Title Page
Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship, Part 23
172 === PDF-Seite 205 === Freedom of Conscience in Matters of Faith
Some of the Prophetsas mentioned in this regard include Hadrat Nuh (Noah)as, Hadrat Ibrahim (Abraham)as, Hadrat Lut (Lot)as, Hadrat Hudas and Hadrat Salihas. But this list is far from being exhausted. In fact, while on the subject, the Holy Qur’an refers to all the Prophetsas generally without specifically mentioning their names. It clearly states that no Prophetsas, born at different epochs of history, ever permitted compulsion in matters of faith. In spite of tremendous suffering, all the Prophetsas always held fast to the basic principle of freedom of conscience. If a tyrant ever attempted to coerce others into changing their faith, he found, and will find them always ready to defend their fundamental rights, even at the cost of immense sacrifices. The same goes for the crime of apostacy. The following far-reaching verse in the Holy Qur’an is worthy of note:
And those who disbelieved said to their Messengers, 'We will, surely, expel you from our land unless you return to our religion.' Then their Lord sent unto them the revelation: 'We will, surely, destroy the wrongdoers.' (Surah Ibrahim; Ch.14: V.14)
In addition to banishment from the homeland, other
173 === PDF-Seite 206 === Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship— Part II
severe punishments were meted out to the followers of the new religion for their so-called crime of 'apostacy'. Hadrat Abraham’sas enemies not only proposed the death sentence for this 'crime', but also proposed that the sentence be carried out in a most brutal manner: they decided to burn Hadrat Abrahamas alive. Allah says:
They said, 'Burn him and help your gods, if at all you mean to do anything. (Surah al-Ambiya’; Ch.21: V.69)
Pharaoh devised various tortuous punishments for the people who turned away from his religion. He threatened those who accepted the religion of Mosesas with punishments as follows:
Pharaoh said, 'Do you believe in him before I give you leave? He must be your chief who has taught you magic. I will therefore surely cut off your hands and your feet on alternate sides, and I will surely crucify you on the trunks of palm-trees; and you shall know which of us is severer and more abiding in punishment.' (Surah Ta Ha; Ch.20: V.72)
174 === PDF-Seite 207 === Freedom of Conscience in Matters of Faith
The ideal in the Holy Qur’an of absolute justice applies equally well to every situation. Having demolished the false notion that force is permissible in religious affairs, it absolves all Prophetsas of the allegation that they coerced people into their religion and, in doing so, extends them (the people) the same right of being treated with justice. The most potent argument the Holy Qur’an builds is with respect to God Almighty, the Creator. If He had decided to coerce people to accept the truth, He could easily have done it without creating any fuss regarding the choice between right and wrong. The very existence of right and wrong, and the option given to man to choose between the two, presents incontrovertible proof that coercion is not a part of God’s scheme of things. As God says in the Holy Qur’an:
And if your Lord had enforced His will, surely, all who are on the earth would have believed together. Will you, then, force men to become believers? (Surah Yunus; Ch.10: V.100)
Some Muslim theologians maintain that although no Prophetas before the Holy Prophetsa of Islam was granted coercion in matters of faith, the Holy Prophetsa of Islam was granted this power to prove his
175 === PDF-Seite 208 === Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship— Part II
excellence and superiority over all the other Prophetsas. Evidently this argument is counter- productive. If lesser Prophetsas than he upheld the torch of freedom of conscience, sanity would require that the Holy Prophetsa should have upheld this torch more loftily than any other Prophetas before him. For the very best of Prophetssa to have come to dash the freedom of human choice is a senseless allegation and is extremely blasphemous to the unblemished character of the Holy Prophetsa. This is exactly the power the Holy Qur’an denies the Holy Prophetsa when it declares:
Admonish, therefore, for you are but an admonisher; You are not a warden over them. But whoever turns away and disbelieves, Allah will punish him with the greatest punishment. Unto Us surely is their return, Then surely, it is for Us to call them to account. (Surah al-Ghashiyah; Ch.88: Vs.22-27)
In keeping with this inviolable principle, no Prophetas ever acquired the role of coercing people to righteousness. All who dared to violate this principle in the name of God, or in the name of righteousness, must be rejected as pseudo-gods, who acquired for
176 === PDF-Seite 209 === Freedom of Conscience in Matters of Faith
themselves a role which was never acquired by any humble servant of God. No true religion can be held accountable for the crimes committed in its name against human conscience. Those responsible are the so-called religious priesthood who unjustly distort the Divine teachings only to suit their own purpose at the cost of the purpose of God. They even acquire for themselves the license to kill life which is created by God. It is the Holy Qur’an which comes to the defence of all such religions and exonerates them from the false allegations of their own depraved priesthood of later ages.
177 === PDF-Seite 210 === === PDF-Seite 211 === 11 Islamic Jihad Misunderstood
Having examined the clear and unequivocal Islamic pronouncements as regards freedom of conscience, we must now resolve the apparent conflict between this and the teachings of Islamic Jihad. What kind of justice would it be if, on the one hand freedom of conscience is upheld unconditionally, while on the other, Muslims are required to take up the sword in the name of what they consider to be right, as against the other religions and the peoples of the world? To understand this issue we bring the readers’ attention to the following verse of the Holy Qur’an: