Arba’in Number Two
Part 6
So now tell me, after all these texts, what doubt remains concerning the death of Hadrat ‘Isa, peace be on him? And as for my claim, that too is not without supporting evidence. It is clearly written in [Sahih al-]Bukhari and [Sahih] Muslim that the Promised Messiah shall be from among this very Ummah [the followers of the Holy Prophet]. And God made the sun and the moon eclipse for me in the heavens during the month of Ramadan. Similarly, many Signs were displayed on the earth, and the evidence was fulfilled in conformity with the Practice of Allah.
And I swear by that Being in Whose hand my life is, that if, after cleansing your hearts, you wish to see some additional Sign
32259, vol. 11, p. 217, published by Darul-Kutub al-‘Ilmiyyah, Beirut, Lebanon (al-Mu‘jamul-Kabir li’l-Tibrani, Musnad an-Nisa’, Binat Rasulullah Sallallahu ‘alaihi wa Sallam, Dhikru sinni Fatimah radiyallahu ‘anha, wa Wafatiha wa Min Akhbariha wa Kunyatiha, ma rawat ‘A’ishatu Ummul-Mu’minin, ‘an-Fatimah radiyallahu ‘anhuma, vol. 22, p. 417–418, Dar Ahya’ al-Turath al-‘Arabi). [Publisher]
Kutub al-‘Ilmiyyah, Beirut, Lebanon [Publisher]
of God, then know that the Omnipotent Lord has full power to show such a Sign according to His will, without submitting to any of your inappropriate demands. ٭I am certain that if you demand from me to show you a Sign after intending sincere taubah [repentance], and if you make a promise with God that if an extraordinary event occurs which is beyond the capabilities of man, then you will leave aside all malice and enmity, and enter the fold of the Bai‘at only to please God, then Allah the Exalted shall definitely show you some Sign because He is Rahim [Merciful] and Karim [Compassionate]. However, it is not within my power to put a limit of two or three days time for God to show you a Sign, or to follow your wishes. It is in Allah’s authority to set whatever date He likes. If the intent is to find the truth, then there
Mo’azzamah [the Great] and Madinah Munawwarah [the Illuminated]: For thirteen hundred years the means of transportation between Makkah and Madinah were camels. Every year hundreds of thousands of camels travelled to Makkah from Madinah, and from Madinah to Makkah. For these camels, a prophecy that everyone agrees is in the Holy Qur’an and Hadith is that a time is approaching when these camels would be rendered obsolete and no one would ride them. Thus the verse:
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
—[And when the she-camels, ten-month pregnant, are abandoned— (Surah at-Takwir, 81:5)]; and the Hadith: ُ یُتْرَك
الِ الْق [In the time of the Messiah camels will be discarded and no one will travel by them—(Sahih Muslim, Kitabul-‘Iman, Babu Nuzuli ‘Isa ibn Maryam Hakiman bi-Shari‘ati Nabiyyina Muhammad Sallallahu ‘alaihi wa Sallam, Darus-Salam, Published in Riyadh, 2000, Edition 2)] testify to this. So, what a great prophecy this is which was to serve as a sign for the time of the Messiah, and for the appearance of the Promised Messiah that has been fulfilled through the coming of the railway!
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
—[All praise is due to Allah for this]. Author should not be any dispute on this point. Obviously, when God would show a fresh Sign to the people of the present time, He would not assign a long period of fifty or sixty years for it to happen. Reasonably it will be a short time similar to a date fixed for the hearing of court cases or business deals that concerned people mutually accept. Such a resolution can be reached when hearts are totally cleansed of any mischief and you really decide to accept the evidence provided by God. For this method [of resolution] it will be required that at least forty well-known maulawis, like Maulawi Muhammad Husain of Batala, Maulawi Nazir Husain of Delhi, Maulawi ‘Abdul-Jabbar Ghaznavi, later Amritsari, Maulawi Rashid Ahmad Gangohi, and Maulawi Pir Mehr ‘Ali Shah Golarhvi should publish a written statement in a newspaper with signatures of fifty noble Muslims that if such a Sign appears, which is, in fact, extraordinary in nature, then they will cease to oppose me, fearing God Who is the Lord of Glory, and enter into the Bai‘at.
