Arba’in Number Four

Although I have documented through convincing arguments in Arba‘in Number 3 that it is the practice of Allah since time immemorial to destroy the one who imputes falsehood to God, I again remind the wise that what I have explained is absolutely the truth. Let him [the reference is to Hafiz Muhammad Yusuf, see the beginning of Arba‘in Number 3] beware lest he adopts the path of destruction by accepting the interpretation of some adversarial maulawi in opposition to me. And it is imperative that he should fear God against considering the arguments of the Holy Qur’an with contempt. It is clear that Allah the Exalted did not write the verse:

in vain, from which no argument could be established. Allah the Exalted is Holy and far beyond doing anything in vain. Hence, given the situation in which this Hakim [the All-Wise God] has expressed this verse and, in similar fashion, another verse whose words are:

on an occasion opportune for argumentation, we are compelled to accept that if someone falsely claims to be a Prophet or an Appointee from Allah, then he will never live up to the same [twenty-three year] period of prophethood of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. Otherwise, this argumentation would not in any way be held up as valid nor would there be established any means to make sense of it, because if someone were to impute falsehood to God and make a false claim to being the Appointee from Allah, and proceed to live up to twenty-three years without being destroyed, then a denier would undoubtedly have the right to raise this objection that since this liar—whom you acknowledge to be a liar—lived for twenty-three years or more without being destroyed, then why should we not consider your Prophet to have been like that liar? For a liar to be given a reprieve of twenty-three years clearly shows that every such false person can be given the same concession. How then would the truth of

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

become manifest upon

the people? Which arguments will be framed to believe in the fact that had the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, forged a lie against God, then he would have definitely similar afflictions of death (Surah Bani Isra’il, 17:76). [Publisher]

upon him, forged a lie against Us, We would have made him taste double punishment in life and death; that is, We would have destroyed him with great chastisement. Author Haqqah, 69:45). [Publisher]

been destroyed well within a period of twenty-three years, but if others were to forge lies against God then they could go on living for more than twenty-three years thereafter without God destroying them?

This is the very similitude of a shopkeeper saying: ‘If I am dishonest in my business or sell substandard products, or tell lies, or fail to give full measure, then lightning will suddenly strike me at that very moment. For this reason you all should have full confidence in me and entertain no doubt that I would ever sell anything defective, or short the full measure, or tell a lie. In fact, buy the goods in my store [trusting me] with your eyes closed, without [the need for] making any inquiry!’ Would people gain a sense of comfort from such senseless talk, and would anyone consider these vain words of his as evidence of his honesty? Never! We seek refuge in Allah! Such a claim can never be proof of this person’s honesty; rather, it is in one manner a way of deceiving the general public and making them inattentive. Of course, this can be upheld as evidence in two cases:

1. One is that this should have taken place several times in the presence of people whereby this individual lied about the products he sells, or weighed less, or tried to deceive in some other way, and then lightning struck him at that very instant

and nearly killed him. And such a phenomenon repeatedly occurred of lightning striking him whenever he lied or weighed less or cheated, until people became fully convinced that lightning strikes him whenever he is dishonest or tells a lie. In such a

case, his claim can certainly be used as proof because many people are witness to the fact that lightning struck when he lied.

2. The second case is that the general public experiences this phenomenon occurring whereby any shopkeeper who lies about his products, fails to give full measure, tries to deceive in any other way, or sells substandard products, is struck by lightning [as a consequence].

Keeping this example in mind, every fair-minded person has to say that the words

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

issuing forth from the mouth of the All-Knowing, All-Wise God will serve as a cogent proof only when one of the two ’[following] conditions are fulfilled by it:

1. First, God forbid, if the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, had made any false statements in the past, and Allah had given him severe punishment. The people knew it as a factual reality that if he had spoken a lie against God, he would have been punished as he was punished earlier on such and such an occasion. However, this kind of reasoning cannot be applied to the pure character of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him. Even to think in this manner about the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, is kufr [disbelief ].

2. The second way of presenting the argument is that it should be a common rule of God Almighty that whomsoever forges a lie against Him, should not be given a long reprieve and meets his destruction quickly. So, this is the reasoning that fits correctly here. Otherwise, the phrase:

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

would be taken as simply a deception by an objector, and God forbid, it

10 of 10 left today