Arba’in Number Four
Part 2
will resemble the vain talk of a shopkeeper. The conscience of those who respect the Word of God Almighty will certainly not accept at all that the phrase spoken by God
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
is so ambiguous as to have no proof supporting it.
It is patently obvious that God Almighty’s rebuking these opponents—who neither accept the prophethood of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, nor the Divine origin of the Holy Qur’an—with a statement lacking proof is merely inadequate and insufficient to satisfy even children. It is evident that the opponents and deniers will not obtain any satisfaction from it; rather, in their view this is only a claim with no supporting evidence.
How ridiculous a belief is it to say: ‘If I commit this particular sin, I will be killed’, even though tens of millions of others commit that very sin every day throughout the world but are not killed? And how repulsive an excuse is it to say that ‘God does not do anything to other liars and sinners, but that this punishment is reserved specifically for me’? It is even more puzzling that the individual making the claim does not provide any proof that he knows from previous experiences—and as witnessed by others—that whenever he commits that particular sin, he is inevitably punished. Thus, the judicious Words of God Almighty were revealed to provide conclusive arguments to the world. To think of them in this absurd manner is equal to mocking and making fun of them. You will find in the Holy Qur’an at hundreds of places that God Almighty does not spare the one who ascribes a lie to Him and punishes him in this very world and destroys him.
Look, at one place Almighty Allah says:
Meaning that one who forges a lie against Allah shall perish frustrated. And then at another place He says:
Meaning, who could be more unjust than he who forges a lie against Allah or gives the lie to His Signs? Now, it is evident that God did not leave those people alive who rejected the Word of God during the time when the Prophets of God appeared, and He destroyed them with terrible and painful punishments. Behold! What was the end of the people of Noah; the people of ‘Ad, Thamud, and Lot; and Pharaoh and the Makkan enemies of our Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him? Thus, when the people who rejected [the Prophets] received punishment in this very world, then how can the one who imputes falsehood to God escape punishment, whose name is mentioned first in this verse? Can the treatment meted out by God to the truthful and the liars be the same? And is there no punishment of God for those who attribute lies to Him?
[Publisher]
And then at one place God Almighty says:
This means that if this Prophet is a liar, he will face destruction as a consequence of his lies, but if he is truthful, you will inevitably taste some punishment, since those who commit transgressions—whether they fabricate lies or reject [the truth]—will not be helped by God.
Now look, what greater elaboration could be asked for than this, that God Almighty repeatedly says in the Holy Qur’an that the fabricator of lies against God will perish in this very world! On the contrary, the foremost evidence for God’s truthful Prophets and Appointees is that they pass away after completing their mission. They are given time to spread the faith. And in the brief lifespan of man, the most extended reprieve that can be given to a man is twenty-three years because, prophethood generally commences at the age of forty. If an additional twenty-three years are granted, those will be the best part of his life. This is why I say again and again that for the truthful ones, the extent of time given to the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, is a correct standard of measurement. It is not possible that a person, being a liar and a fabricator of lies against God, should be granted a reprieve equal to the period of the Holy Prophet’s prophethood which was twenty-three years. He would undoubtedly perish [before that].
In this regard, a friend of mine, with good intentions, had raised a point with me that the verse
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
was unique to the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, and was not applicable in the case of any other claimant of revelation; so why should we think that if someone were to forge a lie against God that he, too, shall also be destroyed? I replied that this Word of Allah is by way of presenting an argument, and just like the other arguments in support of the truthfulness of prophethood, this is another such argument as well. The truthfulness of the statement of Almighty God is validated only when a false claimant perishes. Otherwise, this statement cannot serve as a conclusive argument against a denier, nor can it serve as an argument for him. Rather, he can assert:
The reason that the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, did not die for twenty-three years is not because he was truthful, but it was because forging a lie against God is not so great a sin that God must destroy the liar in this very world; for, if it had been a sin, and the ongoing practice of Allah had established that a fabricator of lies against God is punished in this very world, then there should have been some precedents to prove it, and you accept that there is not a single such example known; on the contrary, there are many examples available of people who forged lies against God for twenty-three years—nay, longer—but they did not perish.
So now tell me, what is the reply to this objection? Suppose you say that only a Messenger who falsely claims to bring a shariah [religious law] is destroyed, but not every fabricator of lies [against God]. Then first, this claim is devoid of evidence. God did not put the condition of bringing a shariah together with forging a lie [against God]. Besides, apart from this you must also understand what shariah is. Anyone who, based on his wahi [revelations], lays down some commandments to do things and other commandments prohibiting things and establishes regulations for his people becomes a shariah-bearing Messenger. Thus, according to this definition, our opponents are still at fault because there are both permissions and prohibitions in my wahi.٭
For example, this revelation is written in Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya:
[Say to the believers to restrain their looks from na mahrams (those outside the prohibited category) and to guard their private parts and ears from unworthy acts. This is required and essential for their attainment of purification.]
In this, there is a command and a prohibition, and twenty-three years have passed since this revelation was received. Similarly, there are commandments as well as prohibitions in my wahi even now. If you say that shariah means new commandments, then this is incorrect.
Allah the Exalted says:
That is, the teachings in the Holy Qur’an are also present in the Torah. If it is said that shariah contains the fully detailed accounts of the commandments and prohibitions, then this is not correct, because if the Torah and the Holy Qur’an had included the full detail of the commandments and prohibitions, then no room would have been left for ijtihad [interpretation, exegesis of Divine Law].