However, if this method is not acceptable to you, and you may be worried that to publish such a promise of making Bai‘at would be below your dignity, or to show such humility is not possible for everyone, then there is another easy way [to settle the matter], and there is no easier way beyond that, in which there is no harm to your dignity nor any fear of a dangerous outcome with loss of life, property, or honour by entering into a mubahalah [prayer duel]. And this is, that, while fearing God and having mercy on the Ummah of Muhammad, you hold a meeting in Batala, Amritsar, or Lahore, and in this meeting gather as many honourable scholars and worldly men as possible, and I will also attend that meeting with the members of my Community. Then, all of you should pray in these words: ‘O our Lord! If You know that this man is a fabricator of lies and is not from You, and he is neither the Promised Messiah nor the Mahdi, then You remove this evil from among the Muslims, and save Islam and the followers of Islam from his mischief as you saved Muslims from the mischief of Musailmah al-Kadhdhab [the Great Liar] and Aswad ‘Ansi by removing them from this world. And if he is from You, and the fault lies in our own understanding and perception, then—O All-Powerful God!—confer upon us the realization so that we be spared destruction. And manifest such matters and Signs in his support that we may feel satisfied that he is from You.’ When this entire supplication has taken place, then I and my Community will say out loud Amin and then after that, I will pray and at that time I will have all these revelations in my hand that have just been written down, and the other revelations also that I am going to write down below.
In other words, this printed treatise in which all the revelations are written will be in my hand. The contents of my prayer will be this: ‘O my Lord! The revelations that are in this treatise which I hold in my hand, according to which I consider myself to be the Promised Messiah and the Promised Mahdi, and declare that Hadrat ‘Isa is dead, if these are not Your words and I am a liar, a fabricator, and a dajjal in Your sight, who has created mischief among the Ummat-e-Muhammadiyah [the followers of the Muhammad s (as)] and Your wrath is on me, then I most humbly supplicate at Your threshold that within one year from today, cut off my name from among the living, and completely disrupt all my work, and erase all trace of my being in the world. But if I am from You, and the revelations that I am presently holding in my hand are from You, and I am a recipient of Your grace, then—O All- Powerful and Noble God!—grant my Community extraordinary progress and extraordinary blessings in the coming year! And bless my lifespan and send down heavenly assistance!’ And when this supplication has taken place, then all the opponents that are present should say Amin! ٭
It will be appropriate that all people come for this prayer with cleansed hearts, without any personal enmity and fervour. They should not consider it a matter of winning and losing, nor should they call it a mubahalah [prayer duel] as the entire gain or loss of this prayer is limited to me alone with no effect on the opponents.
O elders! Obviously, disunity has intensified a lot, and due to this discord and your accusation and rejection, Islam is getting weak. Now that the membership of this Community has reached into the thousands, and every one of my followers has been denounced as a disbeliever, the extent of discord is obvious. At such a time, the love of Islam demands—just as we go into the wilderness for Salatul-Istisqa’ [Prayer for Rain] in full humility—similarly, in this gathering we should adopt humility, and try to make earnest and heartfelt prayers with fervent tears in our eyes. Allah accepts the prayers of His sincere servants. Hence, if this mission is not from Him, and is a man-made operation and pretension, then the prayer of people under God’s mercy shall reach
His Throne promptly. And if my Movement is heavenly and set up by God’s hand, then my prayer will be heard.
Therefore—O elders!—for God’s sake do accept this proposal. There is no need for a big crowd; let forty gather from amongst the scholars—it should not be less than that. The figure of forty has a great blessed effect on acceptance of prayer. As for worldly people, they may join in any numbers. The prayer should be made whilst weeping with complete humility. Though everyone will have to go through travelling inconvenience and some expenses will also be incurred, there is great hope that God will grant His verdict.
O elders, leaders, and scholars of the nation! Once again I implore you in the name of God that you must accept this request of mine! Indeed, it is also worth mentioning that traveling in the rainy season or in summer is not without difficulty, and seasonal illnesses are also there; therefore, for this gathering 15 October 1900 will be appropriate. By then the weather will be good. Moreover, there is nothing wrong if out of our opponents, Pir Mehr Ali Shah Golarhvi, or Muhammad Husain Batalavi, or Maulawi Abdul Jabbar Ghaznavi may become the presiding officer or secretary for the planning of this meeting. After mutual consultation they should publish the acceptance announcement of this proposal. For God’s sake, do not add any other condition now to this announcement.
I have submitted this proposal only for the sake of God, and God is my Witness that I have presented this proposal only to express the truth, with no element of any mubahalah in it. Whatever there is, it only concerns my life and honour. For God’s sake, please, do accept my proposal. Look how much pain the religious scholars go to in opposing me! Many a time they criticise me for things while those very things were done by the Prophets as well. Some Prophets used to do manual work and some were in the employment of others. They made use of things of the disbelievers. They mounted on the mules that belonged to disbelievers whom they used to call dajjal.