Title Page
Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship, Part 24
Permission to fight is given to those against whom war is made, because they have been wronged⎯and Allah indeed has the power to help them⎯ Those who have been driven out from their homes unjustly only because they said, 'Our Lord is Allah'–– –And if Allah did not repel some men by means of
179 === PDF-Seite 212 === Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship— Part II
others, there would surely have been pulled down cloisters and churches and synagogues and mosques, wherein the name of Allah is oft commemorated. And Allah will surely help one who helps Him. Allah is indeed Powerful, Mighty. (Surah al-Hajj; Ch. 22: Vs. 40-41)
These verses form the cornerstone of the Islamic injunctions regarding Jihad of the sword. It was upon the revelation of these verses that Muslims were allowed to take up the sword for the first time. These verses clearly lay down the necessary pre-conditions under which Muslims are not only permitted but are actually commanded to undertake Jihad of the sword. Even a cursory study of these verses will prove that the sword is only permitted in defence and never as a weapon of offense. Primarily, the word Jihad does not mean an armed struggle. In the verses quoted above, even the defensive struggle is referred to as Qital and not Jihad. Qital is a term applicable to a situation where two parties are locked in battle. Muslims are only permitted to defend themselves with the same weapons which are used against them to suppress their rights of existence. The verses declare them to already be the target of aggression, so much so that they had been turned out of their homes and were long subjected to an offensive warfare, while they had never offered any cause for offence to the enemy, except their claim that God was their
180 === PDF-Seite 213 === Islamic Jihad Misunderstood
Provident. Any sensible man can see that when their right to defend themselves is finally granted, it cannot be dubbed as an aggression on their part. The wisdom in authorising a defensive war does not apply only to the case of Muslims, it is granted to all religions whose message has ever been attempted to be suppressed by sword. It highlights this aspect and categorically declares that this fundamental right is granted to all religions. Hence, had Allah not allowed some people to take up arms in defence of their places of worship, not only the mosques but also the churches and synagogues etc. would have been demolished. In the light of the foregoing verses, one can conclude, without fear of contradiction, that Islam only defends the fundamental human right of freedom of conscience. Call it Jihad or Qital but it cannot be dubbed as an exclusive Muslim right. If any warning is given in this verse, it is given to the Muslims that they would not be granted most favoured treatment by God unless they show respect to the places of other people’s worship. If they do not, they would forego the right for their places of worship to be treated respectfully. They must earn this right by showing the same respect for others. These verses which have just been quoted do not only uphold the value of absolute justice but also enter the realm of Ihsan, which means to go beyond the requirements of justice and to add the grace of
181 === PDF-Seite 214 === Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship— Part II
benevolence in treatment to others. This means that even when worship is carried out in a manner as to cause offence, a true Muslim should not only treat the worshipper with respect, but should also be ready to defend their places of worship when attacked. This aspect is highlighted by the following writing of the Holy Prophetsa of Islam which is still preserved in St. Catherine’s Monastry in Mount Sinai:
It is obligatory upon Muslims to defend Christian churches, monastries and shrines from enemy attacks. Whosoever fails to do so is disobedient to, and transgresses against, the commands of God. And he will give his religion (i.e. Islam) a bad name.14
The Holy Prophetsa requires Muslims to go a step further than Ihsan, and treat other religions with such grace as though they were your own kith and kin. The Prophet Muhammad’ssa love for mankind surpassed the love of a mother for her child. He not only engaged in a great Jihad to uphold the basic human rights of mankind, he went further and showed them more love and mercy than they had earned. Under no circumstances is a Muslim permitted to transgress against others. It is preferable that a guilty man be shown clemency than an innocent man be punished. Amazingly, the Founder of Islamsa even rejected help from a renowned warrior when it was direly needed by Muslims during the Battle of Badr—a time
182 === PDF-Seite 215 === Islamic Jihad Misunderstood
when the Muslims’ strength was at its lowest ebb. According to this incident at that time, one of the most famous infidel warriors expressed the wish to join the side of the Muslims. The Companions were overjoyed at this, but Prophet Muhammadsa rejected the request saying he would not accept help from an infidel in the cause of God. At this rejection the person immediately testified to the Unity of God, evidently because he wanted to join the battle. At this, the Holy Prophetsa accepted his claim without challenging his intention, despite the fact that he (the Holy Prophetsa) was well aware that the man in question only wanted to side with the Muslims to satisfy his personal grudge against the invaders from Mecca. The Prophetsa of Islam accepted him into the fold of Islam because he was evidently motivated by the unshakeable principle that only God knows what passes within a human heart. So he extended him this fundamental right to profess whatever faith he may. The same principle applies to any hypocrite under all circumstances. This is fully elaborated in the opening three verses of Surah al-Munafiqun which run as follows:
183 === PDF-Seite 216 === Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship— Part II
In the name of Allah, the Gracious, the Merciful. When the hypocrites come to you, they say, 'We bear witness that you are indeed the Messenger of Allah.' And Allah knows that you are indeed His Messenger, but Allah bears witness that the hypocrites are surely liars. They have made their oaths a shield; thus they turn men away from the way of Allah. Evil surely is that which they have been doing. (Surah al-Munafiqun; Ch.63, Vs.1-3)
This means that they sought shelter under their profession to fulfil their twofold ill intentions. First, to save themselves from the Muslims while they were in a state of war. Second, under the cover of Islam they could mislead the innocent Muslim common folk while posing to be Muslims themselves. Despite this, the Holy Prophetsa is not permitted to deprive them of their fundemental right to profess with their mouths what did not lie in their hearts, and they are still extended the right to call themselves Muslims. What a paradox we witness today in the various Muslim countries of the world, where coercion in religion is not only preached but is also most tenaciously practised. The mullahs see someone who calls himself a Muslim, who recites the Kalima, who performs prayer like other Muslims and who faces the Holy Kaaba while praying, yet they deny him the right of association with Islam. To them, forcing a person to recant his faith is a service to God, while actually it is tantamount to an open rebellion against
184 === PDF-Seite 217 === Islamic Jihad Misunderstood
the unequivocal teachings of the Holy Qur’an and the noble practice of the Prophet Muhammadsa. Yet what do they care? How will these people face God on the Day of Judgement? They may not care, but God certainly will. To further support this claim we quote the following tradition. Hadrat Usamah bin Zaidra narrates:
The Holy Prophetsa sent us to a battle. On the way we encountered an infidel who would hide himself in the jungle and then whenever he came across a lone Muslim he would attack and kill him. Eventually when he came into my grasp I declared my intention to kill him. In reply he recited the Kalima-e-Tauhid: There is no God but Allah, and Muhammad is His Messenger. In other words he pronounced himself to be a Muslim. However, I rejected his declaration and went ahead and killed him. When I related this story to the Holy Prophetsa he asked in great surprise: 'Did you really kill him, inspite of the fact that he recited the Kalima?' I said, 'Yes, O Prophet of Allah.' The Holy Prophetsa then said, 'How will you fare on the Day of Judgment when the Kalima will stand witness against you?' I repeatedly submitted to the Holy Prophetsa, 'O Prophet of Allah, he only feigned belief out of fear.' Each time the Holy Prophetsa responded by saying, 'Did you open his heart that you know he was lying?' And then he kept saying, 'How are you going to reply to Allah when the Kalima of the deceased stands witness against you?' Hadrat Usama bin Zaidra says, 'I fervently wished that I had not been