The Answers
Three Questions by a Christian and their Answers, Part 6
It is the practice of the Benevolent One to hear most of the supplications of those who do as He wills, and become solely and wholly His, and are lost in Him, and He also oc- casionally reveals to them knowledge of His past action or future intention. But they can learn nothing without Divine communication. True, they are close to God, but they are not God. They only understand what they are made to understand, they only know what they are told, they only see what they are shown, and they only speak what they are made to speak; they are nothing in themselves. They only speak when the Supreme Power urges them to speak through revelation, and they only see when it makes them see, and they only hear when it speaks to them. Until God reveals to them something of the unseen, they have no inkling of it. The lives of all the Prophets bear testimony to this fact.
Take the example of the Messiah (as), how he acknowledges his own ignorance and says: But of that day and that hour knoweth no man, no, not the angels which are in heaven, neither the Son, but the Father. (Mark 13:32). He again says: I do nothing of myself (I cannot do anything); but as my Father hath taught me, I speak these things. It is not for me to raise anybody to the height of righteousness. Why callest thou me good? There is none good but one, that is, God. (Mark)
In short, no Prophet has ever claimed omnipotence or omniscience. Look at the humble man who is known as the Messiah, and whom ignorant creature-worshippers have taken for God, and see how on every occasion he proved, through his word and deed, that he was but a poor, weak and frail man, possessing no personal good or merit, and in what beautiful words he made his final admission as his life drew to an end. It is written in the Gospels that the Messiah (learning of his imminent arrest) became extremely anxious and grief-stricken, and said to them (his disciples): My soul is exceedingly sorrowful, even unto death: tarry ye here, and watch with me. And he went a little farther, and fell on his face, and prayed, saying, O my Father, if it be possible, let this cup pass from me. And he said: Abba, Father, all things are possible unto thee; take away this cup from me. That is to say, You are All-Powerful and I am only a weak and humble man. Only You can remove this calamity. And he finally gave up his ghost crying Eli, Eli, lama Sabachthani?, which is translated as: "My God, my God, why hast Thou forsaken me?"
Now, although the prayer was not heard—for it was irrevocably destined not be heard, and what power would a poor creature have before the definite will of the Creator!—still, upon the hope that it might be accepted, the Messiah (as) took the admission of his humility and submission to the extreme. If he had indeed known beforehand that his prayer would be rejected and would never be heard, would he have gone on praying all night till dawn? And would he still have fervently employed himself and his disciples in this vain exercise? Here the critic would agree that Jesus (as) was sure that only God knew and he knew not.
Likewise, the reason why so many of Jesus’ (as) prophecies turned out to be false was his ignorance of matters of the unseen, which caused him to misunderstand and misinterpret Divine prophecies.
For instance, he once said: "In the regeneration when the Son of man shall sit in the throne of his glory, ye (O my twelve disciples) also shall sit upon twelve thrones." (See Matthew 20:28) But it is evident from the same Gospel that Judas Iscariot ended up being deprived of the throne. Though he heard the prophecy that he would sit on the throne, this is not what was destined for him. The question is, if Jesus (as) had truly known beforehand that this man was going to become an apostate and that his end was going to be an evil one, why did he make him the false promise that he would sit on a throne? Similarly, Jesus once saw a fig tree from a distance and went to it so that he could eat some figs, but when he found not a single fig on the tree, he became extremely annoyed and cursed the tree in anger, which had no effect on the tree. If he indeed possessed knowledge of the unseen, he would never have gone up to a barren tree to eat its fruit.
On another occasion, when a woman happened to touch his cloak, he looked around and asked who had touched him. Had he possessed even a little knowledge of the unseen, it would not have been a great matter to know who had done it.
On yet another occasion, he prophesied that men of his generation would not pass away without witnessing all that he had promised, (i.e., his second coming, the falling of the stars, etc.) But no stars fell on earth from heaven, nor did Jesus (as) come to sit in judgement over men, even though his own century went by, and eighteen more centuries have gone by since, and even the nineteenth century is coming to an end. These few testimonies—which have been drawn from the four Gospels themselves—are enough to prove that Jesus (as) did not possess any knowledge of the unseen. The same is true of other Hebrew Prophets. No doubt, Jacob (as) was a Prophet, but he remained unaware of what was happening to his son in a wilderness in his own village. Daniel (as) knew nothing of dreams and their interpretations, until God Himself revealed to him the meaning of Nebuchadnezzar’s dream. It becomes clear from this study that when a Prophet professes ignorance of a certain matter, and says that only God knows about it, he is right in saying so. It is in keeping with his dignity as a Prophet, and in it lies his pride of being a humble man of God. This, in fact, further raises his status in the eyes of his Merciful Master, and does not in any way detract from his status as a Prophet. If anyone should want to know what share the Holy Prophet (sa) had of the knowledge of the unseen which is revealed by God, I am prepared to produce strong arguments to prove that the prophecies of the Holy Prophet (sa) are a thousand times greater, both in quantity and quality, than the prophecies of all Prophets of the Old and New Testaments put together. These prophecies have been detailed in the books of Hadith, which have been compiled with great care. The description in the Holy Qur’an of these prophecies, though brief, is quite satisfactory and effective. What is more, Muslims do not live by old tales alone, as do the followers of other religions. In every century, Muslims have told followers of other religions that these blessings are ever-present in Islam, and even today Muslims continue to invite them to come and test this claim before they accept it, but they do not pay heed. God’s argument has been completed against them, for we invite them and they do not come; we show them but they refuse to see; they have completely turned away their eyes and ears from us lest they should hear and see and be guided.
