Title Page
Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship, Part 22
The verse mentioned below deals with a completely new aspect of the same aforementioned principles. According to this verse, all matters pertaining to the area of human faith are likewise governed by these principles. Moreover, they are not confined to the faith of humans of any one era; in fact they are related to all humans of every age, individually and collectively. The verse is as follows:
Surely, the Believers, and the Jews, and the Christians and the Sabians⎯whichever party from among these truly believes in Allah and the Last Day and does good deeds⎯shall have their reward with their Lord, and no fear shall come upon them, nor shall they grieve. (Surah al-Baqarah; Ch.2: V.63)
Muslim commentators have presented various interpretations of this verse which mostly show their lack of full comprehension, whereas the non-Muslims
165 === PDF-Seite 198 === Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship— Part II
treat this verse completely out of context and their interpretations are mostly prejudiced and hostile. Some have gone so far in their arrogance as to make it a special target of their negative criticism. They believe that it liberates mankind from the obligation of accepting Islam. According to their interpretation, the only conditions for salvation are that you believe in Allah and the Last Day and that you do good works; it does not matter whether you are a Jew, a Christian or a Sabian—a Sabian is defined as a believer in God who may follow any of the Divine books revealed earlier in any part of the world. In other words they claim that, according to this verse, Islam is not at all essential for the salvation of mankind; whichever faith man chooses to follow will lead him to salvation. They fail to realise that this verse encompasses a wide subject of great depth and universal application. To understand its import, one must study it in the light of other similar verses of the Holy Qur’an and derive an inference which is fully in line with them. In its flexibility this verse is generally applicable to many different situations without creating any internal contradiction. None of its genuine interpretations can ever be found in conflict with each other or even with any other verse related to the same subject. But to understand this point clearly, a more detailed study of this verse is required from different points of view. First, in application to the time span prior to Islam,
166 === PDF-Seite 199 === Freedom of Conscience in Matters of Faith
this verse provides us with an excellent example of how the Holy Qur’an treats every other religion with absolute justice in a manner which is totally unrivalled in any other Scripture. This verse promises people of all ages, prior to the revelation of the Holy Qur’an, that regardless of the religion they subscribed to, or by whatever name it was called, as long as they believed in Allah and the Last Day and performed good deeds as their religion required of them, Allah assures them peace and salvation. He promises that they will fear not, nor will they ever grieve. So far as all earlier faiths are concerned, this verse gives glad tidings of salvation to all people belonging to them, provided they sincerely act upon their teachings and also believe in the inevitability of the Day of Judgement. The second aspect of this verse applies to all those people who, despite living at the same time as the Holy Prophetsa, did not receive the message of Islam. In this respect they are placed in the same category as the people of earlier eras. For them the message becomes: All humans, wherever they reside in the world, should rest assured that as long as the message of Islam has not reached them, or is not conveyed to them in a convincing manner such as leaves no room for rejection, Allah will not deal with them unjustly. They will be judged by the standards of their respective religions. As we find in Surah al-Baqarah:
167 === PDF-Seite 200 === Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship— Part II
… Allah burdens not any soul beyond its capacity… (Surah al-Baqarah; Ch.2: V.287)
i.e. He will safeguard them and judge them by the measure of their own religions. Similarly, a third application of the same verse addresses those people who were contemporaries of the Holy Prophetsa but were adherents of other religions. If they were true to their principles and steadfast in their faith and good works, this verse gives them glad tidings that Allah will not deprive them of their reward. In this respect, we find from the Holy Qur’an that good works are rewarded in two ways; one being here on earth, the other being attained in the life after death. As far as the former category is concerned, it means that as a result of their good works and sincere faith, as soon as the message of Islam reaches these people, they are expected to accept it. Thus in the expression 'Falahum Ajruhum', one meaning of the ajr (reward) is their being led to Islam as a reward for their good deeds. This interpretation is fully supported by the Holy Foundersa of Islam himself. Hadrat Hakim bin Hizamra narrates:
Before accepting Islam I undertook many good works. I served the poor, I fed the hungry and helped the distressed. After accepting Islam, I asked the Holy
168 === PDF-Seite 201 === Freedom of Conscience in Matters of Faith
sa Prophet , 'O Prophet of Allah! What will become of the good deeds I performed before I accepted Islam? sa Will they be rewarded?' Muhammad replied, 'Your Islam is your reward.'13
Having examined one aspect of the principle of Freedom of Consceience, we now turn to another aspect of the same which concerns the prohibition of converting others to a different religion by the application of force. The Holy Qur’an is the one and the only book which upholds complete and unconditional freedom in matters of faith in unequivocal terms. It categorically refutes the age-old allegation, levelled against religion by the non-religious, that all religions promote coercion.
There should be no compulsion in matters of faith. Surely, right has become distinct from wrong; so whosoever refuses to be led by those who transgress, and believes in Allah, has surely grasped a strong handle which knows no breaking. And Allah is All- Hearing, All-Knowing. (Surah al-Baqarah; Ch.2: V.257)
In matters of faith there is no compulsion, every person has complete freedom. No religion is given 169 === PDF-Seite 202 === Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship— Part II
permission to convert anyone forcibly and no person renouncing a religion can be prevented by force. In addition, the proclamation 'La Ikraha Fiddini' alludes to an unalterable principle of human nature, that is, even if force is used it is ineffective in matters of religion because it cannot cause a change in an attitude of mind and heart. To try and do this by compulsion is a futile exercise which achieves nothing but oppression. In this verse, the right to use force is denied to all religions, since the use of the word din is general and is applicable to all religions and not solely to Islam. Apparently, some other religions also disclaim the use of force, but the question is: do their Divine Scriptures present this teaching with such clarity? I believe, that in principle, a similar teaching may be found in all Divine books. Albeit, it may not be so comprehensive, it may be comparatively rudimentary and it may even have been doctored by later followers to suit their own personal objectives, but that is a separate issue. As far as the Holy Qur’an is concerned, it does not stop at stating this basic principle but exonerates all religions from the accusation that they used force to propagate their teachings. It names previous Prophetsas and their teachings and declares them to be the upholders of freedom of conscience. As against them, it is always the opponents of truth who attempt to suppress it with the help of coercion. The same verse speaks of the futility of their exercise. The
170 === PDF-Seite 203 === Freedom of Conscience in Matters of Faith
message is loud and clear that the area of faith lies outside the domain of coercion. With regard to the history of religion as portrayed in the Holy Qur’an, it has been clearly explained that ever since Allah established the institution of Prophethood for the guidance of man, there has ensued a continuous struggle between two diametrically opposed views. On the one hand are God’s Prophets and Messengers who receive guidance through Divine revelation and invite their respective nations towards the same, whilst giving them a free choice to either accept or reject the message. They proclaim that neither do they have the authority to enforce their teachings upon anybody, nor do they believe in doing so. On the other hand, there are their opponents who always, without fail, not only declare their belief in the use of coercion but also in practice use force to prevent others from propagating their faith. They proclaim if you do not desist from attempting to change our religion through arguments, you will be severely punished. And whosoever from among our people discards our own religion to adopt a new one will be treated with such cruelty as will become a warning to all others. Hence, according to the Holy Qur’an, every true Prophet proclaimed freedom of conscience, while every false opponent stood for coercion and force to prevent the spread of truth. Out of many examples, the Holy Qur’an mentions Hadrat Shu‘aibas:
171 === PDF-Seite 204 === Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship— Part II
The chiefs among his people who were arrogant said, 'Assuredly we will drive you out, O Shu‘aib, and the believers that are with you, from our town, or you shall have to return to our religion.' He said: 'Even though we be unwilling?' (Surah al-A‘raf; Ch.7: V.89)
In other words Hadrat Shu‘aibas was told: If you renounce our religion then we will not allow you to remain in our country. On hearing this, he simply said, 'Even though we be unwilling?' This pithy statement of Hadrat Shu‘aibas was the most wise and incisive reply to his opponents’ challenge. It is obvious that if one’s heart becomes averse to a particular religion, then using threats of banishment cannot bring one back into the fold. Threats can at best turn people into hypocrites, but they cannot bring about a change in their inner beliefs. People cannot be forced into a religion. The only way to entice them back (to the old religion) is by removing, through logic and reason, the causes behind their rejection. Physical force does not have the strength to change people’s beliefs. The Holy Qur’an also mentions other Prophetsas who received similar treatment at the hands of their opponents. In each case the basic story is the same.