conceal is also revealing itself. It is for this reason that serious misgivings have been born in the minds of discerning people in Europe and America. They would much prefer to
undue eulogy found way into the Gospels. Although the Christians freely admit that the Gospel writers have added these things on their own, I believe that these additions were made gradually. Cunning fabricators, who came later, have had ample opportunity. Whole fabricated books, which found fame as revealed books, were written and circulated by Christians and Jews in the very early days. And by virtue of such forgery, not one, but a number of Gospels gained currency. Christians themselves admit that some Gospels were fabricated after Jesus (as), among which is the Gospel of Barnabas, but this is only what the Christians say. I say that since there are serious differences between those Gospels and the four books of the current New Testament—so much so, that the Gospel of Barnabas denies that Jesus (as) was ever crucified, and is even opposed to the doctrine of the Trinity, and does not recognize the divinity and sonship of Jesus (as), and, in categorical terms, gives the gladtiding of the coming of the Holy Prophet (sa)—why should we accept the Christians’ unsubstantiated claim that only the Gospels to which they have given currency are true, and all those opposed to them are false. Moreover, when forgery has been so widespread among the Christians that some masters of the art wrote complete books on their own and spread them among the people, and did not let any doubt fall upon their integrity, why then should it have been difficult for them to alter and tamper with any other book? Again, when it has been admitted that these Gospels were not written in the time of Jesus (as), and that the four Gospels came into existence some sixty or seventy years—more or less, in view of the diverse narratives—after Jesus’ (as) death, this casts even greater doubt upon them, for, we cannot say with any degree of certainty that the disciples lived that long, or their faculties had remained remain atheists, than to believe in the god presented by the Gospels, who is inconsistent, imperfect and made of flesh and bone.
A learned American friend of mine has informed me through various letters that there is hardly an intellectual in those countries who considers the Christian religion to be unflawed, and who would not be willing to accept Islam. And though the Christians have brought out interpolated and blemished translations of the Holy Qur’an in Europe and America, the light which is inherent in the Holy Qur’an is still casting its influence on pure hearts. There is great enthusiasm among the people of Europe and America, and they have been thrown into confusion by the false doctrines of the New Testament. Some of them have even begun to say that there was no actual person called the Messiah or Jesus, and that he only stands for the Sun, while the twelve disciples stand for the twelve Constellations.