The critic’s second misunderstanding—that the Holy Qur’an has given an inaccurate account of the number of the People of the Cave—is a mere assertion. The critic does not say why this account is wrong and, as against this, what is the correct account. Nor does he advance any arguments so that they may be analyzed and answered to satisfaction. If the critic had any objection to the text in the Holy Qur’an, he ought to have given his reasons, for, it does not behove a seeker after truth to reject something without giving any reason for it. The third misunderstanding which has arisen in the mind of the critic relates to the Holy Qur’an’s account of a king (whose travels have been described in the Holy Qur’an), who, during his travels, came to a place where he saw the Sun setting in a murky pool. Treating the metaphor as a literal expression, the Christian gentleman asks how it could be possible for the Sun, which is so big, to hide in a small marshy pool? This objection is akin to saying, 'The New Testament describes Jesus (as) as the lamb of God. How can this be possible, when a lamb has horns on its head, and wool on its skin, and walks like quadrupeds with its head down, and eats what they eat.' My dear sir, from where and from whom did you learn about the Holy Qur’an claiming that the Sun actually hid in a marshy pool? The Holy Qur’an merely reproduces the perception of the traveller, and says that, to his eyes, the Sun appeared to be setting in a marshy pool. Hence, the description here is of what the man saw, and how he came to a place where the Sun did not appear to be setting behind a hill or a habitation or behind some trees, as is commonly observed, but to be setting into a marshy pool. The meaning is that there were no habitation, no trees and no hills, nor was there any sign of these things as far as the eye could see; there was only a marshy pool into which the Sun seemed to be setting.
Look at the context of the verses carefully, do you find any scholarly research? All you find is the account of a man travelling far and wide, and the purpose of all the description is to show the kind of wilderness in which he found himself. Trying to relate all this to astronomy is simply taking things out of context.
For instance, if someone says that overnight the sky had become so clear and cloudless that the stars seemed to shine like dots, will you start arguing with him and ask how can stars be as small as dots, and will you start quoting from books of astronomy? If you do, you will be acting foolishly, for the speaker never intended his statement as a literal fact, all he was doing was expressing himself in a metaphor, just as all people do. O, you who eat the flesh of Christ and drink his blood during the Holy Communion, are you unaware of the use of metaphors and symbolic expressions? Who does not know that in the language of every country there is a wide room for the use of symbols and metaphors. Divine revelation also makes use of the same metaphors and symbols which common people have innocently adopted in their everyday speech.
It is not the way of Divine revelation to abide by abstruse philosophical terms at every place and occasion. Since the revelation is addressed to the masses, it is important that it should speak in their own idiom and according to their own understanding. There is, no doubt, a time and place for speaking in terms of fact and scientific detail, but it is impossible for a man to simply abandon the use of metaphors and figurative speech when his first and foremost duty is to speak to the common man at his own level, so that they may understand and their hearts may be moved by his words. Admittedly, there is no revealed book which has distanced itself from the use of metaphors and symbols, or has considered this practice to be wrong. Has there ever been such a revealed book? If we reflect, we will find that in our own speech we make use of hundreds of metaphors and idioms everyday, and no one finds fault with them. For instance, when one says, "The first moon is fine as a hair", or, "The stars are like dots", or, "The moon is hiding in a cloud", or, "Though three morning hours have passed, the Sun has risen no higher than a pole", or when we speak of having eaten a plate of pilau or having drunk a glass of sherbat; on hearing all these expressions, no one wonders how the moon of the first night can be as thin as a hair, or how the stars can be as small as dots, or how the moon can hide behind a cloud, or how can the Sun—which is so fast that it covers thousands of miles a day—travel no more than the length of a pole in the span of three hours; nor can eating a plate of pilau or drinking a glass of sherbat, lead anyone to think that the plate and glass have also been swallowed; rather, everyone would understand that only the rice and water contained in them have been consumed.
Even an opponent, if he is wise, will not like anyone to object to things that are so obvious. I have myself heard from some fair-minded Christians that people who raise such objections are either totally ignorant or completely biased. When the same metaphors and idioms have been used in Divine revelation, would it be fair to take them literally and to make them a target of criticism? In such a case, not a single Divine Scripture would escape unscathed. Do not sailors, when travelling in a ship or a steamer, observe, day after day, the spectacle of the Sun rising from water and setting into water? And do they not describe its rising and setting to one another exactly as they see it? If, during such a discussion, one was to start countering them with arguments relating to astronomy and the solar system, he would only be inviting the retort, "You fool, are you the only one who knows of these matters, and do you think we are ignorant?" Though the Christian critic has tried to find fault with the Holy Qur’an, he has ignored the writings of the New Testament, which genuinely attract such criticism. For example, it is written in the Gospels of Matthew and Mark that you will see the Messiah coming to judge mankind when the Sun shall be darkened, and the moon shall not give its light, and the stars shall fall from heaven. Here, the same science of astronomy presents us with the problem of how the stars can fall upon the earth and break into pieces and get lodged in some nook of the earth, and yet mankind should survive and emerge unscathed, regardless of the fact that the falling of even a single star is enough to destroy all its inhabitants. Another point worth considering is how, when the stars have fallen on earth and have wiped out all earthly creatures, will the words of Jesus, 'You shall see the Son of man coming in the clouds of heaven,' come true?